RE:RE:Prashant declared Indian Idol: See ibnlive.com
by Seema on Sep 24, 2007 08:14 AM
this is from wikipedia
Bias judgement On the episode telecasted on September 15, 2007, in the first round of songs, Prashant misses a word from his song which he mumbles and does not sing out clearly. All the judges except Udit Narayan comment sharply against Prashant. Javed Akhtar (commercial Urdu poet who writes for Hindi movies) goes as far as saying that he would like to cheer him with "once more" as long as he does not sing the song correctly. In second song, both the contestants sing well but the other contestant gets standing ovation from the judges who claim him to be "Indian Idol" at least for the judges. Alisa Chennoi goes as far as saying that she is voting for the other contestant. No judge is supposed to support or promote any contestant as a part of rules of any fair game on earth. The program hosts announce that the third song will be the deciding song as for the very first time both the singers will be singing the same song. In this song, the other contestant completely forgets the opening lines. He simply mumbles 5 starting lines of the song. He sings flat and can not recover even with the remaining parts of the song. By convention, a performer is supposed to finish the song, who is then judged by the judges and then after a commercial break, the other performer performs his/her song. However, seeing this pathetic condition of his friend (all the judges gave a shocked look), Prashant comes to stage and helps him with a few lines. As the other contesta
RE:RE:RE:Prashant declared Indian Idol: See ibnlive.com
by Seema on Sep 24, 2007 08:19 AM
Just want to add that.. indian idol is not a search for the best playback singer.. if it were than there were many better than prashant and amit...example (padmanav - amazing voice).. I guess sa re ga ma pa challenge is better suited for that..
ANYONE CAN BE A PLAYBACK SINGER BUT IT TAKES A KIND-HEARTED, HUMBLE AND YET UNIQUELY TALENTED PERSON LIKE PRASHANT TO BE AN INDIAN IDOL! HE DESERVES IT WELL AND TRUE!
RE:Prashant: Indian Idol 3
by Gaurav Bhattacharjee on Sep 23, 2007 10:28 PM
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/Prashant_Tamang_is_the_new_Indian_Idol/articleshow/2395880.cms
RE:RE:Prashant: Indian Idol 3
by bbiggie on Sep 23, 2007 10:26 PM
HOW DISAPPOINTING BUT AMIT HAD A GREAT FUTURE HE WILL MAKE IT TO THE TOP HES VERSATILE AND WILL GET MANY OFFERS IN PLAYBACK SINGING .ALL THE BEST TO HIM
