Discussion Board

Banaras: a daft disappointment


Total 26 messages Pages < Newer  | 1 | 2 | 3
amit
first can u explain......mr raja
by amit on Apr 08, 2006 10:53 AM

how the hell can u write so much on earth for a film which seems u didnt liked atall n didnt understood....
well seems u r the 1 free person on earth who has nothing to do or u getting paid in millions to write....well whtever once again tryin to make u understand the meaning of movie review...it shud be short n with giving the viewers a view whether to watch the movie or not....but seems u wana be a critic or make it a point tht u r the most smartest person on earth......n every1 who acted in the film directed it..worked in it is a fool......
well if rediff pppl reading it make sure u get good ppl to write the reviews.....

    Forward  |  Report abuse
pele
I'm confused
by pele on Apr 08, 2006 03:41 AM

I'm confused as whether the film is good or bad. Mr. Raja Sen's comments made me think that the film must be good as "bad = good and Good = bad" in his dictionary - thanks to all his previous reviews. But this Patel chap is horrible i know so I think Mr. Sen might have changed his dictionary properly this time.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
singh
Review Banaras
by singh on Apr 07, 2006 06:43 PM

Films.. Expression of ones thought which can be abstract or carry a meaning hence to evaluate is difficult, thankful you have been appreciate of at least one facet of the film (cinematography) but what we need to look upon is that at least an attempt to portray on our mystically divine culture has been made. Some encounters or thoughts in the movie you certainly seem to have missed or has gone beyond your comprehension cas those thoughts do carry a very in depth meaning, I agree the movie has not been that well woven or the chemistry between the two lacks somewhere but a very fine performance (specially those little expressions reacted in some scenes) by Urmila (congrats!!!) ... the film could have been shorter by length but all in all a very good attempt made, overall a fine movie (if you are a film lover).. Congrats to the star and crew.( reviewer please dont be so critical of things)

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Om
Sen & no sensibility
by Om on Apr 07, 2006 06:19 PM  | Hide replies

Hi,

I think you would require some sense on understanding spirituality. Well I understand that the world u live in or the enviornment u deal with makes u live in the aura of Oblivion sense oozing out seduction and sexuality.

This simple beautiful alluring humance story is missed by you!.

Raja, it would have helped if you had some kind of background or had done some homework in getting some understanding of spirituality before commenting on the movie.



    Forward  |  Report abuse
Peeved
RE:Sen & no sensibility
by Peeved on Apr 13, 2006 09:28 AM
"Beautiful alluring humane story" - u kidding??? It was the most plastic, shallow movie I ever saw and Urmila's histrionics (more the lack of it) didnt help matters! Obvious inconsistency for eg - parents who are against inter caste marriages surely would have had problems letting their daughter dress up the way she did - nothing rings true in this film! Totally fake.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Total 26 messages Pages: < Newer  | 1 | 2 | 3
Write a message