Discussion Board

Superstar is an average film


Total 17 messages Pages | 1 | 2   Older >
chinmay anand
Dejected Ameeta
by chinmay anand on Feb 18, 2008 05:46 PM

Ameeta Gupta, have you been rejected by your boyfriend recently? at least your mood as reflected while writing down this reviews reflects so.

Like everybody else here, me too felt the movie too good, another feather in Kunal Khemu's cap (after Traffic Signal). I don't know why it didn't pull the crowd.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
anjali
no need to
by anjali on Feb 11, 2008 01:30 AM

no need to tell us the story
thank u very much

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Kumar kumar
What a movie!!!!
by Kumar kumar on Feb 09, 2008 01:37 PM

Wow!! i liked this movie very much! Cant expect a better actor than Kunal. He will indeed become a superstar in the coming days. I admire his looks also. This actor will give competition to Darsheel. This movie is in the league of Taare Zameen..
Well made.Much better than OSO & saawariya

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Himanshu Manroa
I wish I could Strangulate the reviewer!!!
by Himanshu Manroa on Feb 09, 2008 12:19 PM

As kids we used to discuss film stories with our school and society friends. Phir aisa hua, then the hero did this, then the villian killed hero's mother....phir waisa hua....blah blah...aur phir hero ne Villain ko goli maar di!! Finsih. The End.

Looks like Miss Ameeta Gupta has still not been able to get out of her childhood....or worse still, perhaps rediff has started appointing children as reviewers! No...Mylord! I protest. That's Child Labour!!
In fact, here's urging rediff to let Raja do the reviews. Yes, he does have an explosive writting style...but that's perfectly fine. Atleast he knows his craft, his language impeccable (though at times a bit too convoluted), his style interesting. The reviews are film analyses rather than film narration. He may be severely criticised for his opinions, but nevertheless, his reviews still make for an interesting read. Get him back please....and ask Ameeta to concentrate on her studies for the moment.


    Forward  |  Report abuse
Candid Leela
SUPERSTAR is a COOL movie
by Candid Leela on Feb 09, 2008 09:49 AM

Rediff cant instruct..put your opinion but DONT Command... Check your end Line..
"Superstar is an average film. Watch it only if you have nothing else to do".
Gupta DIDI, if u didnt like the movie, you took 5 moniutes to write a Review.. but I like dthe movie and im spending quality time debating against your opinion.
SUPER STAR is nice FLICK..entertaining and interesting.
Why are you mentioning about other movies when talking about one..even if they are based on same canvass... its like Parents comparing children and taunting if one did well in exams. check as Independent movie of Rohit & Kunal.. they DID WELL. but GUPTA DIDI you seem to NOT DOING WELL in your REVIEWS.
:(^):ROSES for you to recover faster.
Expect intelligent review next time not a typicall Journo's one.



    Forward  |  'Report abuse' disabled by moderator
prakash hindustani
it is better then mithya
by prakash hindustani on Feb 09, 2008 08:02 AM

why every film is based on film industy? . . . khoya khoya chand, om shanti om, halla bol, my name is.., mithya...superstar?

....but it is better then mithya. it is interesting story, good acting.


    Forward  |  Report abuse
BibhuDatta rout
Hello, please dont write whole story.
by BibhuDatta rout on Feb 09, 2008 07:13 AM

Perhaps the author has not learnt what is meant by review. Please learn review writing and then jot down your pen.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
siddhartha mohapatra
Don't give Spoilers
by siddhartha mohapatra on Feb 09, 2008 06:49 AM

Miss Ameeta Gupta Please Don't Give Spoilers.You Are Here To Give Your Review And Not Tell Its Story.By Doing So You Are Robbing The Movie Of Its Novelty And Us Of Interest. Kindly Be Responsible And Refrain From Doing So In Future Or Is That Too Much To Expect?

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Total 17 messages Pages: | 1 | 2   Older >
Write a message