I AM NOT A HINDU OR A MULIM OR ANY OTHER NONSENSE RRLIGON ..... BUT I HAVE WATCHED THIS MOVIE AND I MUST SAY it is tottaly BIASED AGIANST PEOPLE OF GUJARAT AND HINDUS>......i have watched many movies in my life from indian to american to chinese to german... but never watched some crap like this..... i have message to this director...u whana make good non biased movies go WATCH DOWNFALLL.....
He is just a shrewd director looking for easy way to success. Reviews of the movie said it was a crap. But it wud get recognition from the present government of India for sure and wud make the money spent bcoz of controversy.
SK asked, why don't you have make film on burning of Godhra train? Do we think people who died there are not having kids? Why don't you make films on attack on parliament or living conditions of Kashmir pandits on Delhi streets/ killings in Kashmir or Assam or West Bengal. Taslima has written Lajja on status of minorities(Hindus) in Bangladesh.Why don't you make a film on it? Any plans to make film on status of Hindhus in Pak and Bangla? Any plans to make film on Coimbattore/Varanasi/Bombay/Delhi/Maleogon blasts? You people have time make Faana and Parzania but never attrocities on Hindhus? Why? Just because you don't get any award or Hindus are not humans to discuss? I saw the movie its fully biased and you should have explained why did Parsis came to India(as history says unabale to bare the persecution in Iran, Parsis came to India) Rahul Dholakia answers, Do I have to make films for every problem in India? Isn't one problem I'm dealing with in my film Parzania about hate, enough? And there are 900 films made in a year. There are many filmmakers who can make a film of their choice so why do you have to question only one filmmaker?
--- This is what we could expect from biased directors, I appreciate Rahul for his direction, but not for the biased answer. Sorry to say this but Rahul you dont have the guts to stand in and explain the real situation. You very well know what you have shown in the film is just one face of the coin, but you need to get recognized. If you ever read this, let me tell you, Please change this attitude.
Hmmm...One more secularist born,isn't it? Sitting in Newyork..wow. Mr Dholakia why dont you come back to your mother land? Please do stay in Kashmir or other muslim dominated places with your family, will you? then talk about love, peace and no hate, them i am sure every indian loves your movie or dont give a bull sh**t sitting in Newyork..Cheers
I havent watched the movie, but after seeing all this hue n cry I think i shud. Boss...its a movie...its not neccessarily true or factual. See it and forget it...why crying... Grow Up Guyz !!!
I suggest a "brave" Bajrang Dal guy to make a film on Godhra . I can suggest a few actors for the same like Hema " get out if you don't like it" Malini , Dara "world wrestling champion" Singh and Vinod Khanna as the officer investigating Godhra. I am sure pseudo secularist will rise against such bold movies featuring slogan shouting Rambhakts versus evil tea sellers of Godhra railway stations.
The movie will end with caption - "Watch for Godhra 2- The revenge of the Clones ; The movie " which will give the alternate "real" version of what happened in Gujarat during the riots - like the brave cops of gujarat and hriday samrat Modi - saving millions of Hindus against huge muslim mobs on the streets of Ahmedabad and how even today Hindus live in relief camps without hope in camps. A fitting reply to all these secular types.
Super hit in Gujarat and played for free on all Motels in the US ; will ensure Modi gets a visa to travel to US as his image gets better .
RE:Revenge of the clones
by Sudhir C P on Feb 13, 2007 06:23 PM
Well said anurag, v has to grow up and should trust each other not this corrupted politicans. In this world no religion / community is bad i think v should stop treating minority and majority and encourage for new reform so called COMMON MAN
The answers of Dholakia to SK is very absurd. His film is very good , but Dholakia seems to toss the coin with tails on both the sides. No film maker will make a film on the other side of the story, more so in India. There is one possiblity. Overseas Indians , could do it and make it in Canada , UK , USA like Water ( not exactly the same theme), One could request Gautier, Elst, or Danino, and many more to write the script.
RE:Answers of Dholakia to SK
by krisna on Feb 13, 2007 07:16 AM
you still seems to believe in Modi ideology...Wake up, hindu is not the only ppl in this beautiful world!
RE:RE:Answers of Dholakia to SK
by s vln on Feb 13, 2007 08:59 AM
Hi Krsna
Hindus are not the only people but they are the Majority of India and the nation is Hindustan, They are tolerant and so this is happening if Hindus were to be like muslims, Minorities would never have seen beyond 1947 as in pakistan now
RE:Disaster Dholakia
by krisna on Feb 13, 2007 07:18 AM
you still seems to believe in Modi ideology...Wake up, hindu is not the only ppl in this beautiful world!
RE:Disaster Dholakia
by F17 on Feb 13, 2007 02:06 AM
I know you... I've seen people like you in history books... They are called Nazis & Fascist.... You know you might succeed in exterminating muslims in India just like Hitler's final solution for jews but how long nazi ideology last... Even hindu god Rama won't help you welcoming you in heaven with open hands...
RE:RE:Disaster Dholakia
by Govind Raj on Feb 21, 2007 01:16 AM
Exterminating Muslims in India! What a Joke Guys! From 2% at the time of Independence they have groen to at leat 14% in under 60 years! How come we talk about extermination? At this rate of growth, Muclims will be Majority in India by the year 2185. You and me will not be alive to see this. But this is a fact. By 2185, Muslims will be 51% of Indian Population and India will be declared Islamic Country. Then the Hindus will be driven out like they have been from Pakistan and Bangladesh. And finally the surviving Hindus will go and live in the Western world as refugees. So don't you worry about Extermination of Muslims. It will never happen, because Hindus are NOT capable of anything like that. But rather the Hindus will be exterminated.
