It seems these reality shows simply keep on churning losers. Where are the previous winners? At max they can either be seen anchoring some other reality show or participating in filth like Big Boss.
Another added to the lot! Where is Abhijit Sawant, Debojit Saha, Anik Dhar, Sanchita Bhattacharyya etc etc? All went into oblivion! The do only stage shows and earn money! All promises of 'great' composers went in vain!
Unlike last season where there were Abhas, Harshit and Ishmeet, There were not many good singers this season except Mallar. I really liked the way he sang. I hope he will get some work in this industry. As we all know singing in not a business everyone can do, there fore sometimes people votes can also be wrong.
Re: This season was not good At All
by Prasad on Dec 24, 2008 02:01 PM
I feel the real winner in this seaon was RITEESHA....she was outstanding and and real upcoming star. Rest all wer eaveragely good. judges are damn biased and public voting is baseless...this time it was indeed boring
Re: Re: This season was not good At All
by abbc on Dec 24, 2008 05:16 PM
exactly,rithisha was the best...should have won....but her elimination was scripted....she used to get highest votes from the audience.i hope she gets assignments in bollywood soon....hers is a special voice,not worth losing.
A pathetic reality show, which only had one good personality and that is SHAAN....AND after that everything was hopeless and pathetic, the HOPELESS, BIASED Judges, the participants everyone.... A boring season of AMUL STAR VOICE OF INDIA....
Re: a bore season of AMUL VOI.......
by Anu M on Dec 25, 2008 01:23 AM
It will be v inappropriate to be harsh on Amul VOI 2. Firstly, this time they brought as many representations they could from various states which is certainly applaudable. Its not an easy task to conduct talent hunt shows in every part of the country and surface the best talent. This was an incredible effort. So the show was a little stretched out which is obvious and especially since they brought back the judges favorites. Judges were biased in many ways and its not visible what the judges do to polish and train these participants other than commenting on their performances. The participants can only do so much with whatever little guidance and practise they get. I suppose during the show, the participants should be made to focus on their performances alone rather than engaging them in promotions all over. The organisers have multiple shows to manage on different channels so perhaps the participants do not get as much training and finishing as they would expect out of a show like this. Anyways, all things said n done VOI is not the only place for music lovers..
Re: Ismail darber judgement and suckwinder singh judgement
by Anu M on Dec 25, 2008 12:56 AM
Total Agreed! Ismail and Sukhvinder were caught up in bragging and bringing up their personal favorites. There seemed an extreme bias towards Saptaparna even when she failed to perform. Vipul got umpteen chances/come backs and unlimited praises, although he was certainly not the best. But am glad they kept Ravi safe in the semi-final round. Ravi was irresistable and his attitude through out the show was very grounded and real!
Eventhough his voice his not good he won, It is because of the judges because ritisha and some other singer were singing well from begining, but judges gave less marks since they doent like them. and also it is surprise to see ravi winning. This proves that VOI2 is not a good show.
Re: Selected a useless singer
by Anu M on Dec 25, 2008 01:03 AM
Not true. Ravi has an excellent voice quality. He is versatile and fast grasping. Vipul, Malhar, Saptparna, Ritisha etc are not 1st timers. They've been around for a while attempting shows/contest and are classically trained unlike Ravi. Given that Ravi was absolutely novice in the field of music, he did damn good. I suppose now that he is here, he will certainly grow as a singer and do well! Let's appreciate what we have. It's still been the decision of the masses. Be it for his charisma, his singing or attitude - He is public's favorite. So respect the opinion of other fellowmen too!
True he was very bad ...he himself said its coz of public voting..I dont understand who voted for him...when all of didnt like his singing..its just some of his selected friends and well wishers must have send lakhs of vote...or self-financed votes...who knows...but again there was no..deserving winner this time in Amul Star voice...
Re: its a disgrace
by Manjunath on Dec 23, 2008 05:52 PM
I agree. I really dont no on which basis public are voting. Same like our political system. All knows who is what but still we have to live with it.
