For reviewing even good southern movies rediff gives half star give 1 star or 2.but utter flop movie like given 3.i defentely know this film is copied from any hollywood movie sure is any one knows the name?
Re: rediff must change
by Vijaykant on Oct 24, 2010 11:26 PM
This is not a movie review, but the review of the music... If you're getting bored of fighting borthie-southie orientations, lets have a bloodbath on whether rediff should review movies or music as well....
the music is a flop show just becaz bachchan's clan stood mr bansali ur music is bakbas the moive is super flop show both look dum specially ash fully plastic smile & all that
Re: super flop
by sameer on Oct 27, 2010 09:11 AM
if u hate ash , u have no right to tell the music is bad , THE MOVIE IS TOP IN THE CHARTS AFTER THE RELEASE , u will see this movie being super hit , ash get all awards including national awards , reserve ur commments until the movie release
God! Why Hrithik? I cant watch Hrithik in these kinds of roles. He is the only guy who looks like a HERO material. It is like watching Arnold Schwarzenegger or Jackie Chan sitting paralyzed in a wheel chair. Just cant imagine. I m not interested to see this movie at all(not that it matters). On a second thought, Abhishek would have been a good fit for this role along with his wife. He and his wife can keep churning disasters. LOL! :o)
plz concentrate on direction. the music by u in guzaarish is a huge disappointment whn compared to the outstanding KHAMOSHI n HDDCS. even saawaria's music ws better than guzaarish.
The imagery is a straight lift from Sea Inside....the shots are all similar...i can say even without seeing Guzaarish that it's a straight lift from Sea Inside...Shame on you Mr.Bhansali
Re: even the visuals are not original
by sunita on Oct 22, 2010 07:33 PM
this is a problem, u know evrything evn before u have seen the movie! u make sure you visit this link and pass judgements. This is how u kill most movies thru ur hate campaign and prejudiced mind. If you dont wish to see the movie dont see it, Why even waste your time here?
Re: Re: even the visuals are not original
by Yoo Hoo on Oct 23, 2010 11:39 AM
everyone has a right to express opinion. This is India not Russia. You dont want to pay heed to his opinion thats upto you. You have no business to tell him he cant be here. You dont want to read so you can opt out of here. And Jayaram is 100 percent right. This film lacks punch....maybe the punch should be on SLB's face for taking a heroine who has no acting skills. Just plastic and artificial expressions
Re: even the visuals are not original
by balan k on Oct 23, 2010 02:40 AM
I agree with Jayaram ....why can't our Indian Directors create a movie on their own and let the Hollywood or other Foreign movie directors to copy from our movies ???
Re: Re: even the visuals are not original
by Guruprasad N on Oct 23, 2010 11:19 AM
It is true that indian directors copy. But I think people try to think everything is a copy. Sarkar and Godfather For Eg. father-son and gangster. This is all that is common between the 2. But everybody started saying this is GodFather. Come-on grow up. Movie is all about screenplay and which was original in Sarkar and even the story back-drop can easily be said to be inspired by Mumbai politics and still these hollywood fans complain! ( I know that before the movie RGV writes saying as numerous film-makers he was inspired by GodFather as well ; That show's that he is humble. Watching and getting inspiration and following the best practices from anywhere should be welcome. They should not replicate the screenplay scene by scene. i.e. Cheating. Hollywood fans in India should grow up and try to appreciate inidan work which has originality.
