Every person is free to have his or her opinion,but it is not necessary always to voice it in public,it is not a question of who is right and who's wrong.If Aamir has not liked anything abt the film he should just shut up. I am also shocked to hear bachchan reiterating.
RE:Own Opinion
by sandeep balagopalan on Dec 01, 2007 10:47 PM
Shocked?? Bachchans seem to be doing that to every second person he meets. Secondly Aamir was asked abt it in an interview, why is he supposed to shut up or for that matter lie??
I completely agree with Aamir. I did not like the movie either. And I found Big B over-acting in the movie. Rani and cinematography were the only good things about 'Black'. I felt Saawariya was several times better than Black.
RE:Black
by Mirza Waheed on Dec 01, 2007 07:36 PM
Black has been the most overrated film of the last few decades, and its director the biggest fraud to have succeeded in Bollywood. The film was an insult to intelligence; Mr Bhansali has mastered the craft of faking it.
Big B is eventually turning into a big bore. He is acting in all & sundry, every ad every RGV's Aag and Nishabd. Anybody who has got couple of crores to spare can hire his services. He has started to beleive that he is above all critisism and some sort of God or what. Its high time he should be reminded in stern term to step down. He is also manipulative and have used his connections to get "life time achievement award " from school functions to blah blah what not orginizations.
RE:BIG B = BIG BORE
by SUNNY RAWAT on Dec 01, 2007 11:18 PM
Black is a highly overated supposedly work of art. SLB is one of the greatest fraud to hit the bollywood. Accepted, Khamoshi was a good movie, but then Hum Dil..., then Devdas and then disastrous Black and then the Mother of all Fakes Saawariya...this guy should be kicked, where he belongs to: the gutter
It seems Media has no work and out of mind. That's why they are asking our comments on such a foolish issue. Bandar samajh rakkha hai kya? dugdugi bajaoge aur nachunga. Please for god's sake post some meaningful article.
first of all media is sick..just for their greed they hype such thngs and create a problem between to respected celebrities..I hv read aamir's interview, AB's reply and Aamir's blog. First of all the interview Aamir was literally forced to give an opinion on black..the interviewer first asked abt which directors he likes..he replied..den he pushed it to SLB...aamir just gave a diplomatic reply..but still the interiewer then specifially asked about black..it was like the interviewer knew aamir's view on black and wanted to print it to create some kinda sensation or sumthg..and honestly he was very successful..aamir gives replies straight frm heart unlike SRK AB and other bollywood celebrities..so its no surprise that he gave his honest opnion..wn if we agree vth his opnions or not is subjective..but its a free country..he is an audience like us while seeing black..so he cn hv his opnion which mite be different from us..well I actually dint like Black all tht much and dnt knew y was tht hype all abt and I second to Aamir's opnions nw..but again u guys mite thnk differently..so fine.its a free country.we can like or dislike a movie..its our personal choice.I dnt see whr Aamit went wrong.ya bbut AB's reply was immature as compared to his age and stature..he has been showing his huge ego since his son has come into movies..earlier he was ok.SRK and AB had a huge ego fight.Aamir is nt gng to just fight coz of his ego.he has alrdy said in his blog that he is no1 in frnt of AB.
RE:Media is sick and so r v all!!
by Amit Kripalani on Dec 01, 2007 03:57 PM
In this whole issue Aamir has gained more respect frm me..and AB is starting to loose it a bit..he shouldn't get so impulsive..the fact is in last 1 decade Aamir's acting standards have risen beyond many of the leading stars in our industry..so if he says there was sumthg wrong vth black..instead of acting like kids and fighting we should try and discuss rationally on his opnion..he could be wrong..but I think on Black he is actually right..specially the performances..tht was way 2 over for me at least...and thts not actor's mistak..thts director's mistake..n thts wt aamir said anyways..and btw just coz some of u guys liked black doesnt mean u cnt hv a second thought on it..neways guys cheers!! and dnt waste time and give media so mcuh bhaav on such crappy news!!
Here I saw all the messages which showed that they r anti-amir fan.But I wonder how Amir's all the films(specially from Lagaan) r hit.Even mangal pandey was not a flop.Its not a hit but it did decent business.Last yr Fanaa and RDB got gr8 business.How that possible if so much anti-amir fans.
Grow up Anti-Amir fan.If u dont like amir's movie plzz dont see it.And plzz read amir's blog before seeing this crap written by media.In blog he mentioned that Dilip Kumar and AB r the two icons he admire and they r his fav. actor.He commented abt Black not the actore.If SLB can tell that Fanaa is very bad movie(in Koffee with Karan) then if he didnot like Black he can also tell this.
And lastly,who have said why these came after 2 yrs,let them remind the interviewer asked him abt Black not him talked abt black.Interviewer asked him who r the directors he want to work now,then he said Raju Hirani and maniratnam. Then interviewer asked specificly abt SLB and Black then he commented this.
And anti-Amir fans u can dislike amir.But fact is he charged 20cr for ghazni.Tell me how many can get 20cr for 1 film in bollywood.And he refused 60cr. for 3 films.Tell me how many can refuse this also.
RE:Welcome Anti-Amir fan
by Noor Chowdhury on Dec 01, 2007 04:06 PM
Obviously not AB. For money he will do anything & everything for example: Cheeni Kum, Nishabd, Stupid Movie Like Black so that he can kiss Rani or any other young girls. Slowly Slowly seems he is becomig paedophile hmmm. Stupid Man he never gave any such movie to be inspired like Aamir.
I am staunch fan of Amir. Same as the way Amitabh appreciates Amir. He has given his voice as a Sutradhar in Lagaan.But such kind of comments I never expected from Amir. Where was he when whole lot of critic were calling Sanjay Leela Bhansali a visionary after BLACK. Even after you read Saawaria reviews by these superintelligent critics you realise how contradictory things they write in a same review. Amir, I was waiting for your movie, because I know they are always worth watching! But I never knew that you too have gone mad like Shahrukh in publicising your image and movie on wrong footings! Learn a lesson from Madhuri Dixit! Half of India was not sure whether she will be accepted back. But analyse, how gracefully the lady has handled her media, interviews, promotional shows etc. Not all of a sudden into hype but a slow raise in discussions, and she created interest about her in minds of public.Right from 'Koffee with Karan' around 4-5 months back!Never was she overconfidant and never ever she over-reacted! She is the real grace equivalant to Amitabh! Amitabh too would not reacted to the Amir's commets but it is the reality that he has to show his flang if not not bite! SLB is having his repute which can never be tarnished! Dear Amir, you too can go to hights, I am sure! But do not follow Faraha Kha-Sajid Khan-Shahrukh khan way! Your tallent is never ever denied even by Amitabh or SLB! Do not be shallow person have faith in yourself!
Aamir is right in pointing out about the artificial environment in the picture. It does not seem to be rooted in reality. And, this happens because of the stylistic handling of the theme. And Amitabh's performance is over the top in a few places - no doubt. As far as Rani's voice-over that was something "over my top" too.
