Children died under the garbage heap in the capital and we want bullet train. Can we learn from Japanese about garbage disposal and get some technology on this please. We will all live better
Re: What a shame
by Janas on Sep 15, 2017 07:46 AM
Well said. BJP & Modi have also turned up like the others. Basic hygiene and safety in Railways have not been addressed but Modi saab is behind bullet trains. Employment can be generated in maintaining ordinary tracks, filling up vacancies. Of course unions should stop haggling for raise in pays every now and then. Then instead of complete automation, we can have jobs as well as work. Govt. employees are pampered and so lot of automation is happening resulting in lossof jobs. We should have a system where it is win win for all.
Re: Re: What a shame
by vadivudaiselvi on Sep 15, 2017 11:10 PM
Well said, even basic upgradation is not happening in Railways & even accidents are not controllable , simply by changing the Minister is not the solution , it is an escape from Public critis, Every alternate days BJP IS MAKING CONSPIRACY IN THE COUNTRY TO KEEP DIVERTING THE cITIZENS ATTENTION TO ESCAPE FROM THEIR BLUNDER MISTAKES. Pellet guns, FAKE SURGICAL ATTACK, BLACKMONEY FAKE PROMISE, DEMONITISATION, COW RAKSHAKS VIOLENCE,MAKING INSTABILITY IN NON BJP RULING STATES,NEET,IMPOSITION OF HINDHI, GDP LOSS, Aadhar, religon based politics Etc.. & yet lot will come once in a week that is their stretegy to confuse people against which they should protes of fight
This is purely a wasteful project for Indians where 8% (10 crores- 100 millions are poverty stricken and beggars) of the total exploded population in Bharat desh. On whose money this project is implemented? In bullet train the ticket fare is more than flight charge. Just 5 compartments !. So many 'passenger trains' are required for our Bharath citizens. This Bullet train is a waste of public money. This govt supports only rich. The present govt policies makes rich to poor and poor to beggars. Looting hard earned money in digital system in banks in intolerable by the HIG,MIG,LIG and BIG (Beggars income group). Only British can save us..They looted only to a minimum extent. They helped Bharath to grow. Farmers are suffering. This BULLET money should have been spent to agricultural sector and water sharing. Prices are high because of GST!!
Re: just 4 compartment for the rich BJP
by Divakar Shetty on Sep 14, 2017 09:57 PM
You seems to be a top grade economist. Better look for job instead of spreading know in rediff.
Some one said in earlier life you were cribbing when training introduced by Britishers in India, same way your writing today
Re: just 4 compartment for the rich BJP
by vadivudaiselvi on Sep 15, 2017 11:19 PM
Certainly ur vie is correct, this is a utter wasrte project, the proposed fare is more than the flight charges. it is only waste of public money to project Modi as a reformer, the country is reeling under sever crisis, 300 childres died due to non availability of oxigen in BJP ruled state UP, CANT UNDERSTAND How these dictators throw money & resources for a failure projects.GDP GOING DOWN DAY BY DAY, Job loss simply false promises wont work for long This person will ruin the economy before he leaves by 2019.only brainless pple & corrupt Gujju Buisness community, & Sangis will shout for him.
Re: just 4 compartment for the rich BJP
by Masu S on Sep 17, 2017 07:58 AM
Well said rajendran, Most of BJP ministers does not have knowledge on how to run government, congress is still better with corruption,
Log-in to My-Family-Doctor at myfamilydoc do co dot in & get 50 Percent off on any test at any Diagnostic lab,CTscan,MRIscan centre of your choice in your city throughout India. No need for unnecessary health pckgs, GET DIRECT DISCOUNT EVEN ON A SINGLE TEST.
He failed to penalise single person termed corrupt under UPA regime by him. He failed to bring ache din in all terms even when petroleum price is lowest. Only gullible common men are happy with his step of notebandi considering black money holders are more hurt than them. He failed to create sab ke sath sab ke vikas and hindu hooliganism is rampant. If he is allowed one more term Indians will fight with themselves over language and culture. Bajpayee created express way and gone. Let him also go with bullet train. Let us consider NaMo a failed mission and be ready to tolerate financial corruption behind than the serious downward movement of all on the face.
