RE:Silence
by Lalitha Subramanian on Nov 16, 2007 01:14 PM
Twice I have written messages and both times my message does not get published. Instead I learn that my message has been reported for abuse. What gives rediff?
RE:Silence
by Lalitha Subramanian on Nov 16, 2007 01:47 PM
Aamir may have his own views on the Nandigram issue, but I feel it would be wise for him to keep quiet.He has had enough problems, from politicians, 'ambulance chasers'[American term for lawyers who create non-existent cases] and even own flesh and blood.Let the actor continue to make socially relevant entertaining cinema.Nothing else, no other news.
no doubt shahrukh is a good actor but people should shtop comparing him with the great Aamir khan.. he is real star.. much much better than any other film star in bollywood.. starring Jo Jeeta Wohi Sikander, Lagaan, Rang De Basanti, Dil chahta hai, Quayamat se Quayamat.. all are un comparable to shahrukh`s movies... both are good but still Aamir khan is the best os all... so in less words... Sau sonar kii (shahrukh ki) to ek lohar ki (aamir ki)
AFTER READING THESE MESSAGES THIS WHAT IT COMES DOWN TO
SRK DOES PROMOTION AND IS NOT GREAT ACTOR
COME ON THATS BULLSH*T I DON'T SEE ANY THING WRONG IN PROMOTING YOUR MOVIE AND BY SO CALLED CHEAP PUBLICITY STUNTS HEY EVERYBODY WANTS MAKE MORE WHY NOT
HOW MANY PEOPLE HAVE NOT KISSED THEIR ASS OF THEIR BOSSES THEIR SENIORS TO GET PROMOTIONS SO SRK KISSES THE ASS OF PEOPLE FOR MAKING MORE MONEY WHATS WRONG WITH THAT
TO ME AAMIR IS MORE OLD SCHOOL AND SRK IS MORE ABOUT MARKETING GENIUS BOTH ARE GREAT ACTORS
SO HEY LETS NOT CRITICIZE SOME ONE USING PEOPLE SENTIMENTS TO MAKE EXTRA DOLLARS EVERY SUCCESSFUL PERSON DOES IN SOME OR OTHER WAY
IF YOU DON'T USE PEOPLE FOR THEIR OWN AND YOUR GOOD YOU WILL NEVER BECOME SUCESSFUL
RE:what is wrong
by sthitaprajnya soumya on Nov 15, 2007 11:54 AM
this a debate od last decade. Definately aamir is better. Far superior actor. he did certain things & other followed. he is a trend setter.
RE:RE:what is wrong
by vishal s on Nov 16, 2007 06:30 AM
srk cant follow aamir neither aamir can follow srk both have different personalities and performance caliber
RE:what is wrong
by ABCdef on Nov 15, 2007 07:33 AM
Whats wrong is to sell SHIT by all this marketing. We dont mind if someone does marketing for some valuable content in movie - and I am not saying great movies. This sucks - all fart no shit!!
RE:what is wrong
by vishal s on Nov 16, 2007 06:28 AM
ok i understand aamir is better but srk is good actor too and if people still see and like this shit( which i don't believe they may be not as good as aamir movies) why we bother let the guy make money mr abc
what is wrong with Copras and Karans , remember he created not they created him , Aditya did his first movie with him , so did Karan Johar, Chak de was also directed by a new comer. I admire Amir also but dont take anything away from SRK he is the BEST. Best person, most intelligent of the lot, very educated, very well read, articulate, eloquent, charming, charismatic, and very humble, very family oriented show me any other actor on this earth who has been into the film industry and never had any scandal; only SRK can do this HE IS THE BEST.
RE:SRK Best
by ABCdef on Nov 15, 2007 07:25 AM
All these values of of SRK does not translate well on screen - he is just lousy actor and irritating at most times. So I can conclude that he not-so-intelligent. And SRK did not create Chopras ---for god's sake dont make fool of urself in public forum. Whats wrong with Chopras and Karan???---its their brand of cinema - IT SUCKS!!!