RE:RE:RE:Disaster Dholakia
by F17 on Feb 13, 2007 07:55 PM
But how do you find out in common man who is a fascist & who is not.... but you are preoccupied with the thought that all muslims are fundamentalists....
Now who is the fascist... All I see is another OSAMA....
RE:RE:Disaster Dholakia
by s vln on Feb 13, 2007 09:03 AM
then better yOUR GOD Osama will take you to his HEAVEN for he seems to be your God...F17 please go to afghanistan and you can live happily with your ilk
RE:RE:RE:Disaster Dholakia
by F17 on Feb 13, 2007 11:49 AM
Osama is no god.... He is a lunetic like the fanatic who only love to kill in the name of religion... Hindu or Muslim.... Tell me how are you different from him.. You are like a miror image of him.... So why not go to Afganistan & fight him in his own game...
RE:RE:RE:RE:Disaster Dholakia
by F17 on Feb 13, 2007 12:39 PM
I am not a muslim, hindu, sikh or a cristian.. My religion is humanity & country.. And I want you to convert to it....
Pam asked, hi Rahul, why everybody tries to make film on Gujarat riots only? Why anybody doesn't try to make films on what happened on happening in Kashmir, Nagaland? You all Bollywoodwalas are biased towards Hindus. Rahul Dholakia answers, Why don't you make a film?
RE:thanks for the dumb film
by harish sowkur on Feb 12, 2007 10:55 PM
I can bet, there would be no communal clashes in Gujarat in near future. Muslims have got the real taste of Hindu retaliation.. GUJARAT HAS BEEN THE VICTIM OF ISLAMIC AGGRESSION FOR SEVERAL CENTURIES(READ HISTORY U WILL KNOW THAT)..EVERYTIME HINDUS WERE THE SUFFERERS..
Pseudo Secularists make blah blah about Gujarat riots..but keep mum on Kashmir violance where Hindus and Sikhs are still being killed..Islamic aggression has now reached Parliment..
In most of the Anti national cases muslims are the culprits..
I Really wonder why Muslims keep mum on terrorist Jehadi attacks in India? Why don't they protest if they don't support it?
And we the Citizens of India have still sleep ing..
RE:RE:thanks for the dumb film
by F17 on Feb 13, 2007 01:23 AM
You will never be happy 'coz you have already made up your mind... Let me ask you why do you have such inferiority complex... Muslims ruled India for only few centuries... India was mostly ruled by Hindu Kings... In your lesson to history we did had most muslim rulers taking care of the hindus with a few exceptions which includes hindu kings as well... but you have taken this to your heart... You simply refuse to accept that even during Mugal era kings never ordered to exterminate Hindu's totally. Muslims also fought for indipendence but we all simply refuse to accept this... What is happening in Kashmir is Pakistan sponsered.. Terrorist attacks are mostly done by PoK kashmiris & pakistanis... How many muslims outside Kashmir are responsible for bombings... check the fraction.... Its the insecurity which right wing outfits instill in comman man that people start believing that muslims will take over this country. Its their agenda for their bread & butter to be in power & limelight...
About those anti national cases.... Don't forget ULFA killings in Assam & other terrorist outfits fighting the state in whole of north east.. Also we should not forget Naxalis.... So do you still believe that Hindus are not indulging in anti national tactics...
Also muslims do protest to such activities but its not properly covered by the media coz its nothing sensational... If there is a story of any bombing then who will want to telecast protest against such bombings... Its not commercially viable...
RE:RE:RE:thanks for the dumb film
by s vln on Feb 13, 2007 09:14 AM
DEAR F17
You have made an excellent case of an Islamic Insurgent, but did you not read Huningtons CLASH OF CIVILIZATION, or better in history as you are a history buff, try recalling Md Ghazni and Md Ghouri, or for that matter mughals who killed their own brothers and sisters like animals to get to power or Last Mughal King Aurangazeb who jailed his own father to death
so do u say only kashmiris do the bombings, then who is dawood or shakeel et al
Hindus may be misguided and may do some anti-national stuff but you guys are rightly guided by your master to be pro-neighbouring countries
try seeing the reservations that these politicians are trying to offer muslims or your personal law board...DOES ANY COUNTRY GIVE YOU GUYS SO MUCH ??
ARE YOU NOT EQUAL TO HINDUS OR MAJORITY, WHAT ARROGATES YOU TO BE ABOVE LAW
NO SECULAR NATION IN THIS WORLD ALLOWS THIS TREATMENT TO MINORITES
YOU ARE LUCKY ...YOU ARE BORN IN INDIA IF YOU WERE IN PAKISTAN AS A HINDU THEN I BET YOU WOULD HAVE KNOWN IT
RE:RE:RE:RE:thanks for the dumb film
by F17 on Feb 13, 2007 12:02 PM
Md Gazni & Md. Gauri were mongol thieves.. They were not here to rule this country but to steal gold.. they were not preachers.... And we all know Mongols... Why do you see every muslim in India a pro paki. Do muslims even know who is the leader of opp. in pakistan.... this is the mis guidence fed to you...
About the reservations lets see... To start with all reservations must be abolished.... But India has given reservations to Sc/St. which belong to a perticular community.... Muslims are not the beneficiory... Personally I don't want any reservation to any community including muslims.... but we should resist all reservations & govt. should drop this shortcut 'coz they were not able to provide education & employmnet to people from every community...
Lastly how many jehadi outfits are there outside kashmir.. allover india working against India... Even Muslims want peace.... but politicians try the same old policy of divide & rule to run this country.... Who says muslims are not proud of India... have you spoken to the youth of India..
You believe what fundamentalist want you to believe.....
