Discussion Board View article

Total 27 messages Pages | 1 | 2 | 3   Older >
Anand Vijayan
Brilliant Film (5 Stars)!
by Anand Vijayan on Feb 26, 2009 02:24 PM

Mr D'Silva you seem to hate anything and everythying that comes out of Hollywood. Your lack of understanding on any subject matter brought to the big screen beggars belief. He seems to like films based on fantasy. If so please stick to reviewing Bollywood films. Here is a true story, an unfortunate event that no mother should endure and Jolie has done magnificently to portray a distrought Christine Collins. With Eastwood at the helm yet another masterpeice has come to the fore Mr D'Silva have you ever heard or read the expression 'truth can be stranger than fiction' My guess is probably not as this is more than likley the first time you have read it..

    Forward  |  Report abuse
ann
It is a great movie with superb performance
by ann on Jan 19, 2009 06:33 AM

Comparing it to Tomb Rider is like comparing Bharat Natyam to Bhangra. Who so ever is reviewing this movie has no sense what she is talking about ? Elvis Disilva has less depth than Elvis presley.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
ann
It is a great movie with superb performance
by ann on Jan 19, 2009 06:33 AM

Comparing it to Tomb Rider is like comparing Bharat Natyam to Bhangra. Who so ever is reviewing this movie has no sense what she is talking about ? Elvis Disilva has less depth than Elvis presley.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Lara
if Priyanka or bipasha or ....
by Lara on Jan 19, 2009 02:16 AM

if your Priyanka(?) or bipasha or your darling katreina
acted instead of angelina this films gave 5 stars ha??????????????????

    Forward  |  Report abuse
KTVReddy
Rather watch QuotaDoc Millionare!!
by KTVReddy on Jan 17, 2009 11:41 PM

Based on real life story of known quota criminal DrRameshBhange(Pune)! Climax will remind veiwere Kamlahasan mimicking monkey in SADMA..Hats off to DrRameshBhnage when he perform naked death defying spiding stnut at Sunempire to win Miss Medha!searTHis gives you a clear insight in to these quota criminals'mind.These Quota Criminals wont get higher caste girl to marry or even to be grilfreind.so these middle aged 50ish quota doctors working in prestigious hospitals uses young or middle aged women COMING TO HIM as there pray! Most of quota doctors are smokers,habitual druncard or drug addict.Clearly it will knock down there virility for sure but problem is not that.Problem lies in THE Head!! By sxually abusing higheR caste women and/or childern,These quota crimianls will satisfy there EGO that they abused one or more highre caste woman and/or childern.This is pretty common psychological backwash when they feel fustated by competition from younger,competenet,more civilised and better looking merit doctor in the same hospitals.they have been taught to belive that they are margnialsed by higher caste professional which is clearly a myth as without QUOTA benefits,these criminals will be driving auto for sure!!



    Forward  |  Report abuse
ansuman banerjee
reviewer is insane
by ansuman banerjee on Jan 17, 2009 07:19 AM

This reviewer does not know what he is talkin about... Changeling is a great movie... i watched in a movie theater abt a month ago.. absolute rubbish review... bring Raja Sen back..

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Guest
Herald
by Guest on Jan 17, 2009 06:02 AM

It is obvious that the reviewer dislikes Angelina Jolie. Certainly Angelina's image is hugh strong, so strong that she's having a problem with the character because one thinks of Angelina as a the megastar than it is difficult forget her even when giving a great performance. I mean, she provokes such a fascination that it's difficult to forget her
as a person. And this situation is unusual. On one side we have to admire Angelina for being who she is but for the other side, this situation is carrying her some problem to really recognize her talent as the great actress she is, as once said Clint Eastwood. I have seen her in other movies before she was that famous and believe, she is very very talented, she is a great actress.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Anand Vijaykumar
larger than life
by Anand Vijaykumar on Jan 17, 2009 04:45 AM

I think the review was a little too overbearing on angelina jolie. There was just a passing mention of the fact that this was a movie made by Clint Eastwood, and no details on the fact that it has won accolades at various film festivals. There's too much emphasis on Jolie-bashing and not looking at the movie as a whole...

    Forward  |  Report abuse
ojas thar
rediff is biased
by ojas thar on Jan 17, 2009 02:41 AM  | Hide replies

i agree to sm1 who said rediff has reviewers who give crappo movies like OSO 4 stars n to a classic masterpiece like this jus a 2.5.

these days u cn't trust any sites - d best policy wld b to talk to sm1 whom u know well or else have sm research on ur own bout d film n c whether its intriguing enof n thn go for it.

Mr. Elvis over here fr sure needs some medical attention tho.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Ranjan Kumar
Re: rediff is biased
by Ranjan Kumar on Jan 19, 2009 08:50 PM
I do completely agree with Ojas. Do not go by this review. It is a classic movie and excellent performance from Angelina Jolie. It should get easily 4 star.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Total 27 messages Pages: | 1 | 2 | 3   Older >
Write a message