All of Patcy's reviews are getting worse day by day. What has happened to the old Rediff reviewing team? With the kind of quality of Patcy's reviews, "the readers may read the reviews initially, but after a while, rediff will regret dwindling audiences".
This movie is good and a very good time pass.I laughed through out the movie. I am a punjabi and i don't think Director/actors tried maligning Punjab or Guru Granth Sahib rather they have shown immense respect for the same. I liked the movie and I think that is why it was House Full till it was removed from theaters.
Everyone has a right to have their views, but as journalists, you must get at least the facts right. Sunny wasn't awarded a national award for his acting performance in Ghayal. He got it only for Damini. And while talking of your incompetence, it would have been nice had you reviewed the movie, apart from indulging in your incessant ramblings.
I saw the post of lalit he is a complete stupid. how can he say that JBSN is a entertainer. apart from that he is critisizing rediff review team. Mr. Lalit alias stupid fool be real.
Why isnt rediff taking the readers comment seriously and change the review team..They are really consistent in their useless reviews.. JBSN was a thorough entertainer by any standards and sunny was great!!Absolutely no doubt
Dear Editor, do u people interview or test the person's caliber for writing a review for ur website? Teach this man Mr Patty to write reviews, ar atleast tell him who n what Sunny Deol is? this rubbish guy has not reviewed the movie bt Sunny, who is saying tht he shud really think abt his career. I doubt he has seen Sunny's movies in the past? Next time Mr. Patty please do concentrate more on movie rather than a Star. This is a free advice, if followed u will earn ur bread n butter in future or else u knw it better...
RE:Rubbish review!
by partha biswas on May 24, 2005 10:29 AM
Dear All, I dont see movies, but only somtimes read the critics version.And yes I have come to the conclusion that what critics say and what actually happens are completely opposite to each other.And mostly the so called Patty.N or whosoever they may be are a bunch of psuedo-intellectuals, and always grinding their axe for no reason.Well they have to earn their living I suppose.But with the rage that is being shown for Jo bole So Nihal, can the Psuedos actually tell what the ruckus is all about?I am sure they cant.And mostly the critics are the invited lot in reviews, and the trouble with Patty.N maybe was that he/she was not invited for the free drink.Am I right?Come on being close to a newspaper house,I know what the critics/reporters really do.
