"The solution Priyan offers to the crisis, however, is much too ridiculous and kills the realism soon enough"
You mean to say MNIK and the way the whole thing was made was not ridiculous ? You mean to say it is very realistic that an Asperger's patient walks all the way to meet the american president, on the way saving many ppl from floods and whatnots and ultimately meets him also ?
You mean to say as in Kuch Kuch hota hain where the guy gets married and has a kid who is around 7 or 8 years old and still the lady is unmarried and then just before her marriage she decides to marry him is very realistic ?
I rmember when an SRK movie was released the review by Raja Sen (who else!) read "as much as it may sound impossible, but what the heck, even Independence Day sounded so, but the movie was just out of this world."
Which means if SRK gives us ridiculous movies, it is okay becoz Independence Day was also unbelievable, but if others try to give us a new story or a new story line, it is unrealistic and unimaginative.
Re: Typical anti-akshay review
by dp on Jul 23, 2010 05:21 PM
mate the world knows that this Raja Sen a bunch of Heezdooon ki fauj get paid for writing against Akshay!
SRK should be given a HAMM KING award for movies like MNIK KANK OSO RBDJ
Re: Not a patch on the original Ashok Kumar- Pearl Padamsee versi
by gittanjali on Jul 23, 2010 05:17 PM
the original khatta,meetha,was truly a memorable enjoyable film!
This lady gave 5 starts to i hate luv stories and 4.5 start to MNIK. she cant review a movie. Khatta meetha is a good movie i suppose just bcoz this lady has given it 2 stars.
why rediff wanted sukanyas review who is she if it is personal view then wirte it in same manner as if we do,why do rediff take such bullish matter it will definetly effect your repo,first she should reveal how much SRK paid her or rediff should expose how much they r etting from SRK to defame other films,he was successful in doing it for Kite and Raavan,now it is third attempt,akshay had done very brillient work in this film again it is very much related to real facts.
Sukyanya verma review seems matter-of-factand balanced. Hope the movie sustains at the box-office. Akshay needs a hit this time after his recent flops.
Its not all comedy all the way. It has a sensible story! touchy moments and fantastic performance by all! Its not just Akshay's movie...but every1's Akshay was OUTSTANDING - PERFECT!
