Discussion Board

Does India need anti-satellite weapons?


Total 48 messages Pages < Newer  | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4   Older >
hotz
India is looking effectiveness and not precision
by hotz on Feb 09, 2010 09:00 PM

India is not focussing on precision targeting in initial stage atleast.logic dictates Its working on cost effective mass debris ejection deterrent at high velocity in space that will knock down all satellites indian or chinese in orbit.And Of course yes in the process will make space more unviable for both india and china but would serve as a very effective deterrent for our neighbor if they try to compromise our space assets indeed.China has just washed its hands of many billion dollars worth of precision research when they learned of what Indias options are in such a scenario.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Indian Reader
Chaddies
by Indian Reader on Feb 09, 2010 08:31 PM  | Hide replies

.
.
While our neighbours are acquiring ASAT capabilities, our political parties like MNS, RSS, Bajrang dal are acquiring Chaddi capabilities.




    Forward  |  Report abuse
Rajendra Aggarwala
Re: Chaddies
by Rajendra Aggarwala on Feb 10, 2010 04:06 PM
Stop indulging in making stupid statements. It was BJP that made India count internationally after coming in power for short 6 years. Congress and other parties counted for Zero even after 54 years of corrupt and worthless rule. J&K fiasco, Tibet border fiasco, lack of military and economic power and defence capabilities, and being counted as a 3rd world nation was all these parties achieved. Stop reading worthless propaganda, open your mind and eyes, and see the dangers in which the country has been pushed by Sonia-Rahul impotent sychophants in Congress. The country is again passing through a disastrous phase after the UPA came back to power by appeasing the terrorists to get muslim votes. You need to be a patriot to make this country strong, and not a slave of white skinned female or a childish boy's antics that Rahul displays daily with our idiotic media singing the tunes of the 'prince' in the modern age. Has he ever visited the troops in the Sianchen, or fighting the terrorists? Sleeping in dalits' houses only shows the imposter in him to indulge in 'acts' only to gain poor and innocents' slavery. Stop these tamashas and start building India. China and Pakistan are in deep collusion and Rahul baba and his stchophants are busy playing antics to fool the downtrodden and the ignorant, and encouraging the terrorists just to remain in power and loot the country. Wake up whosoever you are!!

Col(ret) Rajendra Aggarwala
University Faculty(ret), USA


   Forward   |   Report abuse
Rajendra Aggarwala
Re: Chaddies
by Rajendra Aggarwala on Feb 10, 2010 04:05 PM
Stop indulging in making stupid statements. It was BJP that made India count internationally after coming in power for short 6 years. Congress and other parties counted for Zero even after 54 years of corrupt and worthless rule. J&K fiasco, Tibet border fiasco, lack of military and economic power and defence capabilities, and being counted as a 3rd world nation was all these parties achieved. Stop reading worthless propaganda, open your mind and eyes, and see the dangers in which the country has been pushed by Sonia-Rahul impotent sychophants in Congress. The country is again passing through a disastrous phase after the UPA came back to power by appeasing the terrorists to get muslim votes. You need to be a patriot to make this country strong, and not a slave of white skinned female or a childish boy's antics that Rahul displays daily with our idiotic media singing the tunes of the 'prince' in the modern age. Has he ever visited the troops in the Sianchen, or fighting the terrorists? Sleeping in dalits' houses only shows the imposter in him to indulge in 'acts' only to gain poor and innocents' slavery. Stop these tamashas and start building India. China and Pakistan are in deep collusion and Rahul baba and his stchophants are busy playing antics to fool the downtrodden and the ignorant, and encouraging the terrorists just to remain in power and loot the country. Wake up whosoever you are!!

Col(ret) Rajendra Aggarwala
University Faculty(ret), USA


   Forward   |   Report abuse
mantu kumar
Selfish human being bend on destroying this earth
by mantu kumar on Feb 09, 2010 07:50 PM

There are millions of varieties of animals and plants on our earth.Area of earth that is ruled by human is almost 100%.They are forcing other species to the corner and polluting all known natural resources so much that from few years from now all air water and land will be polluted and everything that we eat drink and breath will be of highly poor quality.This is all done by the leaders of societies.Earth has limited resorces and our leaders should focus more on providing solution for consuming these resources and that to in such a manner that no resouce get polluted.Use of things which pollute nature should be phased out slowly .All human being on this earth should unite and force leaders to stop fight among themselves and force them to think about using all available natural resources in such a way that earth becomes nice place for all species and live happily.Population control,use of minimum energy( so that its production which produces pollution is minimised ),Teaching human being to limit there artificial requirement( such as new model cars, plane, building big marble houses (which requires lots of energy)and many such things to show off which puts burden on earth.
Making new weapons which destroy human being of other countries will take no country forward but will cause harm to human itself. Why not drop this harmful idea and instead compete with each other on how to make life of people better and how best we can manage our available resources to keeps pollution away

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Rajesh Bangad
a day shall come
by Rajesh Bangad on Feb 09, 2010 07:13 PM  | Hide replies

A day shall come when india shall be required to fight with China and Pakistan front a time.
and our leaders are sleeping.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
dray
Re: a day shall come
by dray on Dec 14, 2017 10:10 PM
I think this page explains it quite well with detailed information and analysis:

Why India Needs to Demonstrate Anti Satellite (ASAT) Capability - Publicly

https://www.strategicfront.org/forums/threads/why-india-needs-to-demonstrate-anti-satellite-asat-capability-p ublicly.354/


   Forward   |   'Report abuse' disabled by moderator
Slam D
its not about need
by Slam D on Feb 09, 2010 07:12 PM  | Hide replies

Can india ever have the guts to use it.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
revulagaddasreenu
Re: its not about need
by revulagaddasreenu on Feb 09, 2010 07:50 PM
we should have one ...and then pray that opportunity never arise so that we could use it...just like the nuc weapons

   Forward   |   Report abuse
dj kumar
Does India needs ASAT
by dj kumar on Feb 09, 2010 06:30 PM

Yes India needs ASAT capabilities ASAP because the world (read US n China, possibly including Russia) is fast moving to restrict this capability to themselves by creating ridiculous laws n treaties (similar to NPT n CTBT). If India miss this chance then again we have to fight against the discriminating world laws. AND offence is the best defence, if 2morow China knocks down our sattelite we shud be in position to counter that

    Forward  |  Report abuse
SK NAPE
Don't Worry
by SK NAPE on Feb 09, 2010 06:28 PM  | Hide replies

Don't worry my fellow Indians.MMS,Chidu,PM, SoNji are closely monitoring the situation as always. God save my country..

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Ary Doriz
Re: Don't Worry
by Ary Doriz on Feb 10, 2010 12:37 AM
And no Kargil has happened yet.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
SK NAPE
Corruption
by SK NAPE on Feb 09, 2010 06:25 PM

Don't worry my fellow indians, MMS, Chiddu, PM and others so called leaders are monitoring this situation closely as always.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Total 48 messages Pages: < Newer  | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4   Older >
Write a message