Re: Who Mumbaikars?
by Somesh on Feb 13, 2010 03:43 AM
I think SRK should apologize to the Indian patriots without wasting any more time! Think about the soldiers who fought right there in Mumbai and got killed! Remember them!!
I try to put my point as follows: Assume that, to my extreme misfortune any of my very close relatives had been a victim of the terror attacks in 2008 (which originated from a particular country). Now some superstar one day comes in and expresses his affection towards such a nation (from where many a terror attacks have originated) and says that they are "Great Neighbours", should I not consider these statements of the superstar as extremely extremely insensitive ?? Am I wrong if I feel offended by such insensitive statements of that so-called superstar ? The logic used by the media people to defend the superstar's statements has been extremely ridiculous. They have used all their might to prove a cause to be a wrong cause just because it has been supported by a particular party !!
Re: My take
by Devdutt Nayak on Feb 13, 2010 02:19 AM
People always mix enemies with neutrals.
The Pak public knows that their Govt and their Army is their worst enemy.
Pak people are not bad if Army chiefs and ISI are b--tards, just like Indians are not bad because Sharad Pawar is whatever he is, or Telgi or Ketan Parekh or Mulayam Singh are inhuman beasts.
The Govt does worse things to Army widows than this hurt and emotional turmoil. Have you volunteered your own earned money and time to help them out?
No point raising intelligent objections when you just preach and dont act.
Nothing personal, btw.
People on both sides need to understand that Govts use media to make public puppets to play with.
That is the definition of politics - how to fool the public and still get rewarded for it.
That's their core skill.
Intelligent observation or suggestion hardly means factual observation
I hate the Govt on multiple levels. I have personally suffered due to Govt indiscretion in education.
Like everyone else with a degree from Mumbai.
But do I hate all Indians because of the corrupt ministers and corrupt police force?
Re: Re: My take
by Panchal A on Feb 13, 2010 03:43 AM
Devdutt.. Well said.. I completely agree to you.. I am proud to be Indian and I love Bharat mata. At the same time I love all good people from the world.
Re: Re: My take
by thoughtfulindian on Feb 13, 2010 03:11 AM
So u still believe ignoring the fact that India Pakistan have strined realationship..and u want to assume that people in Pakistan are mere victims and terror has no root in the their psyche...A agree that u cant show hatred to all pakistanis ..but it does not mean we dont show our anger..and start playing crciket with them...Keep ursef in the place of victims before u give sermons...To me the answers remains that no superficial niceties ..if the relation is strained accept it..dont show as if nothing happened..We have played cricket for 60 years with same innocent pakistanis...did that stop 3 wars and kargil..U can talk peace only because u have been protected by the Indian armed forces..had pakistan had a upper hand in any of the wars ur so called " innocent pakistanis" will not come to ur rescue ..they will celebrate their vitory and support their army... How many of the pakistanis condemned Indian attack..they condemn only when the beast has turned against them...
Re: Re: My take
by thoughtfulindian on Feb 13, 2010 03:11 AM
So u still believe ignoring the fact that India Pakistan have strined realationship..and u want to assume that people in Pakistan are mere victims and terror has no root in the their psyche...A agree that u cant show hatred to all pakistanis ..but it does not mean we dont show our anger..and start playing crciket with them...Keep ursef in the place of victims before u give sermons...To me the answers remains that no superficial niceties ..if the relation is strained accept it..dont show as if nothing happened..We have played cricket for 60 years with same innocent pakistanis...did that stop 3 wars and kargil..U can talk peace only because u have been protected by the Indian armed forces..had pakistan had a upper hand in any of the wars ur so called " innocent pakistanis" will not come to ur rescue ..they will celebrate their vitory and support their army... How many of the pakistanis condemned Indian attack..they condemn only when the beast has turned against them...
Re: My take
by thoughtfulindian on Feb 13, 2010 01:50 AM
U are right and the same thought t has shaped my opinion too in last few days.. I definitely consider it unpatriotic and insensitive on part of SRK to say that lets play cricket with a country that killed my countrymen..However, i do not believe that we can depend on people like Thakreys and their violence to hold the city to ransom... I too have the same question for SRK ..had it been his family a victim of the terror attack ..would he still say good cricketrers are welocme from neighbor or cricket teams are beyond national borders... Would USA or europe play cricket with a nation that is responsible for killing their citizens...It seems in last 300 years we have not learnt anything about national identity..We are happy so long our family is not blown up
Re: Democratic India
by thoughtfulindian on Feb 13, 2010 01:55 AM
U are right Raja ...and I repeat ur own statement "Think again not for anyone but for yourself."...If this happens to u or SRK where u lose a dear one ..would u like the rest of us playing crciket with them..as if nothing happened... I loath what SRK said and people like u support...but again I disapprove of the so called Sena actions (which is nothing but a bunch of oragnized goons ) Its a problem of insensitivity and will not go away by burning training.. I wish u dont ever have to face what the victims and their familys had to go thru.. peace
Re: What if SRK dies due to injuries in stone pelling by Sena ?
by Rahuldravid Backstabber on Feb 13, 2010 08:39 AM
Wonderful! Shows your up-bringing! A man has to die because of his personal opinions!!! When will we learn to agree to disagree!
After being threatened by Shiv Sainiks SRK went into hiding of his akka Arabs..so he can show to them how 'M' are being targeted by 'H' and get enough money and support by making them watch his movie..even its a big crap, appreciate his junk. It will make an impression that our PM and Govt is realnulla who can't save a person from some party threat..and will get a great name for India.
Re: It was planned
by David Johnson on Feb 13, 2010 12:33 AM
SRK is definitely a traitor, he would immediately join the hands with pakistan if it attacks India..
Re: To all Indian fans of SRK
by r anand on Feb 13, 2010 01:20 AM
Instead of MNIK watch Dispatches : Terror In Mumbai movie. torrent Indians have a short memory, pakistan promoters SRK and bacchan , NDTV TOI. Plz watch this movie instead of MNIK Original recording of mobile phone conversations which no news channel had the guts to show
Re: SRK creates anti national shocker in UAE
by Somesh on Feb 13, 2010 03:47 AM
Man this is crazy, he should not be allowed into the nation any more, Ask him to shift his base where he is getting all the support! Traitor!!
