Till date I have been an avid reader of your reviews and to me you have been one of the best reviewers online. However this incident of revealing the RACE climax has completely shocked me. I thought of giving it a benefit of doubt that for once you have let the reader down. But I am further disappointed with you trying to justify your actions. I believe that a person tries to justify when he starts getting cornered or he feels he is wrong. You and I will both agree that you are not god neither do you have the final say for deciding the fate of a movie. It is upto the viewers to brand it as a hit or a flop. Atleast the directors/producers have made an effort to make a movie and they are not compelling/forcing viewers to go and watch RACE. I somehow feel that you owe an apology for your actions but then if you have a stubborn ego then probably you can go on arguing and justifying your actions. A polite sorry will do nothing but maintain your respect as a reviewer otherwise you are ruining your reputation as a good reviewer. Rest is upto you to decide!!!
well guys i live in USA so the taste of movies for people living in states is different from people living in india and i really liked this movie its far better than those SRK's love stories this movie is holding everyone and i dont know how come this idiot editor is giving his thoughts i dont understand y a media needs one person to judge movie for 100 crore people he should appreciate this movie as its different from most of them god knows when bollywood will come out of fancy love stories and start making movies like TZP, Race, RDB and very similar to it.
I have been reading movie reviews for the past one year now.. I dont know why but i have never ever read a good review of an Indian Movie on Rediff... I have read awesome reviews on Hollywood flicks even if the movie is crap.I have never ever read a positive review for a movie in rediff.. You guys gotta do something about this!!!
RE:One Advise
by Ashish Bhutada on Mar 28, 2008 01:00 PM
continuing the same... Raja sen is SRK addict. He just write good only when the movie is of SRK. Raja, do you get anything from SRK? Why the hell you don't like other movie. come on grow up man...
ITS ABSURD, THAT THE REVEIWER HAS TO COME OUT AND DEFEND HIS REVIEW STUFF N ALL....RACE IS PUREST OF PURE COMMERCIAL ZILCH, WHICH HAS NOT EVEN A SINGLE IOTA OF REALITY, MEANT FOR JUST KILL-TIME-FUN, EVENING, AND 4 PEOPLE WHO WATCH MOVIES AS A COMPULSION, AS RELEASES KEEP DWINDLING OVER A PERIOD OF TIME....ALL DRESSED UP NOWHERE TO GO...RACE/X/Y...IT WUD NEVER MAKE A DIFF. N who cares/remembers REVIEW 4 SUCH A MOVIE.
IN A POPULATION OF 100 CRORES, AIDED BY FREE DISCUSSION BOARDS, IF A MAX 1000 PEOPLE WRITE STUFF, BASED ON THEIR THOUGHTS, A REVIEWER NEED NOT COME TO HIS DEFENCE AT ALL.
INSTEAD LET US HAVE REVIEW OF ENGLISH MOVIES/REGIONAL GOOD MOVIES - ALL LANGUAGES.REDIFF OF LATE CUT DOWN REVIEWS OF ENGLISH MOVIES WHOSE RELEASES R OUTNUMBERING HINDI ONES.
IN THE END TE FAMOUS SAYING ''IF EVERY RUB HURTS, HOW COULD/CAN THE MIRROR BE CLEAN''.
Well you seem to have bigger ego about your view than the film makers seems to have with their movie! For god's sake, stop promenading as a critic and fix your head. Good or bad, you have no business revealing the climax. Let the public decide whats good for them.
I cant believe that you have written this follow-up piece after the initial mistake. You are using the media to settle personal disputes and thats appalling! Why dont the two of you talk and keep us out of this!
And before you jump to conclusions like you regularly seem to do, I do not represent the film makers.
Raja ji, chalo chale taran adarsh ki sharan mein aur dekhe kaisi hoti hai yeh film critic (for ur information i tell u RACE collection till wednesday is arount 55 crore (world wide).... Sorry raja ur plans fails regarding to make this movie flop. anyways gud night for 1 yr have sweet dreams with ur ???????
very bad mr.raja sen u should have said sorry to film makers who have made such a wonderful film.and on top of that u r saying tht this film is borrowing. plz keep ur views with u.
I watched this pakistan movie Khuda ke liye 3 months back & its one of the finest movies I have seen the direction,the acting & the best of them all is the music.Everyone should watch such a masterpiece from Shoaib Mansoor.
