I find this discussion board a little amusing- rather than people discussing movie- they are discussing critic..Save the guy-Its their job to praise or criticize the movie- these discussion boards are to discuss the movie and not the critic..So heres my analysis- Movie is So-So- neither here nor there..
Re: WHY Review the Reviwer??
by Seema Yadav on Aug 13, 2010 11:02 PM
completely agree with Alviro--- We shuld let reviewer be the one and discuss movie instead.. just saw the movie- like it- kinda different thriller..Well ritten sunil :-)
Re: Re: WHY Review the Reviwer??
by surya das on Aug 14, 2010 07:49 AM
Alviro, first and foremost thing is that there is nothing wrong to discuss about critics. Cause if we found critic is biased by one or more things, which is now-a-days find in many occasions in Rediff. If critic gives his/her fair review and don't make unnecessary controversies then nobody interested to talk abt these critics, but in this case it is not. And, u will find in discussion board people thrashed critics left and right along with their points whether they like or not. If someone is reviewing fate of one movie (understand bad critics spoil the early shows of the movie, and create -ve publicity), then every people on board has rights to discuss about the movie along with critics of their wrong doing. Understand this first.
Re: Re: WHY Review the Reviwer??
by surya das on Aug 14, 2010 07:46 AM
Alviro, first and foremost thing is there is nothing wrong to discuss on a critic. Cause if we found the critic is biased by one or more things, which is now-a-days find in many occasions in Rediff. If critic gives his/her fair review and don't make unnecessary controversies then nobody interested to talk abt these critics, but in this case it is not. And, u will find in discussion board people trashed critics left and right along with their points whether they like or not. If someone is reviewing fate of one movie (understand bad critics spoil the early shows of the movies), then every people on board has rights to discuss about the movie along with critics wrong doing. Understand this first.
Whoever u are, U have given a balanced view of the movie-I felt that movie was not that bad and also I felt that it was not so good..Though I disagree that music was loud- it was apt for a horror flick... BUT honestly speaking- this guy Bobby has lost it... could not carry post Kareeb, soldier and Gupt..
Perfect- I watched the movie in morning... and felt exactly like the reviewer---That its a good movie which could have been better...I searched all net and find only rediff review to be the one I felt i would have written... Great.. BUT is Peepli a good movie as well
Mugdha godse is a Maharashtrian Bramhin ... I am proud of her . Women belonging to this caste are very curvy and good looking . I am looking for a bride in a similar community
Re: Mugdha
by Xpert Advice on Aug 13, 2010 01:06 PM
Mughda maharashtrian bramhin?!!! Kai boltoos re?
I am poudru of all maharashtrians, very poudru. Marathi should be the national language of India and world. All the disease in world are spread by non-marathis.
Maharashtrians are pure, divine and have only one God. Raj Bhakrey...
Maharashtrians have a great song, very popular, should be sent to grammy. It goes like 'Dheecha Dheecha, Dheecha Dheecha...' which they play during festivals... to the extent that the idol almost runs to be immersed in the waters!
Re: Re: Mugdha
by Rahul Bawdekar on Aug 13, 2010 03:07 PM
do not judge all Maharashtrians generally, just look around and u will find many prominent maharashtrians doing very well in their respective fields... as for Raj Thakre goes all politicians are alike,
Re: Re: Re: Mugdha
by Xpert Advice on Aug 16, 2010 07:36 AM
Hi Rahul, a fair comment and is accepted. I agree not all Maharashtrians should be generaised but that is equally applicable to other communities as well. Read the below comments by people like Babli and John and you will know what I am talking about.
Sure many Maharashtrians are doing well, so do people from other communities. All politicians may be alike but that doesn't make them right.
What saddens me is that people like Raj Thakrey do well in life and somehow find many supporters who probably doesn't have a goal in life except to disturb public peace.
Re: Re: Mugdha
by babli on Aug 13, 2010 06:05 PM
what abt the bhaiyyas? 20 of them living in 8*8 rooms? spitting zarda & pan everywhere ? hating the people, language & place which gives them livelihood ? playing their own double meaning songs in loud volume? why can't they mix with the locals ? why can't they learn the local language ?
Re: Re: Re: Mugdha
by Xpert Advice on Aug 16, 2010 07:41 AM
Babli, if you go to Andhra would you learn and talk in Telugu? Would you stop talking in Marathi?
Don't tell me you don't like double meaning songs or stuff lika that. Probably you are frustrated by the fact that you are not able to enjoy the songs they play because you don't understand the language.
It's time you learn about everyone being united as Indians and not as Maharashtrians, Gujratis etc. There is no difference between the Paki terrorists and people like Raj Thakrey (and you) whose only intention is to divide India and rule.
