No compensation can ever pacify the looser (farmers), who loss their livelihood forever. If a midway could be found to safeguard the land ownership right of a landowners followed by an immediate compensation for loss of livelihoods, the process of land acquisition for industry from private landowners would be smoother and peaceful. However, with certain pre-conditions, a model framework for amicable resolution can be developed. Land acquisition for industry appears to touch one major components of land economics, which keeps functional linkage with other three primary factors of Industry i.e., labour, capital (resources), and organization (management). Since classical economists identify Land, Labour, Capital and Organization as four primary stakeholders for any industrial unit, each of such component including land conceptually reserves at least one-fourth (25) of share of total value of an industry. An industry coming up in a land often enjoys land acquisition right over government land by paying nominal price to Government. However, private lands, belonging to farmers or local inhabitants and consisting of small portion of Industrial area, need to be only acquired through a long term lease agreement with landowners without snatching the landownership right from them. During the acquisition of land for Industry development, ownership right of private land owners should not be fully sold out to industry or government. Rather,it should be given to the industry under lease.
Re: Pro farmer solution for SEZ
by sampurnananda mahapatra on May 19, 2010 03:22 PM
This means, neither the government nor the entrepreneur operating in Industrial area would enjoy absolute ownership right of land acquired from private owners. By adopting such a framework, the landowners would earn the selling value of their land at prevailing market price without losing their ownership right. With renewal of lease period of every 25 years, the landowners will be continuing to earn selling value of their land prevailing that time. In spite of transferring the land use right to industrialist, the landowners would have guaranty of employment for at least one bread earner of their families. As a shareholder of the industry, the landowners will be earning income periodically from dividends. Since original landowners would hold the shares of industry, they could at any time sell their shares, as if selling of their land to others. Similarly, with such amicable deal with local landowners, industrialists would be able to easily acquire land and would be welcomed in any proposed area for land acquisition. SEZ, as being sarcastically called as special exploitation zone, would be regarded by the public as social enrichment zone with adoption of such a framework.
Acharya Budhimaan, you have put it to an extent correctly. We definitely need industrial product, but there should be a balance. Never weigh industrialization as development. Thats foolish totally. If a farmer has become rich by selling his land, he will have and so do you, loads of cash but no food to buy?! that will be true if your so called industrialization is extended all over India. What industry are you talking about. Of course, there should be something put in place in order to improvise on that. But you cannot bring a dated technology and sell it at a premium in India. Be it anything from Energy converting equipments (including automotive), or if you think real estate development (which is nothing but converting cleaner country side into a concrete rubble full of dust). There should be ethics followed like Good construction practice, Good Manufacturing practices etc. I think there should be a balance on preservation of eco-system and Industrialization. We should think more seriously on population control rather than thinking it as market pool to increase companies revenue.
we the original people of india, the aborginals who are into places far as NZ, Papua, Aus, Fiji
we have been in tough situation with sanskritized ( bengali, tamil, Odiya, etc) language people for long time.
Tamil and sinhalese (from lanka) are sanskritized as well though they are in denial about it.
We dont want to be prisoner of angrezi, the Purest aboriginal languages is Maori and purest of our stock are in Paupua and NZ. Under oppression of Angrezi.
Re: all tribal areas of india should merge
by acharya buddhimaan on Oct 25, 2009 07:28 PM
DS,
How double standard you are? How much immoral and a hypocrite you are? You are writing on a computer with a power source and still talking against industries as if you are a very pious supporter of farmers. You are using computer, power generation industries, equipments, your vehicle all are part of industries which requires acres of land. Farmers too need electricity and equipments to carry out their farming which again depends on setting out industries. The western countries are superdeveloped not because of farmers or farmland but because of industries and services. Come on look at communist China - a ideology which boasts of protecting the interests of farmers and peasants. The concept of SEZ is from China and if China can get acres of land and become an economic superpower why not India? And how do you think India become prosperpous without industries and land for setting the same? Are ou visualizing an India prosperpous without industries!!!
