Discussion Board

Bhool Bhulaiya, a classic dumbed down


Total 226 messages Pages | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5   Older >   >>
BR
Wonderful movie - remake or not
by BR on Nov 05, 2007 01:16 AM

Liked all the central characters. Everyone gave a fine performance, and Priyadarshan used a lot of restraint in many scenes to maintain the fiction. I found Shiny being criticised. But he is an actor who gives a more natural performance, it was a good shot when he bent forward to hug his uncle. He looked and walked just like a king in the climax scene.

Akshay as he has been recently, was quite fabulous. Somehow he managed to look so handsome. And the song 'Aami je tomaar' was fabulous. I think Shreya Ghoshal is going to be become an icon, an icon that Anuradha Poudwal was almost to be.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
roshini devaraj
review
by roshini devaraj on Oct 25, 2007 05:21 PM

This is the best review i have read in rediff in a long time. Keep it up!

    Forward  |  Report abuse
z
for the MANICHITRATHAZHU fans...!!!!
by z on Oct 23, 2007 02:33 PM

the theme of MANICHITRATHAZHU is not just amazing, its a maze, when u uncover it. over and above the scientific/ tanstric parts of the movie and explanations given is an unsaid story (as said by the writr, madhu muttom, in an interview) . there are hints of an illicit fantasy or a relationship. thats true.
if u hv watched the malayalam version, the husband (nakulan) is hinted in one scene, as someone who's hesitant to sexual acts /impotent. when the wife calls him ot bed he (is working) and says ' u sleep. i have work' and the lady says ' pl call me when u are coming to bed'....its interpreted that the wife was not completely satisfied and she (in the trance , as the dual persona) fanstasises about the dancer mahadevan.the characterisation of mahadevan as a handsome man also belies this. now this angle /cue is there ONLY in malayalam. and thats the beauty of the movie.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
raghu vishnu
Manichitrathazhu is the best
by raghu vishnu on Oct 23, 2007 11:27 AM  | Hide replies

Dear friends, manichitrarthazhu is so loved by us mallus because it is a one of a kind movie....with real life situations,real life comedy , back ground songs, highly effective and perfect emoting(not overacting to express emotions). Emotions are to come naturally not to be depicted expressively or explicitly...this is what cinema is all about.and please understand, the climax scenes are not meant to be scary. The aim is to convey the emotions of a Pscycic.It is the confusion ,turmoil, revenge, anger, fear in the mind of the character that is diplayed so effeciently and perfectly be shobana. I agree with a lot of our friends who have said that jothika and soundarya were scarier. Yes they were scarier because they could not portray the emotions as perfectly as Shobana. they could only show one emotion , terror on thier face .and that too only with light effects.and this was not the essence of the movie. scaring is soemthing lots of movies come up with. that made chandramukhi and the others good movies. And the difference is what exactly makes manichithrathazhu a one of a kind movie that cannot be replicated...and mind you it is for mature cinema goers where cinema is a medium of expression and not just entertainment. and regarding the dance sequence..... did any of you notice that the first part of the song portrays a non-dancer by character (Ganga/avni etc)dancing. So the steps are not of a professional dancer. only in the imaginative scenes when nagavalli/ manjulika dances

    Forward  |  Report abuse
raghu vishnu
RE:Manichitrathazhu is the best
by raghu vishnu on Oct 23, 2007 11:29 AM
Continued from above:
only in the imaginative scenes when nagavalli/ manjulika dances is the dance shown as a profeesional one. Can anyone depict this diefference between a non-dancer and a professional dancer as perfectly as Shoabana has done. im sure the cine-goers of the other langauges did'nt even notice the difference. All this and more endears the movie to us mallus a lot. thats why we have been fighting for the movie tooth and nail to establish the fact that manichitrathazhu is the best

