however the movie maybe, the novel was quite a spectacular one...still remember telling myself to read the first 20 pages and go to sleep and ended up reading the whole novel in one go....folks who havent read this novel please do it...costs just 95 bucks...
Re: superb novel
by firstlady on Aug 28, 2008 10:29 PM
i agree to u .Even the novel one nite @call centre is also too gud.Infact I am waiting for the release of that movie....
Aamir is 43; Madhavan is 38; Kareena is nearing 30. If Raj Kumar Hirani trying to pass them off as 18-20 year old undergraduate students?
Five Point Something is a movie which will work excellently if made with new comers who look the age. Unfortunately, Raj Hirani, who's a master storyteller (I love both his Munnabhai films) seems to rely more on star power!!
A Tamil movie called Kalloori (college) was made last year and it worked big time because the actors (all newcomers) looked their age and it was so real, everybody identified with them. The movie was accepted by the masses too. Check out its review on Rediff.
Re: Is Rajkumar hirani trying to pass off these actors as an undergrad student?
by itzkml on Aug 29, 2008 09:52 AM
u r right about the age differences. however, just close ur eyes and picturise the characters each of the three r going to portray.. aamir as ryan madhavan as hari sharman as alok they r tailor made for the roles. remember rang de basant and dil chahta hai ? they all worked dint they
Re: Aamir replaces SRK in 3 idiots
by ballu shahrukh on Aug 28, 2008 06:39 PM
i agree wid u .. SRK was d 1'st choice 4 thiz film .. thn it went to Aamir whn he rejected it .. bcos of certain terms .. Even 4 munnabhai shahruk was considered initially ..
This Novel was based on life in IIT (what not to do in IIT) and I believe the average age of an IITian student is some where around 18---24 but this character are playing all people who are around 35---40 (Except kareena who is around 28—30) …….I don’t know how they are going to justify with the character and how they are going to play a role of 1st year---4th year IIT student……….Keeping my figure cross……..
Re: HOW ????
by dip saraswat on Sep 01, 2008 03:13 PM
Aamir has guts and that stature to carry any role that comes his way. I believe these days its the strength of script and the storyline that puts soul into the movie. aamir complimented by kareena ( who has recently found the tag of blue eyed actress ) will make it a great couple on screen. Moreover , Indian movies are told in sucha a manner that a mithun or dharmendra can be college movers. Aamir is a success story looking at DCH and RDB.
Re: HOW ????
by Hate Who divides on Aug 28, 2008 06:31 PM
story will be justify if they tried 19 yrs badly to get into IIT Delhi Btech Mechanical class
Re: Please quickly advise whould I do?
by dhinchak dhinchak dhin on Aug 28, 2008 06:15 PM
1. Start taking tablets to stop motion 2. Put the Vine bottle Cork, at ur exit 3. Leave ur company and join the jhoppar-patti of Bangladeshis, they r using much advance system.. no water.. no paper.. nature would do its job
Re: Amir ar Ryan
by hemant dinkar on Aug 28, 2008 06:21 PM
No dude u r wrong ~ because HARI is the main hero of that novel so obviously AAMIR is going o play HARI and KAREENA as his love angle (Dean daughters) and SHARMAN is going to play RYAN and MADHAVAN is going to play that third guy (Big Specs) and I am agree that Boman is definitely going to make a mark as a dean …………….
Re: Amir ar Ryan
by Chaitanya on Aug 28, 2008 06:34 PM
Characters: Ryan: Aamir Khan Hari: R. Madhvan Alok: Sharman Joshi Prof Cherian: Boman Irani I'm not sure who is playing Prof Veera.
If the movie is by Rajkumar Hirani 7 it has Aamir Khan in it then you have to be 100% sure that a) The script must have been scrutinized b) The film will be a Terrific Mind blowing Film even better than Munnabhai c) And it will be a hit. The film has 2 Perfectionist what more can you ask.Lets wait for the Idiots like idiots
The book was just about okay just like the lady character mention it in his second book " one night at the call centre". but i guess, raju will make a good film out of this book