Now back to the comment on farmers as beggars. Which part of India have farmers turned beggars because of not giving suitable compensation. Come to Gurgaon and Delhi where the same farmers have sold their small land holdings to industries and real estate and today they are 100 times richer than you. COME AND SEE FIRST AND THEN COMMENT!
Dear friend, before typing against setting up of industries be sure that you are not using the equipments like computer hardware, kitchen ware, bathroom fittings, pen etc...
Re: Re: all tribal areas of india should merge
by D S on Oct 25, 2009 08:07 PM
Dont_convert_tribals_to_civilize_just_restore_our_OLD_lifestyle by D S on Oct 14, 2009 08:04 PM
We DONT NEED LURES AND TOO MUCH OF THIS money that spoils..
Tribals never had malnutrition when they lived the jungle lifestyle,
Re: Re: all tribal areas of india should merge
by Krishnadas kiran on Feb 12, 2010 09:14 AM
Acharya Budhimaan, you have put it to an extent correctly. We definitely need industrial product, but there should be a balance. Never weigh industrialization as development. Thats foolish totally. If a farmer has become rich by selling his land, he will have and so do you, loads of cash but no food to buy?! that will be true if your so called industrialization is extended all over India. What industry are you talking about. Of course, there should be something put in place in order to improvise on that. But you cannot bring a dated technology and sell it at a premium in India. Be it anything from Energy converting equipments (including automotive), or if you think real estate development (which is nothing but converting cleaner country side into a concrete rubble full of dust). There should be ethics followed like Good construction practice, Good Manufacturing practices etc. I think there should be a balance on preservation of eco-system and Industrialization. We should think more seriously on population control rather than thinking it as market pool to increase companies revenue.
Re: Re: all tribal areas of india should merge
by Krishnadas kiran on Feb 12, 2010 09:14 AM
Acharya Budhimaan, you have put it to an extent correctly. We definitely need industrial product, but there should be a balance. Never weigh industrialization as development. Thats foolish totally. If a farmer has become rich by selling his land, he will have and so do you, loads of cash but no food to buy?! that will be true if your so called industrialization is extended all over India. What industry are you talking about. Of course, there should be something put in place in order to improvise on that. But you cannot bring a dated technology and sell it at a premium in India. Be it anything from Energy converting equipments (including automotive), or if you think real estate development (which is nothing but converting cleaner country side into a concrete rubble full of dust). There should be ethics followed like Good construction practice, Good Manufacturing practices etc. I think there should be a balance on preservation of eco-system and Industrialization. We should think more seriously on population control rather than thinking it as market pool to increase companies revenue.
Re: A Question
by Sunit Kumar on Oct 25, 2009 06:40 AM
Thats the point isnt it ? After completely destroying the Bengali Civilization and realizing how wrong they were, they now want to pull rest of the India down too, so that in the course of time WASTE Bengal will be ok !!!
Re: Re: A Question
by D S on Oct 25, 2009 06:15 PM
What bengal and what bhojpuri??
we are the original people of india, the aborginals who are into places far as NZ, Papua, Aus, Fiji, india
we have been in tough situation with sanskritized ( bengali, tamil, Odiya, etc) language people for long time.
Tamil and sinhalese (from lanka) are sanskritized as well though they are in denial about it.
We dont want to be prisoner of angrezi as well, the Purest aboriginal languages is Maori and purest of our stock are in Paupua and NZ. Under the direct oppression of Angrezi. the angrezi will be punished to the most severest of HELL, God will personally remove them and their lackeys from the earth.
Graham staines was angrez, the same angrez that destroyed Aborginals fully in Australia and NZ.
Gyypsies in India are not making it easy for us. They just copy and steeal for their state.
Re: Re: Re: A Question
by D S on Oct 25, 2009 06:19 PM
killing of Staines was NOTHING in comparison to destruction, killing and starving of millions of aborginals in Auz, Nz, Fiji, Pupua, Americas...
The remaining don the angrezi names so they can erase us fully by taking away our land and women by giving them jobs.
