BHOOMI SHUD HAVE BEEN OUT VERY EARLY. SHE NEVER DESERVES THIS PLACE ARPITA KHAN SHUD HAVE BEEN THERE. HER VOICE WAS FABULOUS BHOOMI IS 10% ALSO NOT NEAR TO ARPITA.
Re: BHOOMI SHUD HAVE BEEN OUT
by Hulksterp on Aug 07, 2010 08:56 PM
Yes defiantely she should have been out she has sung only those songs which suited here voice texture, the day she choosed to sing other song sung by legendary Lata Mangeshkar her voice cracked and she was not even able to sing half of the song in a proper manner, Shashi was far better singer then Bhumi or Tia,everything seems to be fixed here ultimately It will be Rakesh wining the show instead of deserving candidate
Re: BHOOMI SHUD HAVE BEEN OUT
by Brijesh on Aug 05, 2010 09:02 PM
Mr. John if looks what was needed than Tia was way more good looking than Bhoomi but she was still voted out........so thats a bogus point.
Now coming to Bhoomi, she has a different voice like Usha Utthap has. Not comparing Bhoomi with Usha but just making a point that her voice is different. Bhoomi can sing certain songs like no one else.
She is good and hence she is in still in the game.
The one person who I believe should not be even selected is Mr. Shreeram. He is already a playback singer in south and hence should not be qualified in Indian Idol as he definetely has an edge compare to others......but well thats my opinion
Re: Re: BHOOMI SHUD HAVE BEEN OUT
by aaaa on Aug 06, 2010 02:08 AM
Well for that matter Rakesh was a singer performing shows and so was Swaroop with his folk songs. I think this is a national platform and anyone should have the opportunity to participate except for the past participants.
Bhoomi never deserved to be a Top 3 singers of Indian Idol. Swaroop .......he never learnt singing/classical/western/Hindustani. As a desert singer, he is trying all types of songs which is appreciable. I think style of the participant works out. Anu Malik does not like Swaroop, this public knows well.
Re: Bhoomi
by Sohail Ahmed on Aug 05, 2010 04:00 PM
Yes but public voted swaroop out and did well, he's a good folk singer, but now the competition requires the best..
Rakesh is just not deserving of being on the final. He's there only because the judges showed pity on his crocodile tears...and because he was saved the judges couldn't save the deserving Shivam Pathak...who should've been in the final instead!
Bloody sentimental fool...parading his old and sick parents, proposing to his 'oh-so-ugly' girlfriend in front of national television!
Rakesh...I wish you're singing outweighed all these negatives...but sadly doesn't. U shouldn't win boy!!
Re: Rakesh...you just shouldn't win!
by SHAAN on Aug 05, 2010 03:37 PM
Rakesh Is singing & looklike of mohd. rafi as his early days in 60-70, he is going to win I/I.
Re: Re: Rakesh...you just shouldn't win!
by Nitin Nambiar on Aug 05, 2010 06:08 PM
Please don't spell out your boundless ignorance in full public view!
Do you even know anything about Mohd. Rafi? 60s-70s were his early days??? He started singing in 1944. He was a good 16 yrs into the industry by 1960. Actually speaking 1960s and 1970s saw Rafi in his peak.
Rakesh sings well and is very talented....no doubt! But, he sings like Mohd. Rafi is stretching the compliments far, far out of bounds.
Re: Re: Re: Rakesh...you just shouldn't win!
by vasudeep shetty on Aug 10, 2010 08:29 AM
rakesh and MOHD.RAFI.....please stop joking yaar...rakesh comes no where near to SREERAM.....then, where is the comparison betn him and RAFI saab...maybe, u never heard RAFI saab sing.....