RE:SRK Best
by surve on Nov 15, 2007 02:29 PM
no doubt shahrukh is a good actor but people should shtop comparing him with the great Aamir khan.. he is real star.. much much better than any other film star in bollywood.. starring Jo Jeeta Wohi Sikander, Lagaan, Rang De Basanti, Dil chahta hai, Quayamat se Quayamat.. all are un comparable to shahrukh`s movies... both are good but still Aamir khan is the best os all... so in less words... Sau sonar kii (shahrukh ki) to ek lohar ki (aamir ki)
RE:AMIR AND SRK R THE BEST
by biji george on Nov 14, 2007 08:04 PM
SRK is good when he knows that he is aired. Aamir is more straight forward. he always does for good cause
RE:AMIR AND SRK R THE BEST
by surve on Nov 15, 2007 02:30 PM
no doubt shahrukh is a good actor but people should shtop comparing him with the great Aamir khan.. he is real star.. much much better than any other film star in bollywood.. starring Jo Jeeta Wohi Sikander, Lagaan, Rang De Basanti, Dil chahta hai, Quayamat se Quayamat.. all are un comparable to shahrukh`s movies... both are good but still Aamir khan is the best os all... so in less words... Sau sonar kii (shahrukh ki) to ek lohar ki (aamir ki)
RE:AMIR AND SRK R THE BEST
by aryan acharya on Nov 15, 2007 02:53 AM
srk is a sell out, aamir is not. i do however admire that even though srk's is hideous he's a star.he does have charisma, gives hope to the millions of wannabe's. aamir is a better actor has more range, in my opinion the best ators india has are: aamir, amitabh, om puri, pankaj kapur,boman irani even anupam kher from his saraansh dys. and many more unsung one's. but the public wants a gift rapped shahrukh toh theeq hai.
He is the best among all the current corps of actors, he is far far better actor than SRK, In his long carreer of 19 years he has given lot of super films.
Although, I have not anything against SRK but I still think that he has to prove hiself as an actor other than doing romantic role.
Aamir has done all kind of role with some new directors, but SRK has always with Chopra's & Johar's Camp.
I think u vl agree with me. waiting for your comments.
RE:Aamir is best
by hindu on Nov 14, 2007 06:30 PM
watch Mela and then tell wht Amir does in such films. Wht abt Atank hi atank and wht abt Mangal (Bundle ) Pandey Though SRK also has done some stupid things he nevere claimed that he is the only actor in india but Amir thinks taht way and thats why never attends any Award function in India but went for Oscars like a begger
RE:RE:Aamir is best
by ABCdef on Nov 14, 2007 07:31 PM
SRK and Humble!!
hahahahahahahahaha Egoistic person who calls himself as a thrid person and constantly reminds that he is KING.
And FILMFARE sucks ..everyone knows that. When Prahar was the best film of the year it was not even mentioned in nominees. That all is a big organized fools show like WWF wrestling!!
And Aamir is right in showing his respect only to national and Oscar awards - they dont give these awards based on film earnings and no camp can buy them (even if there is some politics - which u cannot deny in any field of life now - but its minimal than Filmfare)
RE:Aamir is best
by Homendra Shrivastava on Nov 15, 2007 12:45 PM
the major difference between aamir & sharukh is aamir change himself for his character of his movie and srk change the character according to himself.
RE:Aamir is best
by k u s h a l on Nov 14, 2007 06:59 PM
...offf !!! wat do i say...c'mmon acting not depends on the banner...for ur kind comments boss..heheheh & offcourse whenevr SRK has got chance say for SWADESH he has shown up..man .. so there he is...better than EGOISTIC AMIR... abhi picture bakki hai....akad kaam nahi ayegi mere bhai ..hahahahah:))
RE:Aamir is best
by Super User on Nov 14, 2007 06:21 PM
Sohan, You are not entirely correct.
SRK has done films where the emphasis was not on romance.e.g. Swades, Chak De!
Also, some of SRK's finest movies have come from outside of Chopra/Johar camps e.g. Raju ban gaya gentleman, Kabhi haan kabhi naa have not been directed by Chopras or Johar.
In my opinion SRK too is a fine actor just as good as Aamir. If anything I admire SRK more because he comes from a family that has no connections with the film industry and has yet made it this big!