Re: Re: Re: Re: A Question
by acharya buddhimaan on Oct 25, 2009 07:30 PM
Vijaya Vittal,
How double standard you are? How much immoral and a hypocrite you are? You are writing on a computer with a power source and still talking against industries as if you are a very pious supporter of farmers. You are using computer, power generation industries, equipments, your vehicle all are part of industries which requires acres of land. Farmers too need electricity and equipments to carry out their farming which again depends on setting out industries. The western countries are superdeveloped not because of farmers or farmland but because of industries and services. Come on look at communist China - a ideology which boasts of protecting the interests of farmers and peasants. The concept of SEZ is from China and if China can get acres of land and become an economic superpower why not India? And how do you think India become prosperpous without industries and land for setting the same? Are ou visualizing an India prosperpous without industries!!!
Now back to the comment on farmers as beggars. Which part of India have farmers turned beggars because of not giving suitable compensation. Come to Gurgaon and Delhi where the same farmers have sold their small land holdings to industries and real estate and today they are 100 times richer than you. COME AND SEE FIRST AND THEN COMMENT!
Dear friend, before typing against setting up of industries be sure that you are not using the equipments like computer hardware, kitchen ware, bathroom fittings, pen etc...
The need of the hour is to provide opportunities for growth, which is urgently required for the employment of our unemployed/underemployed population. Towards that end, the private investors must be invited to invest and start projects. There is no denying that these private players work for profits, but do we now live under those conditions which would allow us to provide employment for the jobless without the role of the private investors? So, let us admit that - at least for the time being - the SEZs are required, which give an edge to the orivate investors. Of course, efforts may be taken to ensure a better deal for the farmers and the workers, but NOT at the cost of the SEZs.
Re: Need of the hour
by Rajendra Nayak on Oct 20, 2009 05:55 AM
Harmohan Roy, The article and the replies are going to extremes. Having sound knowledge of International law we have to understand that we have signed certain treaties and conventions which clearly mention about the free movement of service providers. For the time being, some of us can get employment but later on, they can bring anybody they want from South East Asia and Visa cannot be denied. If Visa is denied to outsiders, then there will be tit for tat situation and Indians will be the losers. The worst scenario in India is that politicians have all the freedom to do what they want, nothing is debated and no body cares for good views.Majority of the politicians have only 20 to 25% backing in the form of valid votes and they do the acts for the majority. Getting employment for the locals in SEZ, is a big question mark because every Industry has a right to bring it's own people whom they want to employ. At International level if you talk of 'Sons and duaghters of the soil'they will move to SriLanka or African countries or elsewhere which are peaceful countries.
CPIM Communist Act from 30 years in West Benal is unconstitutional for poor, poor population is increased in WB because of 1000's of industries closed in WB. And WB which has India's first underground Metro trains is also one the poorest state in India after Bihar.
Re: CPIM Communist Act from 30 years in West Benal is unconstitut
by Haramohan Roy on Oct 19, 2009 08:58 PM
What relevance does this post (forget about the authenticity of the contents) have with the topic at hand?
Re: Re: CPIM Communist Act from 30 years in West Benal is unconst
by Venu Gopalan on Oct 25, 2009 10:40 PM
THERE ARE TWO STATES IN INDIA ONE IN EAST ONE IN SOUTH ,ONE IS RULED BY CPM LED FRONT FOE THREE DECADES AND ONE IS RULED ALTERNATE BY C.P.M &CON:LED FRONTS.TO SEE THE DIFFERENCE SEE PICTURES AFTER CYCLON HIT IN SUNDERBAN AND 24 PARGANA DISTS JUST BEFORE THE MONSOON .I WONDER STILL SUCH PLACES ARE EXISTING IN BENGAL .
Re: Re: CPIM Communist Act from 30 years in West Benal is unconst
by Sunit Kumar on Oct 25, 2009 06:42 AM
Oh so ur a communist supporter but GOOD communist's right ? Thats like saying the good teaching of koran.....
Why such articles are published? You dont have anything betterto report or she owns a large stake of yours using her black money collected from antinational groups?
Re: Misleading
by Devdutt Sen on Oct 19, 2009 01:40 PM
I am surprised that this article is lingering on the website whereas other important ones are getting replaced. something fishy
