Without revealing the suspense all I can say this is an intriguing suspense drama which is very rare in hindi cinema.. The film is dark,complex psychological yet there is layers of emotions which make it more compelling.. Aamir Khan again proved that he is the only superstar actor who believes in quality films that are beyond regular mainstream ideas..Nawazuddin Siddqui is a fine actor & here he rocked as usual..(It is very difficult to not reveal the plot yet write about this film)
Re: An intriguing suspense drama
by arnab bhattacharya on Nov 30, 2012 11:51 AM
It seems Talaash is a very good cinema..In India very good films are not accepted at a large scale..
which doesn't describe the plot (i kno it's suspense, but m not saying climax jst the plot the ways it's in trailor) and focuses on only one scene (check first paragraph)it means, the critique has been handsomely paid. wish i cud be critique too... and yes...as the review mentions (between the lines) there's not plot at all
Re: when there is review about a movie
by Maihoon Don on Nov 30, 2012 11:52 AM
all reviews are giving 3 stars blindly without even telling what is the story of the movie. but the viewer comments on all websites are saying that the movie is boring and disappointing.
Re: Re: when there is review about a movie
by arnab bhattacharya on Nov 30, 2012 12:03 PM
boring doesnt make it a bad film.. and in a suspense film one shouldn't reveal the story
Re: Re: Re: when there is review about a movie
by Maihoon Don on Nov 30, 2012 12:13 PM
what happened to aamir who was obsessed with box office success????
Re: Re: when there is review about a movie
by abhinandan chatterjee on Nov 30, 2012 12:10 PM
reviewers have given a 3 and 1/2 star(min)even max 5 to this movie. As far as other aspects of filmmaking are concerned, better not comment with such a myopic view.
a movie may be good or bad. but it is extremely unethical to reveal the suspense or climax of a movie.this is purely infringement of intellectual property.
they are giving 3 stars to this movie based on aamir's past movie. from audience reactions looks to be a badly made movie. suspense movies do not run nowadays. only masala movies work at box office as people go for a laugh during the weekends after a hectic week.
exceptions are ra.one, don2 and JTHJ. Only SRK can go against the norm and create superhits.
Re: Reviewers are biased
by Ranjinee Sengupta on Nov 30, 2012 11:49 AM
Srk has never gone against the norms and given suerhits.. all his typical commercial films are superhits
Re: Re: Reviewers are biased
by Maihoon Don on Nov 30, 2012 11:51 AM
in the age of slapstick comedies, he gave one superhero, one thriller and one romantic movie. is that not going against the norm?
you have not seen movies like swades, paheli, chk_de, right?
Re: Re: Re: Reviewers are biased
by arnab bhattacharya on Nov 30, 2012 11:54 AM
Dude Ra One,Don 2 were pathetic films... n check RDB,TZP,DCH even Lagaan,sarfarosh were not ur typical commercial films..
Re: Re: Re: Re: Reviewers are biased
by saleem khan on Nov 30, 2012 01:57 PM
sharukh all films were non sense. first of all he doesn't have acting skills. aamir is real king of romance. every movie has diffrent story. sharukh & salman are famous for making nonsense films. i rate aamir 100 % perfectionist . aamir is real king of marketing the films. Go & watch talaash & comment .Don't comment this nonsense statements on aamir khan.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Reviewers are biased
by Maihoon Don on Nov 30, 2012 12:03 PM
You are a blind hater of SRK so its a waste of time responding to dumbos like you. you did not even understand the context of my original message.
Re: Re: Re: Reviewers are biased
by harish balasubramanian on Nov 30, 2012 12:00 PM
Well said mate!! infact the truth of the matter is of all the films that our friend arnab mentioned,RDB,LAGAAN. 3 IDIOTS AND now even Talaash was offered to SRK first!!!!!
Re: Reviewers are biased
by rari on Nov 30, 2012 12:10 PM
see the power of srk...for a discussion forum which is supposed to discus about amir khan's movie, people are talking more about SRK...you can hate or love srk but cannot ignore him
Re: Re: Reviewers are biased
by saleem khan on Nov 30, 2012 01:53 PM
aamir is real king of bollywood. sharukh doesn't know acting at all. talaash is block blaster movie.
Talaash - Finally after 3 years Aamir comes back in a lead role in movie and hence with huge expectations I went for the movie of one my favourite actor, but came out slightly disappointed. There was no faltering the acting skills of Aamir, he has again done brilliantly and even the two leading ladies and spporting cast does act very well, but something to falter a bit was the story itself mainly the suspense and the way it handled in the second half. If you are bit brainy types u will figure out the suspense slightly before it happens which dissolves the purpose of the movie. It is a very sincere effort combined with brilliant acting and offcourse not a usual masala entertainer at all. Summary - Brilliant acting in a different genre of movies, quite a few good moments but bit on the slower side at times, wish the movie was more tightly gripped and suspense revealed in slightly better manner in the second half. I would rate Kahani better than Talaash, if it was not Aamir khan in this movie it would have gone unnoticed, masses might reject the movie and classes will have a divide.
