I can provide real life script if you need which will be a box office hit about Indian families and that happens around it. If you need, I am not from film background, but I have an excellent script that can be made as a movie. True life of a educated person suffering in married life and also in his career.
This film may be scientifically correct about bipolar depression but second half is slow.To be honest,I looked only at exit gate.Maybe mental people can behave like that but no thrill or suspense.No empathy is created towards the character by the director.Just one man getting diagnosed by bipolar disorder and beating everybody including his friend.Just one or two scenes in second half was realistic and moving.The melodrama was too much.Can there be a subtle approach on this sensitive mental issue.
I watched the movie a week back and still feeling depressed!!
It seems Pavithra was paid handsomely to write a positive review!!She gave such good rating for Mounaguru which was correct!!But this is disappointing.How can she ignore the second half?
the climax though medically correct(since he has extreme form of depression),the way it is presented is highly regretted!!
Re: Scientifically correct but still disturbing portrait
by John Patrick on Apr 23, 2012 05:44 AM
This is not Scientifically correct.This is wrong. Bi-polar patients do not have illucinations. Patients who have Schizophrenia are the ones who have illucinations. Aishwarya Rajinikanth Dhanush should have consulted a Medical expert first about this. This film is totally wrong. And I am amazed that in India people are treated with Shock treatment. This is Bullshit. These are patients that have deficiency in chemical metabolism that causes this. Stress can cause this, and so many things. Schizophrenia is diagnozed as family hereditory. This movie is giving wrong medical diagnosis. Moreover, consult doctors first before you make a movie and I am sorry I would not agree with this. I wrote a review after watching the movie in more details but could not save it, so I am writing here. Aishwarya Dhanush you are wrong totally about bi-polar. Moreover, in India they call it as Mental Health and here they do not want patient to be called that they are in that department instead they call it with more respect saying it as Behavioral Health. There is a difference how you all treat patients and respect a patient. But, I would disagree with the diagnosis of bi-polar patients and schizophrenia patients. Know the difference. Research first before taking the movie. Moreover, the guy who acts as a doctor cannot even explain it properly. Sad. Moreover, it is controllable through medication by explaining to the patient their illness. India needs to go a long long way.
l read rediff reviews , from pavithira srinivasan i compelled to dislike , why ? she or he is wrote a 3 not a movie i think she is ate 3 apples from the press meet of 3, if u don't belive please read her or his last para "aishwarya dhanush has chosen to present to take on romance that is appealing in its freshness"- sema comedy , english therinhtaa ippadiyaa ice vaikirathu, in our country english writing journalists are more powerful because they are portrating awkword words in a beautiful word. straightaa sollamey yeppadi sister or brother ippadi article present pannureenga ...marketil duplicate product vikaravanga aasai kaati sollura words vendaanga -with reguest sk , madurai
es ... dhanush is a super actor , but selvaragavan now aishwarya always portrying always mentally retraded person. why this kolaveri? from kadahl konden to mayakkam yenna dhanush crossed several films, but commericially sucess films are action oriented pollathavan , mappillai, uthamaputhiran, aadukalam etc . handsome 28 year old dhaunsh both the directors making awkwardely. he is drinking beer, using bad words, beating wife unnecessarily , please don't justify just like doctors he is bipological disorder . we know both directors are aiming national award, but plz remember decent mental character(balu mahindraa's moondram pirai) only gets both national and audience recognition. in moondrambirai u can't find kamal kaasan singing or beating sridevi with beer bottle. next story we don't know meaning of "3", but in tamil pattai namam. yes , we are not expecting this story for commercial dhanu's appeal. you (aishwarya) made again big mistake, dhanush is matured actor having two childs all people know his bio, without mustacle(meesai) and oily face how we accept he is school going boy ? you may justify love as you wish ..as a female director are you coming from hollywood? plz remember you are from respectable family, you are added flavour of klssing ,drinking alchocal is vanishing the fame fame of u and dhanush. i never compromise with story, what is the intention to make a movie? to get relaxation , are u assure us? every shot crying or rounding the adolocent girl is
yes ... dhanush is a super actor , but selvaragavan now aishwarya always portrying always mentally retraded person. why this kolaveri? from kadahl konden to mayakkam yenna dhanush crossed several films, but commericially sucess films are action oriented pollathavan , mappillai, uthamaputhiran, aadukalam etc . handsome 28 year old dhaunsh both the directors making awkwardely. he is drinking beer, using bad words, beating wife unnecessarily , please don't justify just like doctors he is bipological disorder . we know both directors are aiming national award, but plz remember decent mental character(balu mahindraa's moondram pirai) only gets both national and audience recognition. in moondrambirai u can't find kamal kaasan singing or beating sridevi with beer bottle. next story we don't know meaning of "3", but in tamil pattai namam. yes , we are not expecting this story for commercial dhanu's appeal. you (aishwarya) made again big mistake, dhanush is matured actor having two childs all people know his bio, without mustacle(meesai) and oily face how we accept he is school going boy ? you may justify love as you wish ..as a female director are you coming from hollywood? plz remember you are from respectable family, you are added flavour of klssing ,drinking alchocal is vanishing the fame fame of u and dhanush. i never compromise with story, what is the intention to make a movie? to get relaxation , are u assure us? every shot crying or rounding the adolocent girl is
Yes ... dhanush is a super actor , but selvaragavan now aishwarya always portrying always mentally retraded person. why this kolaveri? from kadahl konden to mayakkam yenna dhanush crossed several films, but commericially sucess films are action oriented pollathavan , mappillai, uthamaputhiran, aadukalam etc . handsome 28 year old dhaunsh both the directors making awkwardely. he is drinking beer, using bad words, beating wife unnecessarily , please don't justify just like doctors he is bipological disorder . we know both directors are aiming national award, but plz remember decent mental character(balu mahindraa's moondram pirai) only gets both national and audience recognition. in moondrambirai u can't find kamal kaasan singing or beating sridevi with beer bottle. next story we don't know meaning of "3", but in tamil pattai namam. yes , we are not expecting this story for commercial dhanu's appeal. you (aishwarya) made again big mistake, dhanush is matured actor having two childs all people know his bio, without mustacle(meesai) and oily face how we accept he is school going boy ? you may justify love as you wish ..as a female director are you coming from hollywood? plz remember you are from respectable family, you are added flavour of klssing ,drinking alchocal is vanishing the fame fame of u and dhanush. i never compromise with story, what is the intention to make a movie? to get relaxation , are u assure us? every shot crying or rounding the adolocent girl is
