never understood the concept of movie reviews. movies are like food tastes. you cannot review them. atmost you can review the cinema hall in which the movie was screened. different people like different kind of movies. violence, comedy, drama, love, sex, action, suspense, special effects.. the same movie might receive different reaction from members of a single family. how can then one country agree on whether a movie is good or bad. why should even people read the reviews? just go and watch it.( i did that before i read this review). if you like it, sit quiet. if you don't like it, sit even more quieter. after all it is not like raja sen's review will prevent people from watching the movie.
Re: what does a movie review mean?
by Amit on Dec 29, 2009 07:40 PM
Exactly. I think most of the people here are either paid by the producer or by the theater owners. A review is ones personal opinion. Not necessarily it would be same for everyone.
firstly they ask Raja sen to write a crap to get negative publicity n internet hits (ploy is very succesful).. now they are affraid that the audience has really taken it to heart n may never trust rediff anymore now they want to lure the ppl by asking sunkanya to write a review which aready known.. come on rediff first dont play such gimmick & if rediff claim it is not gimmick then come on stick to ur own reviews n dont condradict urself.. n plz dont block my view this time have some guts..
Re: another gimmick by rediff..
by karn vir on Dec 29, 2009 06:58 PM
thats the power of media...they can gag anyone...even my comment is under moderators review below.....
Re: This movie is really a suck
by miraj on Dec 29, 2009 06:55 PM
i second u..it deserves one star only..i mean where was the story in this movie..and hw about those runaway bride scenes which make ppl throw up now...and the topper was somebody studying in an engg college(& that 2 reputed) with a fake identity..
it deserves one star only..i mean where was the story in this movie..and hw about those runaway bride scenes which make ppl throw up now...and the topper was somebody studying in an engg college(& that 2 reputed) with a fake identity..
Rediff is trying to please its readers....Once people started abusing Raja Sen and 3 idiots has proved it to be a super hit and probably on way to becoming iconic film....Rediff asks sukanya verma to write good reveiw with 4 star rating....thats is trying to be smart....
The review seems nothing more than a last minute, belated effort by rediff to save some face and Sukanya's review is nothing short of a kiss-a** article in this regard.
I didn't like Raja Sen's article as did many people but at least appreciated that rediff had the ba**s to host it on their website when the whole world was applauding this movie. Not any more; Rediff has lost even more face now.
Re: Re: a must watch movie
by vj on Dec 29, 2009 06:59 PM
i have wasted by money on 3 idiots.. n you know wat i am very haapy that i wasted it.. if u r so disspointed with movie y the hell ur reading the positive review (Raja sen has already written the things wat u want n suprise nobody belived him n went to watch movie).. I hope ur bigger than atleast Raja sen so tat few ppl will trust u..