   Forward   |   Report abuse
kunal sharma
RE:Manichitrathazhu is the best
by kunal sharma on Oct 25, 2007 09:09 PM
thats true but shobna chandrakumar is par ahead from others she is dancer too by profession thats why she did it so well but this is a noticeable thing such that first part goes in imagination not a professional dance sequence which both the actresses have shown according to the role's demand

   Forward   |   Report abuse
killer
RE:Manichitrathazhu is the best
by killer on Nov 09, 2007 12:02 PM
This is a nice movie

   Forward   |   Report abuse
raghu vishnu
you tube-manichitrathazhu
by raghu vishnu on Oct 22, 2007 07:36 PM

for those unluucky indians who've had to satisfy yourselves with bhol bhuliya, apthamithra and chandramukhi...pls long on to u tube and search for manichithrathazhu. you can get to see some of the main scenes towards the end of the movie.and mind you...the scenes are not about scaring you.watch the emotions of a Psychic.....

    Forward  |  Report abuse
raghu vishnu
Manichitrathazhu's nagavalli Padma Shri Shobana
by raghu vishnu on Oct 22, 2007 07:07 PM  | Hide replies

Given below is a profile of Padma Shri Shobana ,the dancer. Now you'll can deciede whether jothoika, or soundarya,or vidhya balan or anybody else for that matter could have even have come close to her performance in the dance sequence in manichitrathazhu . Two time national award winner for best actress ...so guess i dont have to repeat the sentence to prove she remains unbeaten for her acting skills in the original

In 2006 January, the Indian government honored Shobana with Padma Shri title for her significant contributions to cinema and Bharatanatyam.


- 1990
Natya Ratna Awarded by Deccan Fine Arts, Secundrabad - 1992
Natya Jothi Title Awarded by Indian Fine Arts, Australia - 1994
Yuva Kala Bharathi Awarded by Bharat Kalachar - 1995
Natya Mayuri Secunderabad Fine Arts - 1995
Bharata Kalaratna Awarded by Bharathalaya - 1996
Nadana Mamani Awarded by Karthik Fine Arts - 1997
Ugadi Purskhar Awarded by Madras Telugu Academy - 1998
The highlights of shobana's performances
Ghatam Maestro Vikku Vinayakram, Violin Vidwans Ganesh Kumaresh, and Tabla Virtuoso Zakir Hussain at The Music Academy Madras and The Nisha Gandhi open air theatre Trivandrum - 2000
Sawai Gandharva Mahotsav at Pune hosted by Pandit Bhimsen Joshi - 2000 and 2002
Performed at the Kalidas Samaroh in Hyderabad hosted by Pandit Jasraj - 2000
Featured in the Hampi festival in Karnataka - 2000
The Soorya festival at Trivandrum - 1993, 1994, 1995, 1997, 2000 and 2001


    Forward  |  Report abuse
raghu vishnu
RE:Manichitrathazhu's nagavalli Padma Shri Shobana
by raghu vishnu on Oct 22, 2007 07:07 PM
Continued from above:

Maestro Vikku Vinayakram, Violin Vidwans Ganesh Kumaresh, and Tabla Virtuoso Zakir Hussain at The Music Academy Madras and The Nisha Gandhi open air theatre Trivandrum - 2000
Shobana has recently performed at the Sawai Gandharva Mahotsav at Pune hosted by Pandit Bhimsen Joshi - 2000
Performed at the Kalidas Samaroh in Hyderabad hosted by Pandit Jasraj - 2000
Featured in the Hampi festival in Karnataka - 2000
The Soorya festival at Trivandrum - 1993, 1994, 1995, 1997, 2000 and 2001
She has performed a duet with Oddissi exponent Sonal Mansingh at the opening of The International Film Festival in Delhi - 1998
World music institute- 1999, 2001 , 2003
International festivals- the cleavland museum festival of tanjore bronzes - 2003
Musee gimme in paris at the festival of Asian arts - 2006
Masters of percussion - Rhythm Sticks festival at the Royal Elizabeth hall - 2006
Featured at the prestigious ELEPHANTA FESTIVAL - 2003
Featured at the PUNE GANESH FESTIVAL - 2002
Only Bharatanatyam exponent to be featured in Navarasa, along with Ghatam Maestro Vikku Vinayakram, Violin Vidwans Ganesh Kumaresh, and Tabla Virtuoso Zakir Hussain at The Music Academy Madras and The Nisha Gandhi open air theatre Trivandrum - 2000
Shobana has recently performed at the Sawai Gandharva Mahotsav at Pune hosted by Pandit Bhimsen Joshi - 2000
Performed at the Kalidas Samaroh in Hyderabad hosted by Pandit Jasraj - 2000


