What the hell is this review all about? I feel they gave the review to a fresher just to give him a feel of how te industry works...and then it went through multiple trimmings....eventually leaving nothing at all. I have never seen a more pathetic and juvenile review.
Re: Review standards of rediff plumbing newer depths everyday
by Nikhil Kumar on Oct 01, 2010 02:38 PM
Well said dude! These reviewers not only do not recognise the hardwork of the musicians but usually they undermine their work by writing pathetic reviews like these. Especially rediff!
Absolutely nonsense. Most of the time, the reviewer talks about the placement of the tracks. Does he remember that the listener can skip forward to the tracks that he wants? Instead of reviewing each track properly, this reviewer wastes time in inane things. Only 3 tracks were reviewed properly here.
On the album, its one of Rahman's better albums this year after Raavan, Robot and Vinnaithandi Varuvaya (Tamil). The Tamil one wins but Jhoota Hi Sahi is second in the list followed by Raavan and Robot. Despite the criticism, all these albums have grown on the listeners and many are still listening to Raavan, Robot, Vinnaithandi Varuvaya, etc. Same with JHS, which people will continue to listen. Even Rahman's so called average songs stays on our playlist for a very long time.
Re: Re: top 5 music albums in 2010 (bollywood )
by kapil siddhu on Sep 30, 2010 10:09 AM
its my choice as far as melody is concerned. u cn also post ur comments n choices here(if u hv interest n knowledge of music), its absolutely free
Rediff needs to seriously relook at their band of writers...this writer is not clear in what he wants to convey...ends up trashing some genuinely great songs. Finally ends up giving 3.5 out of 5 , all the while saying that there are only 2 songs that he likes. Pathetic review.
i am sorry but the review is all flawed.i have never seen any review which finds fault with the order of the songs of the album?since when did the order of songs make it a hit or dud?
as for the music,i think its the best of the year so far!arr rocks and how!!!! being a Guitaristmyself, i havent seen anyone else attempt Jazz in mainstream cinema with such success!Kudos to arr for his effort!
Re: lousy review
by K Anjani on Sep 29, 2010 09:19 PM
U r acbsolutely correct!!!!! y don't these reviewers pack their bags and let the audience ( us) decide what is good and what is bad.....this is one of the best of Rahman...And as far as Mr. Abhishek's profoundity is concerned, i have some clear doubts. Do you really have a sense of music??? Please check.
Re: Re: lousy review
by kannan krishnan on Sep 30, 2010 12:01 PM
Same crap repeated for every ARR movie Song grows in you,song makes you grow,listen many times This is his best Same repeated All hype All his over rated music flopped except Tamil Vinnai Thandi Varuvayya Even donkeys bray if you go on listening will grow on you!!!!