"Don't remember the last comedy that was critically acclaimed"
You dont have good memory. Eat more horlicks. Ishqiya series, Tere Bin Laden, Hera Pheri, Munnabhai series, Khosla ka Ghosla, 3 idiots, OMG, Bheja Fry etc. Even the ridiculous Partner is better.
You are doing good whatever you are getting.comedy is ur stength. (You completely overshadowd Saif in humshakal).Now try few serious roles and check ur luck.
Some critics loved it - We want the names. They should be checked for their mental stability.
Don't remember the last comedy that was critically acclaimed :- Dedh Ishqiya which released earlier this year had better laughs and the jokes were pretty intelligent and it got immense critical acclaim. Though not a classic, but definitely better than the moronic Humshakals.