Not a very good film and not a very bad film either , it could have been much much better , but a very good one for kids ..........and also teaches us a lot of family values......
every 1 hr if you come with negative points ,you loose your own credibility.I am not a fan of srk,but the way he gives all he has for the work he is involved is very inspiring.people here portray him very wrongly,after so many years of marriage he has respected his wife religion and let children learn faith of both parents,how he can be communal.you want movie to be flop and lose money ,what kind of laxmi puja you are doing
Re: Re: harder you try ,more doubt you imply
by sushant aggarwal on Oct 28, 2011 10:24 AM
i too agree with you... atleast SRK has the guts to try smthng new everytime .... be it RNBDJ, Billu, Swades, Don and now RA.one :)
I have been continuously following most of the movie reviews done by Rediff. Never before i came across any review campaign like this, that too negative. I also remember (hopes that other rediff readers also remembers), rediff always used to glorify all the movies of sharukh khan, but why this change now. Dear rediff, all i have to say is your objective will be definitely doubted for: you should also remember the fact that every movie which is made has herculean effort behind it, quite a lot of people have their livelihood because of that.
.. and if you think people are not going for the movies rather reading your reviews, please visit any of the theaters having the Ra.One and checkout the crowd !.
Disclaimer : I am not a Sharukh khan fan, just like movies, and always think about the effort behind that..
Re: Dear rediff .. why
by raj tanuja on Oct 28, 2011 10:52 AM
Notonly rediff, reviews from all the other leading portals too say the same story. Those efforts which cannot effectively communicating with the viewer always ends in bitter results! This is the history of even movies across the world! He invested huge money in the movie is not at all a reason. Technologically and storywise the movie was not up to the marks. Even comparing with 'ROBOT'. The collections also started dropping now. However, this will never give loss of money to King Khan as he is a good marketing man, & already succefully collected money from various rights! Hope we will realise his real potential and will work for good movies hereafter than this nonsense movies!!!
Re: Dear rediff .. why
by Chinmaya Mishra on Oct 28, 2011 11:07 AM
Effort is their. But use that amount and effort in a right way so that it make a sense. Using effort for bad is not going to give any gain.
Re: Dear rediff .. why
by Akki baba on Oct 28, 2011 11:23 AM
diot movie has opened well bcoz of expectations....see the collections from monday...it will crash in one week only.....even tmk..opened well.super duper flop movie
Re: Dear rediff .. why
by Bhupathy on Oct 28, 2011 12:27 PM
Dear Saisuresh Sivasamy,
I totally agree with Rithesh, Please give logical critisim to RA One, Your comments about the Ra One seems to be very personal and has no logic. We need to appreciate the effort, labour, pain taken by Shahrukh to take Hindi Movie making to the next level. Do we need to be always such low level and keep doing the same Themes without any technological improvements. Shahrukh is trying to change this old medivial attitude of Bollywood movies to the next level, even his bitter foes and competitors like Aamir & Salman have wished him luck as they do see his hardwork and effort put into this film. Your Sour and incompetent review shows that you are a hard core Tamilian not indian who should accept Hindi as their National Language. Please accept this belief as Indian first and Tamilian later. All your negatives about this movie shows more of you personal Vibe as Shahrukh has made some commedy about Tamil speaking person and accent of tamilian. thats too bad, Please grow up.
Re: Dear rediff .. why
by Bhupathy on Oct 28, 2011 12:28 PM
Dear Saisuresh Sivasamy,
I totally agree with Rithesh, Please give logical critisim to RA One, Your comments about the Ra One seems to be very personal and has no logic. We need to appreciate the effort, labour, pain taken by Shahrukh to take Hindi Movie making to the next level. Do we need to be always such low level and keep doing the same Themes without any technological improvements. Shahrukh is trying to change this old medivial attitude of Bollywood movies to the next level, even his bitter foes and competitors like Aamir & Salman have wished him luck as they do see his hardwork and effort put into this film. Your Sour and incompetent review shows that you are a hard core Tamilian not indian who should accept Hindi as their National Language. Please accept this belief as Indian first and Tamilian later. All your negatives about this movie shows more of you personal Vibe as Shahrukh has made some commedy about Tamil speaking person and accent of tamilian. thats too bad, Please grow up.
Saisuresh Sivaswamy - first things first. You are NOT a "Tamilian" as you would like to call yourself. Second, no one is comparing Ra.One to Robot (other than you, that is). Third, no one is comparing SRK to Rajni. That would be like comparing day and night. Literally. Fourth, in north India, people do not worship people. No matter whether he is SRK or Big B. So, as you said, they can fail too if they do not deliver what the audience likes. No one is free (unemployed) like Tamilians to camp out constipated for days for advanced booking so before the movie opens, it has made more than what the producers spent. Get it?
Re: Weirdo
by KHALIL AHAMAD on Oct 28, 2011 10:43 AM
very good u taught saisuresh a good lesson, saisuresh calling yourself a tamilian proves that u r not among indians.
I mean how many bad reviews will you publish of a movie. Review has to be once and thats it. I hope SRK takes Rediff to court, just like Digvijay took some guys for extra defamation. it looks like Rediff is getting personal with SRK,,,,
Ra one is a good movie, one can watch this movie time and again. I do not know why media is against this movie only taran adarsh review is in favour of this movie, he did the same for bodyGuard as well. It look like he only understands public mood .
Re: Rediff reviews always misleads
by raj tanuja on Oct 28, 2011 10:54 AM
Notonly rediff, reviews from all the other leading portals too say the same story. Those efforts which cannot effectively communicating with the viewer always ends in bitter results! This is the history of even movies across the world! He invested huge money in the movie is not at all a reason. Technologically and storywise the movie was not up to the marks. Even comparing with 'ROBOT'. The collections also started dropping now. However, this will never give loss of money to King Khan as he is a good marketing man, & already succefully collected money from various rights! Hope he will realise his real potential and will work for good movies hereafter than this nonsense movies!!!
