After watching the whole movie, my wife asked, what happened ? I think many people may have thought the same, and probably that’s what the movie maker want. One scene is enough to understand the movie, it seems as if the movie maker is more interested that people should know his wit and intelligence rather than taking people for a two hour ride. The “Hath JaganNath” written on the toilet door, could have been more authentic, if it was graffiti on the door, causally with a sketch pen or something without the photo of the girl, so that it is present there subtly not explicitly, because the toilet seems to be part of a family building not some boys hostel. Little bit of salt makes food tasty, too much of it makes food uneatable, things like dark cinematography, and story telling and dialogues in different languages were great but it was so great that ordinary people have to stress their brain on what’s happening. I think a good movie is the one, which can hypnotise the intelligence of viewer, he just watch , No thinking about anything, this movie could have been very engaging if not overdone in some aspects.
Re: FLOP and PATHETIC MOVIE
by Rishabh Ravi on Aug 26, 2009 12:21 AM
Hi Chitra, If Kaminey is what you call a pathetic / disgusting movie, I really would like to know what kind of movies do you like?!!! If we have a few more people like you, Hindi movies will continue to languish at the lows that they are presently. I feel sorry for you, really!
Re: Re: FLOP and PATHETIC MOVIE
by Sycorax on Aug 26, 2009 04:07 PM
So Rishab, liking Kaminey gives you the right to judge other people? Some parameter of intellectualism that is!
Re: Re: Re: FLOP and PATHETIC MOVIE
by mayank jain on Aug 26, 2009 09:42 PM
Dear Chitra Verma,
I dont know what is ur personal problem with the movie because u make it a point that u should post a comment on this forum on daily basis.... I got to know when i have read the comments. Why ur waisting ur time? Because many people have watched it, Most of them liked it as it is a big hit till now, Almost all the critics liked it n if u have some knowledge of cinema than u can easily make out that on the acting part, direction, story, screenplay, music, editing, cinematography etc. every department of this movie is GOOD! Atleast u shud appriciate it for its originallity in the time when most of the movies in Bollywood is either remake or inspired by other language movies. The story is written by a poor African who was in need of some money and it is the genius of Vishal Bhardwaj that not only he recongnised the potential in the story even he has bought the story from that guy and give him good amt of money. So that's why i feel even if people like u may not be with this movie but GOD is with this movie considering the genuine effort behind it... THINK IF U CAN?
Re: FLOP and PATHETIC MOVIE
by snapback on Sep 01, 2009 05:24 PM
I Agree with Chitra....all those below who like shoddy cinematography and unnecessary stuttering and retarded behavior can watch this movie...as per the story....like somebody said..a serious "Hungama"....nothing more....
Re: FLOP and PATHETIC MOVIE
by Ramesh Kahitarikar on Aug 26, 2009 10:51 PM | Hide message
Dear Chitra, go bury yourself into some Yashraj candy floss Rahul-Raj piece of sh*t.
Re: flop movie - rediff flop rating - don't watch
by Dilip Das on Aug 27, 2009 10:52 AM
You are really a fool person to call KAMINEY a double impact copy. Get well soon...
Hi I have seen this movie yesterday its was not too good movie but its ok shahid had shown good acting skills especially as a charli some scenes are really good in the movie the one shaid is running with the horses all the scenes will look like a realistic the camera work is good over all the movie was fine, thanks to vishal for a different kind of movies.
The first half of the movie is kinda hollywood type...nice try to emulate direction from Firngis but then there are too many charecters in the movie and the director is unable to control them. there is a complete chaos!!! I still can not figure out what was happening in last 45 minutes!!wtf! that pissed me off. We can say Shahid is gradually evolving as an actor,rest everything in movie is shit!!! Sometime I ponder wtf these directors think !! Are we Bollocks or what!! Senseless, baseless and criminal waste of money and time ..... PS:In my survey only those people liked it who never witnessed good cinema.
Kaminey is such an aggresively marketed that everyone felt that its one of the best movie.
I also fell prey to such misconception. But when i watched the movie it was so much below my expectations that i want my money back
I urge all the one's who have not seen this movie that please don't waste your time and money on this FLOP Meaningless Movie. Kaminey is utterly BORING MOVIE.
on an off-tangent note , this movie is full of the dark lanes n locales of 'bombay' like in slum-dog. Though SD is out of context here, i cant help comparing. no doubt this movie's visuals are gud, but wasnt slumdog brilliant. danny boy, how do u do it??
mai fa ko fa bolkta hoon fir lol ...movie is fantastic, go for it yuall...... how the heck did they shoot this movie, all frames look real . its rivetting, break-neck fast and a brainer this one. so many characs hit u, and so fast, u need ur wits alive to keep up. im surprised glam hot gals can act @priyanka, she plays the charac, and not a glamdoll. shahid has matured, the bros feel like diff characters; my one gripe is the identical hairstyle, not pat. every charac and every scene is engaging....
and the music is gr8, which even the this-movie-is-pits sayers, who dont want to give any credit to this movie, have to concede.... cheerzzz