The movie is not even a remote copy of phone booth.... rediff caught this time.. rediff din't pay its critic to buy cinema ticket it seems..so he/she is writing on assumption..LOL...height of poor journalism.. Some years back in UK, one author took a book critic to court coz he wrote the review without reading the book..
Re: critic has not seen this movie or phone booth
by amit subburaja on Oct 16, 2010 03:42 PM
Also, critic says 16 dec was better than tango charlie..this itself shows the taste n knowledge of this critic
When greats like Javed Akhtar pleaded to the production houses to encourage and take their chances on young talented script writers and lyricist it was a very very serious warning about lack of talent in bollywood.
The results could be seen in string of flops being churned out year after year. Time for Bollywood to look outside the imaginary glossy world and brush up its creative talent if any.
casting is poor flop director going sanjay gupta way... kangna looks like host of laughter challenge rather than a reporter movie is unintentional comedy like rgv ki aag and rudraksh
I think the critic is a sick person. Knock Out is definitely one of the most engaging, action packed and international class film made in Indian Cinema. Sanjay Dutt proves time and again that he is one of the most natural actors in Indian film industry and his personality is definitely at par with most of the hollywood actors. The problem with some of our Indian audience is that they r still not fed up with crap films made by sick film makers like karan johar and yash raj's. Our audience needs to grow up and accept that Knock Out was a hollywood class film with no songs and brilliant performances by two great actors like Sanjay Dutt and Irfan Khan. It is definitely a different film and not conventional masala hindi film like dabangg. And people who think that Knock Out went overboard with its script should not forget that southie Rajini kanth's film where 100 % of the film is absolute crap. I would suggest the sensible people to go and watch Knock Out !!
Re: One of the best movies so far !!
by Sriram Govindarajan on Oct 17, 2010 02:09 PM
We make films on original scripts unlike you who always pliagarise scripts...We do credit the original if we go for remake unlike you...so the film robot is completely original with the script being written 10 years back...How can you stand a blatant copy of phone booth and say its a great movie...
I think the critic is a sick person. Knock Out is definitely one of the most engaging, action packed and international class film made in Indian Cinema. Sanjay Dutt proves time and again that he is one of the most natural actors in Indian film industry and his personality is definitely at par with most of the hollywood actors. The problem with some of our Indian audience is that they r still not fed up with crap films made by sick film makers like karan johar and yash raj's. Our audience needs to grow up and accept that Knock Out was a hollywood class film with no songs and brilliant performances by two great actors like Sanjay Dutt and Irfan Khan. It is definitely a different film and not conventional masala hindi film like dabangg. And people who think that Knock Out went overboard with its script should not forget that southie Rajini kanth's film where 100 % of the film is absolute crap. I would suggest the sensible people to go and watch Knock Out !!