   Forward   |   Report abuse
raghu vishnu
RE:RE:Manichitrathazhu's nagavalli Padma Shri Shobana
by raghu vishnu on Oct 22, 2007 07:08 PM
Continued from above:
Featured in the Hampi festival in Karnataka - 2000
The Soorya festival at Trivandrum in - 1993, 1994, 1995, 1997, 2000 and 2001
Was chosen by the C.M of Andhra Pradesh Chandrababu Naidu to present his ideals in information technology through dance, to the visiting American President Bill Clinton - 2000
Has been given the grade of A TOP at the National Doordarshan Kendra Delhi, which is the highest in the ranking for classical artistes - 2000
Shobana was the Bharatanatyam artist featured in Bharata Bala's Vande Matram series of music video that promotes Indian culture all over the world. - 1999
Along with Mr A.R Rehman and Shivamani performed live at MICHEAL AND FRIENDS Munich, This was lead by pop icon Micheal Jackson - 1999.
Presented by the World Music Institute in their October series in New York. - 1999
Was presented by the Krishna Gana Sabha, Narada Gana sabha, Karthik Fine Arts And The Bharat Kalachar in the Chennai Music and Dance Festival - 2000
She has performed a duet with Oddissi exponent Sonal Mansingh at the opening of PONGAL FESTIVAL 1st Prize Sri Krishna Gana Sabha 1990
BHARAT KALARATNA [ Bharathalaya, Chennai ] - 1996
NADANA MAMANI [ Kartik Fine Arts, Chennai ] - 1997
NATYA RATNA [ Deccan Fine Arts, Secundrabad ] - 1992
UGADI PURSKAR [ Madras Telugu Academy ] - 1998
The International Film Festival in Delhi - 1998


   Forward   |   Report abuse
prasad shinde
www.akshaykumar.org
by prasad shinde on Oct 18, 2007 10:18 PM

This is very good site to know abt AKKI and its related articles...


    Forward  |  Report abuse
vaishag
This is a good movie
by vaishag on Oct 18, 2007 01:11 PM

Bhool Bhulaiya is a go n watch movie. If you wish to read the review of the movie. Please go to
http://www.indicine.com/movies/bollywood/bhool-bhulaiyaa-movie-review/

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Sumit Deb
sumitsdeb@rediffmail.com
by Sumit Deb on Oct 18, 2007 05:23 AM  | Hide replies

I watchd this much talked movie n had seen the kannada version of this movie around June 06. Bhool Bhulaiya is a good movie for first timers or so called north indians but if u r frm South where this movie was released in all the four languages and mega hit all the 4 times then it wud be a disappointmnt. I m frm Bengal n watched the Kannada version during my stay in mysore.. n beleive me guys thougth i dont kno kannada i watched this movie thrice. The music given was compltly mind blowing .. specially the climax song.. even now i can feel tht "ra raaaaa...." horror.I have to make sure to watch the mother of all .. thts Malayalam. Hats off to the orifinal story writer.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
SUNIL
RE:sumitsdeb@rediffmail.com
by SUNIL on Oct 21, 2007 10:26 AM
hi
i m sunil kmsr gupta. i am shild know actres moblie number for i am talking wiht act.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Total 226 messages Pages: | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5   Older >   >>
Write a message