Does anyone know the plight of those who died on account of this Project Nano Blunder? Can any one give the total loss in 10 yrs, on account of this blunder? In terms of loss to Tata's, loss to farmers, money spent on Courts, running around leaving their bread earning jobs for the poor etc.? Above all, can anyone answer who & why they wanted only this place for the Project, ruining already scarce farm land? More often than not, such blunders cost India too much.
Re: no industry will survive in bengal
by paul theo on Sep 22, 2016 12:05 PM
IF CONGRESS WAS NOT THERE , YOU WOULD HAVE STILL BEEN A SLAVE OF THE BRITISH. WHILE THE RSS WERE HIDING DURING FREEDOM STRUGGLE.
Re: Re: no industry will survive in bengal
by Ashwin on Sep 22, 2016 12:14 PM
You are probably not aware that Gandhi & Congress which fought British & Gandhi/Nehru Congress which ruled/ruined India are 2 totally different entities. Mahatma Gandhi wanted Congress disbanded after Independence since the job of Congress was over after Independence. Political Party under Nehru named itself Congress, to gain Votes from the innocent Indians who do not know that Gandhiji is dead long ago & the Gandhi in Politics is different. That is India. If present day Congress had ruled properly, without corruption of all kinds, they would not have lost their existence in several States and also in the Center. If some Congress has fought for India's Independence, present day Congress can not take credit. Do you think, I will be made Prime Minister of India, if I name myself Jawaharlal Nehru or Rajiv Gandhi? At least educated people must think pragmatically.
Re: Re: Re: no industry will survive in bengal
by Ashwin on Sep 22, 2016 12:21 PM
The only good thing Congress Party has done in their 70 yrs Rule, is Division of United Andhra Pradesh & formation of Separate Telangana. Today Andhra people rue that the division was not as per their wish. But they dont recollect that even merger of Andhra with Hyderabad State (Telangana) was without the consent of Telangana people. In fact, Fazal Ali Commission, specially appointed to study & recommend, has clearly recommended that the 2 States should not be merged. Look into the matter after 5 years.But Andhras merged with Telangana with Gentlemen's Agreement which was violated in word & deed, for 60 yrs, to loot and ruin Telangana. Brijesh Kumar expressed his shock & commented "how Telangana people tolerated such unjustice for 60 yrs"? He was dealing with Krishna River water sharing between Andhra & Telangana and this is his opinion. He was not from Telangana, to support Telangana. This is what happens when alround corruption and greed takes place. As you sow, so you reap
Re: Re: no industry will survive in bengal
by Lakshmoji on Sep 25, 2016 05:59 AM
Today's Congress is like Kejriwal's AAP. Today's Congress milked freedom struggle Congress and survived, AAP is milking Anna Hazare's movement and surviving.
Don't link today's Congress to freedom struggle. That Congress saved India from British and this Congress made India an Italian slave.
Anyhow those who are sold for a rice bag and liquor bottle do not understand this.
The judgement of the Courts is fair and as per law. Private or Govt. are not allowed to acquire agricultural land for setting up Industries. Land which fall under the category of NA (Non-agricultural), Barren or Govt Land is best suited for acquisition for Industries.
The same problem was faced by Posco in Orissa as the land being procured was being used by generations for growing betel leaves which is a cash crop.
The site selection was wrong and on top of that the developers failed to manage the stakeholders and obtain their consent before finalizing the sites.
Perhaps, the Bengal has no future. The left had tried to moderate themselves and tried to create industrial environment in Bengal. It is only people of Bengal who chosen this fate for them by electing this government.
Re: This is a setback for the indian industries
by paul theo on Sep 22, 2016 12:06 PM
TATAS HAVE LOST HUGE AMOUNT OF MONEY BECAUSE OF IMPROPER POLITICAL DECISIONS , WHO WILL PAY FOR THEIR LOSSES?WILL THE JUSTICE SYSTEM DECIDE THAT TOO.
From News paper report it has been noted that the Factory shed road etc was constructed by TATA Motors over around 73 acre land and one water body of 40 acres also created by TATA . Now as per news report this sheds are to be dismantled and to be converted to Agriculture land . This sheds may be used for small scale Agro Industries and there is no need to dismantle it . The local earlier land owners willing to form co operative and run small industry may take over land along with shed, road , Water body for developing small industry at Singur . This proposal may be examined by experts to help the local people . The land where there was no construction may be used as cultivation land. Thanks . Tapas Biswas . mob --9432174445
No one is bothered to control the unwanted population there. Everyone is anti industry or business community how the State can flourish, cannot increase land, rather more and more urbanisation is being done.
Re: Re: Re: Bengal
by arungopal agarwal on Sep 22, 2016 04:53 PM
In last 70 years, we could not provide employment to all, rather unemployment increased, do not live in fools paradise.
Re: SALUTE TO DIDI!
by Raman Krishnaswamy on Sep 21, 2016 08:49 PM
Concern for the poorest ? What a laugh ! Lakhs of poorest of the poor have been robbed of their life earnings by the Rs 65 lakhs Narada scam and the Rs 15000 crore Saradha Chit Fund scam.
