Re: Re: Mungaru Male
by chandran on Dec 18, 2012 12:06 PM
@madhi Egzatly correct macchha.Copied from international tracks and claimed to be international one.
'Adiye' is a complete copy of 'The trouble with love is' by Kelly Clarkson...youtube it. Yes, the track is truly audacious. Audacious to blatantly copy a popular track and think that no one is going to find out about it.
Re: 'Adiye' is a complete copy
by siddharth msi on Dec 18, 2012 03:19 AM
I visited the linked youtube page and saw/heard the song. Well, there is some resemblance but you should know what's complete copy and what's inspired!
Re: 'Adiye' is a complete copy
by zack on Dec 18, 2012 08:03 AM
Harris jayaranee fan ah nee...inthe maathri blues songg 1000 mela irukku...anaa ithu athu ille...blues type song , not copy...tune kedda ve totally diffrent....
Re: Re: 'Adiye' is a complete copy
by Raj Rag on Dec 18, 2012 02:08 PM
Same genre doesn't mean it has to have the same notes as well. Adiye has the exact same notes as 'The trouble with love is'! Anyone with the faintest iota of musical sense would know that upon first hearing. It is a blatant copy and you don't need to admit it for it to be true. Good luck trying to delude yourself!
Re: 'Adiye' is a complete copy
by rich on Dec 18, 2012 09:10 AM
ridiculous! its no where the same tune! just because both are in the blues genre dosent mean its copied! the problem with many people is that they try to show how much they know about music by resorting to such crude and irresponsible remarks!
Re: Re: 'Adiye' is a complete copy
by Raj Rag on Dec 18, 2012 02:07 PM
Same genre doesn't mean it has to have the same notes as well. Adiye has the exact same notes as 'The trouble with love is'! Anyone with the faintest iota of musical sense would know that upon first hearing. It is a blatant copy and you don't need to admit it for it to be true. Good luck trying to delude yourself!
Re: Re: Re: 'Adiye' is a complete copy
by Anjani on Dec 18, 2012 03:35 PM
@rich- u r right. Same genre songs. Some day someone will say all Zazz based songs have been copied from each others.Naysayers...Hunh!!
Re: Re: Re: 'Adiye' is a complete copy
by Raj Rag on Dec 18, 2012 11:12 PM
It has the same notes (Raag) as well. If you repeat 'The trouble wiiiith...the trouble wiiiith...the trouble with love is', it will correspond to 'Adiye...adiye...enga nee kootipora' - not to mention all the blues chorus in the background, the base rhythm, the claps, the tempo - all that is an exact replica! Same genre songs don't have all these things as an exact replica. A Ray Charles or a Stevie Wonder would kill themselves before copying so many elements from another song.
Seeing a Positive Feedback from Pavithra and deservingly so. Apparently looking at her comments would look as though she was a pessimist but this time A pessimist herself coud not downgrade it any lower. 3.5 * from Pavithra means 5/5. This Album truly stands out and could become the greatest albums of the decade. Just that it needs more counts of Listening, as Tunes are seemingly new and not copied/influenced/reused like other Musicians.
Re: Its divine
by kishore kumar on Dec 18, 2012 01:05 AM
nothing new about Magudi :).. what a joke it is, atleast in the past 25 years I have not heard a song like this. Pavithra can you tell what does it resemble to??