Re: A failed mission
by MNN on Sep 14, 2017 07:46 PM
This very financial corruption which you are ready to face again& again, shows how short sighted you are & all those who cling on to such a view. The corruption is like a parasite, it has penetrated deep in to the system , from where it refuses to budge . And if people are asking for reports on all the points mentioned, i fail to understand, why we never seeked a report card from the previous se tof govt over 60 yrs. Garibi hatao , was one of the clarion call. Did Garibi go away? Why ? Did you ask that question Soumitra. If not why ? Accepted there is hardships, but if you want to change the situation, some real hard actions are needed. The mute question is are we as a nation , willing to bring about the change in each one of us , looks no to me , but i am still being optimistic, as some one is trying sincerely to change the narrative.
Re: Re: Re: A failed mission
by Divakar Shetty on Sep 14, 2017 09:48 PM
You think progress means your personal growth? Nothing more nothing less.. cribbing has become your daily routine. Do some work, you will progress. Sitting abusing will grow only abuse around....
Re: Re: Re: Re: A failed mission
by haya vada na on Sep 14, 2017 10:22 PM
Diwaker you dont know one thing that MR, Vidwan soni is not having vidwath at all and somitra goswami may be a nearer person to cummins who have spoiled some part of India and China and so its better to neglect these blind people
Re: Re: Re: A failed mission
by Rajendran Srinivasan on Sep 14, 2017 10:20 PM
failed demonetisation, failed GST, abnormal price rise for tax paying poor, BJP makes rich to poor, poor to beggars and supporting super rich for party funds generation.
Re: Re: Re: A failed mission
by P S SHAH on Sep 15, 2017 07:48 PM
Duffer Soni, I thought you are Duffer but now I think you are blind also. Better check your brain and eye sight.
Bullet train needs dedicated tracks and will burden the middle class with more taxes for decades. It is a huge strain .
Bullet train is not a commodity item like maruti car or cellphone. Therefore it will remain out of reach of common man.
What Modi should have done was focus on Spanish Talgo trains which can go upto 200 kmph on existing tracks and also upgrade all coaches on Indian trains to lighter german design. speeds of upto 150 kmph should have been made the norm.
Re: Wrong comparison
by ASHOK UPADHYAYA on Sep 14, 2017 02:11 PM
Why we need aeroplanes airports for internal travels? Our country has been kept poor for almost 70 years....Japan China all have progressed much where as our country is still considered developing country.... Corruption, Gandgi, Indiscipline are the main causes of our non development....Bullet train will give jobs, new technology... In future we will assist other countries for bullet. Train n technology...
Re: Re: Wrong comparison
by Rakesh Dandekar on Sep 14, 2017 03:11 PM
whatever you said is not from govt but it is from us. everything like corruption, gandgi, indiscipline are made by people and not govt. if you are correct not a single govt can do any corruption. First we have to improve. some one says like mobile, maruti cars are reach to common man who can afford but not bullet train. Yes it is required but only time will tell how much job creation in this bullet trainl Japnees workers never go on strike instead of they produce more than requirement and ask the management to sell and give bonus but in India every thing we have get from strike.Bullet train announced today simultaneously they should take care of Mumbai local train where common people are travelling. We are master only for 70 years rule and not any problem today are facing.
Re: Re: Wrong comparison
by India.Today on Sep 14, 2017 09:45 PM
do you know between this 500 odd kms., how many stops are envisaged for this particular train ? i guess that would bring down the speed to less than that of Shatabdi. Then what is the use of having a bullet train if it has to be stopped at all stations in the first instance.
Secondly, stop shifting blame to previous governments for the failures of BJP administration. we are tired of hearing 60 / 70 years of governance achieved nothing for the country. Now, if anyone is found using this language, i would advise his friends to take such persons to mental assylum.