RE:Aamir is best
by ABCdef on Nov 14, 2007 07:25 PM
"""If anything I admire SRK more because he comes from a family that has no connections with the film industry and has yet made it this big! """ Apart from that (the inspiration factor) there is nothing that one can talk about SRK. there are tons of actors who have come from outside of industry - SRK just got lucky and got the timings right. And being from a film family does not take away anything from Aamir - infact he should be admired more cause he has achived this without taking being part of any CAMP!! SRK just goes with the flow whereas Aamir is the true rebel and sensible.
And if u say SRK is an entertainer - thats plain wrong - the King of entertainment has been and IS Govinda (and now some can say Akshay).
RE:Aamir is best
by truth prevails on Nov 15, 2007 03:30 AM
what is wrong with Copras and Karans , remember he created not they created him , Aditya did his first movie with him , so did Karan Johar, Chak de was also directed by a new comer. I admire Amir also but dont take anything away from SRK he is the BEST. Best person, most intelligent of the lot, very educated, very well read, articulate, eloquent, charming, charismatic, and very humble, very family oriented show me any other actor on this earth who has been into the film industry and never had any scandal; only SRK can do this HE IS THE BEST.
RE:Aamir is best
by jassi singh on Nov 14, 2007 07:16 PM
After seing Chag de India i can say that shahkukh would have been better then Aamir in Lagaan.Aamir says that he does 1 film a year and does the best short after many attempts but i say srk does 3-4 films and gives best shorts in less attempts.
RE:Aamir is best
by ABCdef on Nov 14, 2007 07:46 PM
Does not matter! Lagaan was more practical in showing cast/creed difference and how to handle that - it was just more timeless than chak de.
And as far as acting is concerned - Aamir may not be great than SRK according to U but at least he is not IRRITATING....SRk is really irritating and i get sick after 30 mins of watching him. I only liked him in Paheli and Baadshah (yeah this movie had his perfect sense of humor)
RE:Aamir is best
by MAYANK KUKREJA on Nov 14, 2007 08:56 PM
Actually, SRK is more a salesman, rather than an actor. If u watch his activites carefully. its clear, that he knws, hw to sell his ideas, how to sell himself. he knws well, hw to b in news. attendin 20 20 cricket matches regularly b4 om shanti om is a clear example of dat. just check out, if he goes to stadiums again? he knws very well, dat his films need loads of publicity. therefore there is band of filmstars for a song in om shanti om....
RE:Aamir is best
by bob c on Nov 15, 2007 12:18 AM
you have hit bull's eye my friend. Perfectly right. He is not an actor he is hakla.
Who said he is from poor family background please open wikipedia and read about him he had good family background and people go ga ga on his family backgorund and he he is at this positions destpite that etc. all is bull shit
RE:Aamir is best
by saif ahmad on Nov 14, 2007 08:54 PM
Mr. Jassi Singh if you think SRK cud have acted better than Amir in lagaan then all i can say is you are out of ur mind..SRK is an overactor....yea swades,,,yea swades,,,he acted really well and all...yea yea..why did the film bomb at box office then???? the trick is to act well and get it a commercial success as well...which SRK wud never be able to do...things which only amir khan and akshay kumar can do among the present lot...SRK hams and the world knows it...yea chak de chak de yea yea...chak de will not be remembered for a long cozz it was just a usual underdog team coming together and doing well...Lagaan will be cozz it was set in a different era...Lagaan was not about Sports...it was about life...and as for Raju Ban gaya gentleman....well it was a mindless movie actually...it was a bore...the only movie in which SRK did act well was Darr...but then that was beacuse the role wanted him to ham and to stammer all the while....which comes naturally to him ...so there u go...dont compare SRK with Amir...first let SRK learn about acting...then we can think of comparing...
RE:Aamir is best
by Alijaan on Nov 14, 2007 08:54 PM
I TOTOLY AGREE WITH U. SRK KNOWS ONLY TO ENTERTAIN NOT A GOOD ACTING LIKE AAMIR KHAN.AAMIR IS FAR FAR........ AHEAD OF SRK AND OTHERS TOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
RE:Real or Reel Effort
by Anurag Jain on Nov 14, 2007 06:25 PM
You are right, but whats wrong in it. Anyways they do open promotion by displaying big hordings and making jazzy TV ads. Atleast they are doing good for the socity by using the socity itself as a promotion ground :)
