after reading the review on dhaam dhoom music its obvious that the one who wrote this review has zero sense of music ..flute sax and guitar are well used in almost each and every film of Ilayaraja,a r rehman and even deva,yuvan etc.. and it has been said that the VALIYE UYIR VALIYE song has a sax interlude..but its completely a lead guitar..first of all learn all the basics before passing a comment on creative works...
saraswathy has reviewed tamil film songs for some time.wherever flute,guitar,sax used she always mentioned.so she could not have said they are not heard in tamil films.someone must have done it to malign her or the editor must have scrapped words without bothering about meaning. is it not the editor's jo9b to check these things?why blame saraswathy? nowhere saraswathy says dhaam dhoom music is disappointing. read the review fully, especially the last line.she only compared it to unnale unnale and said "it passes muster" putting words in the writer's mouth?who writes review captios?reviewer or editor?
The writer has a very bad taste for music.Harris Jayaraj's composition in DHAAM DHOOM is fantastic.The song,Saghiye is going to be a hit like Suttrum Vizhi of GHAJINI and the song Anbe Anbe is goin to top the music charts like June Pona of UNNALE UNNALE.Dear Saraswathy Srinivas,mark my words.
RE:Harris Disappoints???
by srinivas mahishi on Apr 29, 2008 11:34 AM
saraswathy gave 2 1/2 stars(above average) verdict for dhaam dhoom.editor conveniently deleted verdict part and put it as(disappointing).for dasavatharam verdict is 2 stars and editor calls it mediocre, .is 2 stars better than 21/2 stars?
Is the reviewer even aware of the kind of music tht r in markets and being played over the airwaves? Dham Dhoom is def yet another winner from HJ. Reviewer praises some songs and in end she says album sucks?! too much contradiction in the article.
RE:WTF?!
by srinivas mahishi on Apr 29, 2008 11:00 AM
she never said album sucks.said "it has not reached the heights of unnale unnale,but it passes muster".at rediff reviewer does not write captions of reviews. editor writes.so don't blame saraswathy.
where is this saraswathy srinivas living?Is she reviewing without hearing Tamil film music?she says guitar and flute are not heard in Tamil films!hilarious!!-prajani4@hotmail.com
where is this Saraswathy Srinivas living?Is she reviewing without hearing Tamil film music?she says guitar and flute are not heard in Tamil films! hilarious!!
RE:Dhaam Dhoom music review
by srinivas mahishi on Apr 29, 2008 11:09 AM
saraswathy wrote in her original piece was:composer has used along with guitar,flute,sax also instruments like santoor and sarangi which are not usually heard in tamil film music".rediff editor cut off words"instuments like santoor and sarangi"now tell me whose fault it is,saraswathy's or the editors? caption also was not written by saraswathy but the editor which is the practice at rediff.for your information she had given21/2 stars verdict (which means above average)which also has been deleted by rediff.pl.read the review once again,you will see.the editor has spoiled saraswathy's name for reasons best known to him/her.you have every right to differ from her about the album,but don't blame her for someone else's mistake.
RE:Dhaam Dhoom music review
by daya on Jul 13, 2008 10:07 AM
santoor and sarangi are also widely used in tamil film industry..minnale,siraichaalai..lot of MSV musicals.. for god's sake ..please let knowledged persons to write reviews
RE:RE:Dhaam Dhoom music review
by srinivas mahishi on Apr 29, 2008 11:45 AM
rediff, the least you can do is carry out the corrections at least at this late stage.
the # of disappointed movies done by you guys are not fingered by any 1,patha nahi tum log ko koy tamara ungalee karne se accha lag tha hai, you faggets !
