They shud be best left to give their reviews on craps like "Rakhi ka Swayamwar". Either rediff movie reviewer(s) dont know what acting is, or may be they have a little trouble with understanding english. I understand Depp and Bale's accent can be a little difficult for rediff reviewer to understand, but at least he should write the movie off..
Come on rediff.. Mature up, and get some men to review the good movies not eunuchs...
Re: Rediff reviewers dont know abc of movies..
by raj singh on Aug 08, 2009 09:27 AM
They shud be best left to give their reviews on craps like "Rakhi ka Swayamwar". Either rediff movie reviewer(s) dont know what acting is, or may be they have a little trouble with understanding english. I understand Depp and Bale's accent can be a little difficult for rediff reviewer to understand, but at least he should write the movie off..
Come on rediff.. Mature up, and get some men to review the good movies not eunuchs...
Re: Rediff reviewers dont know abc of movies..
by vaibhav sharma on Aug 07, 2009 07:55 PM
but at least he should not write the movie off.. was a typo in my earlier message
who is this guy? who doesnt think johnny depp or christian bale can act? must be a fan of bhijpuri movies. went expecting some raunchy numbers got some dark, quality, acting instead. his disappointment is showing man.
Mr. D'silva. Stop reviewing movies! you just dont get it. Its not a gangster war crime drama flick. Its about a character which Mann has perfectly sold to the audience in form of a Love Story. Thats about it! Just read what you have written in your review. Its shame that ppl like you are actually paid to write non sense. Go back to the cinema hall n watch it for like 100 times, you might just get it then!
The reviewer is Useless and so are some of the other readers posting their comments. Public Enemies is an excellent movie bringing today's gen Y a taste of 30s gangsters with top quality actors and direction. The movie has been very well received by critics and the public. Just look at reviews and comments on other websites to validate my comments.
If one compare this movie with the same Ditector (Micheal Mann) movie HEAT in which Robert De Niro is chased after by Al Pacino.Except Marion Cotillard is additional attraction.Same story line except charecters are different.Al Pacino's role played by Christian Bale and De Niro role portrayed by Johnny Depp.
HEAT is far better atleast there was scene between De Niro and PACINO in Restaurent.
I guess the review is spot on.I felt the same way and it wasnt just me;the whole theatre released a sigh of relief when the movie ended.Its s**t movie and my advice to anyone who is planning to watch it "Dont watch it".The movie is sinfully long and doesent have a flow.I was fooled by the trailer and I am disappointed now after watching the movie. Nattu.
Re: The reviewer is right
by johnny on Aug 08, 2009 11:49 AM
i think u don't understand the english, ya it happens and johnny's accent is little bit different, why don't u try bhojpuri movies, they are perfect for u, what were u expecting in movie, johnny will be jack sparrow, sorry my dear, but u should increase ur level, u are that type of psycho who just want to criticize evry good thing, u r good for nothing..
I don't know if you just want to prove your 'geeky' level of movie reviews. But after ice age and this movie review, it looks like you may have better things in life to do .
I thought this movie is brilliant with its cinemetography and the now infamous allegation of depps over acting. This movie will be a hit in metros
