I could understand your point about film writeups anf analysis. The subjected bias involved in assessing some films but the article is too long. The person who you mentioned is Baradwag Ranjan, he has his thought process and has certain fixed views about a certain grammar of a particular film, so why you feel so wrong about it? There have been more moments where he analysed a few commercial films rather merciselessly. I could not get the point of this article..is it to diss South Indian films or the reviewers who watch them?