Discussion Board

Why Bengal CM did not resign


Total 163 messages Pages | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5   Older >   >>
bray
The Root of Nandigram Uprising.
by bray on Mar 22, 2007 09:50 PM  | Hide replies

To understand the brutal assaults by West Bengal police and CPI (M)'s hired goons on 14th March'07 on people of Nandigram block-I, one has to go back 3-4 months in the densely populated area near the Bay of Bengal. The state government wanted to acquire nearly 2000 acres of arable land including some 200 temples, mosques, schools and homestead plots to hand over to the Salim Group of Indonesia for setting up a chemical hub and SEZ. This incensed the farming and fishing community, as they did not have any other skills and with compensation money would not get any land to buy in equally densely populated blocks I & II. Their sentiments were exploited by opposition parties, particularly Trinamool Congress, led by firebrand Mamata Banerjee. The first uprising occurred on 3rd January, this yea, on a rumour that some ooficers had arrived at a panchayet office to start the acquisition. The villagers went amok, cut roads, bridges and culverts on main roads to resist the advance of the police. They raised an outcry against local leaders and cadres of the CPI (M), as a notification was found, issued by the Haldia Development Authority, headed by the local MP, Lakshman Seth. Inter and intra-party clashes began with bombs, bullets and grenades, leaving at least half a dozen villagers dead. The Chief Minister admitted an administrative error in issuing the notification and promised not to acquire any land in Nandigram for industries, if the people did not want. However, over two months passed and villagers did not allow CPI (M) goons and cadres return home and rebuild their support base. Over 2000 of them were out of their homes and they exerted pressure on Mr. Seth to do something. The Chief Minister was misled by some officers and party leaders to believe that there was administration in the troubled area and the police could not enter to restore law and order. The CM walked into the trap and gave his consent to launch a massive police offensive to break the resistance. Local CPI (M) leaders took advantage of the situation and some 300 of them entered with police contingents on the 14th and indulged in an orgy of firing, raping women and killing school-going children. Although the official death-toll is 14, local people put it at over a thousand. The CBI team which gave its report to Kolkata High Court on 22nd March will reveal the extent of brutality, being compared with General O'Dyer's killing of over a hundred civilians in a walled Amritsar garden, Jalianwala Bagh on 13th April 1919, in protest of which Rabindranath Tagore returned knighthood to the British Raj in Delhi.
In my opinion, since the Chief Minister has admitted his mistake in under-estimating the ground-swell and resistance by the people of Nandigram, he should resign, owning moral responsibility. In addition, the State or Central Police must arrest key CPI (M) leaders, like Benoy Konar and Lakshman Seth who threatened dire action to avenge expulsion of their partymen and openly instigated violence. But will Bengal's blindly loyal police do these or a shameless CM tender resignation? This was not his first mistake and administrative failure but third, beginning with similar police offensive on farmers of Singur on 28th November, last year, followed by the issue of a notification by HDA which set ablaze Nandigram in the first week of January, this year?

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Uttamkumar
RE:The Root of Nandigram Uprising.
by Uttamkumar on Mar 23, 2007 08:57 AM
20,000 acres, not merely 2,000 acres, they wanted to acquire.

If Buddhadev is a human being and human feeling, he MUST RESIGN.


   Forward   |   Report abuse
Shampa Daripa
RE:The Root of Nandigram Uprising.
by Shampa Daripa on Apr 25, 2007 06:56 PM
IN HUMAN MUDERER CM MUST RESIGN

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Shampa Daripa
RE:[object]
by Shampa Daripa on Apr 25, 2007 06:58 PM
Shameless, Murderer CM Must RESIGN

SHAMPA DARIPA
BANKURA

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Raj Aryan
Politician's chair
by Raj Aryan on Mar 22, 2007 06:10 PM

In recent times which political leader has resigned on his own??? Rememeber Sibu Sorren who was central minister & was on run for more than a month.
I wonder what all the people who were asking Modi's resignation after Gujrat riots say about Nandigram Genocide??????????
Bottom line is for all the politicians the chair is the most important thing to them. They can do anything for them.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Raj  Shekhar
buddha is not yet budda
by Raj Shekhar on Mar 22, 2007 05:23 PM

WB CM is not resigning as he as not complete 25 years like Mr.Basu (former CM)

    Forward  |  Report abuse
allen
Plz
by allen on Mar 22, 2007 01:28 PM

Rediff has become d propaganda machine of sic ppl!!!!..using abuses.. no quality.. wrting garbage... the whole purpose of discussion is lost ..I request rediff to start a cleansing process... the moderator is either too slow or ignorant. Make this a platform for exchanging knowledge ( not filth )


    Forward  |  Report abuse
Dimension Four
Allowed to be continued for Rashtra Dharma
by Dimension Four on Mar 22, 2007 10:57 AM

We are not over here to take the resignation of the elected representative but we want them to behave properly looking forward for the people. Does Red party become ostrich who can't understand reality. It is high time they shold leave to interfere in the life of the citizen and do some proper governance work. Let start giving road permit to the transport operator (auto, rickshaw, bus etc) who are plying on the permit on CPM and not on moter vehicle department

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Gautam Sinha
Buddha didnt resign for left but will left learn?
by Gautam Sinha on Mar 22, 2007 10:13 AM

Buddha did not resign to avoid embarassment for his party. But will the perty learn? For years the left has encouraged immigrants from Bangladesh of a particular community with a 'victim' mindset into India and allowed them to systematically set up parallel systems. True the left did a much better job at integrating them into mainstream than other parties but also allowed them to remain in that ghetto mindset. The results are obvious. Their clandestine operations and narrow mindset are taking a toll on the state. BSF and intellegence had always warned of WB being a vulnerable state but the left never learned and always encouraged them. It is rather obvious why policemen did not stop arms coming in, possibly they were discouraged from doing so on earlier occassions when leftists were allowing this covertly. Left will never learn from its mistakes. It is a known perception that areas like Khiderpore/Garden Reach right inside Kolkata are ruled openly by these criminal elements with adequate patronage from the left. Will the left now wake up?

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator. | Hide replies
Message deleted by moderator
Uttamkumar
MAOIST in INDIA and NEPAL
by Uttamkumar on Mar 22, 2007 09:34 AM


Maoists in INDIA are terrorist defined by CPM and Maoists in Nepal is nationalist and took part in
the Govt there with strong back up and support of India's communists (terrorists).

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Total 163 messages Pages: | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5   Older >   >>
Write a message