Re: Inspired movie??
by Jigar on Dec 09, 2009 02:55 PM
Nishant, why do you comment without watching the movie? See the movie first and then make comparisons as to whether they are remakes or adaptations.
Re: Re: Inspired movie??
by Nishant on Dec 11, 2009 03:55 AM
My comment was more of a query. To reword "Is Jack the inspiration for Paa?" . Thanks for the advice though.
Re: Inspired movie??
by krishna on Dec 09, 2009 06:03 AM
jack is mahabakwaas movie and bad acting by williams........there is no connection between them at all and hence to say that paa is inspired by it is a joke....some srk fanatcs are showing their frstration right since the paa promos are out...someone says it is a copy of benjamin button while others say jack...u belong to later category....to compare jack with paa is an insult to the movie paa....
Re: Re: Inspired movie??
by Nishant on Dec 09, 2009 10:09 AM
Hey Krishna, take it easy. Firstly, I thought "Jack" might be the inspiration behind "Paa" as majority of hindi movies are either derived from Hollywood or Korean movies. If you say there's no connection, then I would be more than glad, as I did not like "Jack". Will watch "Paa" this weekend. Secondly, being inspired by a foreign movie is no sin, however credit must be given where its due (if at all its due...take the case of Hitch & Partner for ex). Thirdly, you are right in saying its not a copy of Benjamin Button but your SRK point is...out of context.
Re: Re: Re: Inspired movie??
by vashishth joshi on Dec 09, 2009 11:45 AM
nishant i think 99% movie is remake of hollywood movie. but u seen the performance of the indian's in hindi movie. Black is also remake of hollywood but the performance of Bib B was amazing in that movie.so he got the National Award for that. And he'll also get another National Award for Paa. I think ssrrkkkkk couldn't get any national award for his upcoming career.
For people who like to see serious boring melodramas, and definitely those who couldnt understand the funny side of DDD should watch this film. In short only for self proclaimed 'film intelectuals'. You should seriously think of joining the rediff board of film critics
Re: Amazing Movie, Great performance by Big B
by vashishth joshi on Dec 09, 2009 11:39 AM
remo i am with you. and i became a great fan of auro after watching the movie.