Re: Re: Re: Wrong comparison
by India.Today on Sep 14, 2017 09:47 PM
and the feasibility study for bullet trains were started and the works were in progress since 2006. this was not BJPs project but was started by earlier governemnts. so, stop shifting credit to anyone. It is India's project and only people of India would decide if they require it.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Wrong comparison
by B B Sharma on Sep 15, 2017 11:34 AM
Mr Abe is Japan`s top sales man - he has sold the bullet train idea to India even though cost consideration had edged the Japanese out in Indonesia & Thailand where China has been the gainer.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Wrong comparison
by B B Sharma on Sep 15, 2017 12:41 PM
I still fail to understand how bullet train would attain a speed of 350 KM / hour & for how long , when 12 stops are purposed in a total distance of 500 KM ? Further it would have been more prudent & appropriate to have metros in at least 10 odd cities instead a single bullet train from Ahmedabad to Mumbai , provided if there are some other extraneous considerations
Re: Re: Wrong comparison
by V S on Sep 16, 2017 12:03 AM
bullet train will give jobs ? sure. you can create more jobs by supporting millions of small businesses in India
Re: Wrong comparison
by MNN on Sep 14, 2017 07:49 PM
VS i feel that will also happen, the Talgo & German design trains , will also come . Just that there should be more fillip or push from their respective govts, the way the Japanese have done. They are prepared for the long haul.
Re: Wrong comparison
by K G on Sep 14, 2017 12:43 PM
With what MRV says, we are getting interest free loan for bullet trains. So the majority of repayment will be footed from the revenue. But yes taxes might be levied for it. For that matter won't we incur more taxes if we go with Talgo option for which funding of this sort won't come and we need to borrow at higher interest rate?!!!
Also MRV has answered it. It is not this or that. We need Bullet trains in some select sectors, Talgo in some existing routes & lines, Rajdhanis and Shatabdis with increased speed, and finally the expresses and passengers with increased speed to cater to all class of people. So all possible options have to be worked on, and not instead of this that. Nehru onwards every PM of India has been saying that Rlys is India's backbone for commutation. If so it cannot have one sarva roga nivarani. It needs multiple methods of modernization and betterment with appropriate lessening of burden and shrewd ways.
What we should worry about is how we would operate and maintain it. They should not endup like Volvo buses of TNSTC which are also breaking down in Chennai!!!
When farmers are struggling to make a living,this wasteful project is to be stopped at all costs.Instead this Rs.98000 crores would be well spent on water resources,infrastructure improvement,education et c.One would hope some socially powerful people will put a PIL to stop this project
Re: Waste of a project
by MS Vasan on Sep 14, 2017 01:39 PM
Not 98,000 crores but more are coming from Japan... That is Modi's power of negotiation....Japan will NOT give 98,000 crores to repay the farmers...but the farmers enroute on the bullet train will make money from booming real estate appreciation...
Re: Re: Waste of a project
by Rajendran Srinivasan on Sep 14, 2017 10:22 PM
Farmers can travel in bullock carts not in bullet train. Even u cannot travel.. soooo costly. Only for rich BJP people
Re: Waste of a project
by MNN on Sep 14, 2017 07:53 PM
Just happened to read in the newspapers, that more than 50% of the farmers seeking loan waiver are fake . So who is the real farmer? and who created these fakes. We the people of this country. Now , at least do people understand , what corruption is doing to this country & still people prefer financial corruption. I feel pity on such people.
Re: Waste of a project
by Ramesh Koushik on Sep 14, 2017 11:24 AM
So much money was spent for the purposes which you mentioned. What came out of them? Who prevented the previous rulers from getting the benefits out of these expenses to people?
Re: Re: Waste of a project
by ASHOK UPADHYAYA on Sep 14, 2017 02:17 PM
Debt waiver is not the solution... Congress PC has set bad precedent.....every year you can not waive loans.. small n marginal farm is main problem... there are also other poorer people in the country who do not have even land house...
Re: Re: Re: Waste of a project
by sridhar pathy on Sep 14, 2017 04:40 PM
what about connecting all rivers in india.It would be better instead of bullet train
