Its rediculus on the side of Politicians, playing games with innocent farmers, who cannot make their decission But these politicians play games to save their skin
Re: tata may charge 1.5 per car
by b gar on Sep 11, 2008 10:12 AM
no one buy a car to help someone, one buy a car for his need and comfortness, if hurndreds of people decide to reject this car still he could sell this car to thousands of people, for a businessman legend like Ratan Tata it is easy to find a market always for his goods. When u are making some big projects like this some people will suffer and many people will be benefit. you are focusing only on one man Ratan tata, not focusing on job oppertunities and millions of families live because of this project and economic growth. So like Tata said think big then u will know what to do.
Re: tata may charge 1.5 per car
by paresnath ray on Sep 11, 2008 10:04 AM
Foolish comment. TATA should leave Singure & in the process may loose around Rs.500 Crore, but if they continue they must be ready to loose many Rs.500 crores over a period as there will be no derth of crooks like Mamata & Associates who live for their selfish Power.
Re: MAMATA - the Maruti and BAJAJ Chairman
by Hot Romantic on Sep 11, 2008 09:40 AM
You are absoultely correct. She is getting lots of money to do all these nonsense activity. If she had the intention of not giving land to Tatas, she could have done this type of agitation from the begining. Initially she had protested but it was only a drama.
Re: MAMATA - the Maruti and BAJAJ Chairman
by azumithal on Sep 11, 2008 10:00 AM
i am sorry but i know the deal and it is bad for farmers and do not believe what media is playing out for Tatas
Re: Re: MAMATA - the Maruti and BAJAJ Chairman
by Biswajit Das on Sep 11, 2008 10:51 AM
We need job are more job...we educated Bengalies needs hi-tech and skilled job...not the farming...farming would not save ourselves as well as Bengals...but Industrialization can save farmers as well as others...
azumithal...leave your selfish thinking...we become terrorist if we not getting job...
Re: MAMATA - the Maruti and BAJAJ Chairman
by Biswajit Das on Sep 11, 2008 10:46 AM
farmers are not the savers of West Bengal...even farming is not profitable...why should we stick on that? We need to hunt new business to save ourselves...It is the industrialization and IT business which can save BENGAL...
Re: Re: Nirupam Sen is behaving like Tata's Industry Minister !!
by Hot Romantic on Sep 11, 2008 09:49 AM
CPM had done nasty politics for the last 30 years with dharnas and strikes. As a result West Bengal's economic growth was hindered. Now the same role is taken by another nonsence lady. Do you think that 400 acre land which is full of fly ash and concrete, demanded by them (Trinamul) can be cultivated anymore. They just want to sale off that land and earn brokerage. We must not loose our sense due to political inclination.
Re: There are tons of land just oppsite to the mother plant across NH2
by Saugata Sarkar on Sep 11, 2008 09:49 AM
No one should cooperate with you and your didi, let alone Tata. Your didi is going to lose her LS seat and your 30 MLAs strength would be reduced to 20. Wait and watch. If Nirupam Sen is Tata Motors MD, in your words, Mamata is a chaprasi of Rahul Bajaj.
Re: Re: There are tons of land just oppsite to the mother plant across NH2
by Biswajit Das on Sep 11, 2008 10:54 AM
Have you any idea of Automobile Engineering? or Civil Engg. or Architecture? Even 97% Bengalies welcoming TATA NANO are you are not on that 97%
Re: There are tons of land just oppsite to the mother plant across NH2
by kaustav ghosal on Sep 11, 2008 09:45 AM
do you really know the concepts like Just in Time approach to production ? Don't just make demands for making demands
Ratan Tata is grasping poor farmers land from the WB government and distributing it among its so called vendors.These vendors will sell this at exhorbitant price in futere.
Re: Singur
by arnab ghosh on Sep 11, 2008 09:25 AM
who the hell r u,do u know the exact scenario,why will the vendors sell the land,the land is going to be used for their use which is in the supply line for the Nano project
Re: Singur
by kaustav ghosal on Sep 11, 2008 09:47 AM
Typical mindset of a antidevelopment activist. Sideline with the likes of ultra leftists who want to take back iNdia to stone age like Khemer Rouge triedd in cambodia
Re: Singur
by Arnab Banerjee on Sep 11, 2008 09:26 AM
What do you think after getting the land back the farmers will start farming ? Defifnitely not they will also sell that off.
Mr. Ratan Tata is not there at Singur to earn money from land brokery, it is Manna & allied who want this brokarage
Re: Re: Singur
by grv iyer on Sep 11, 2008 09:29 AM
We know what this government has done to farmers for the last 40 years. People like Ashim think that farmers life will become miserable just because of Tata's entry. It is a mistake done by Tata, when the rest of the country wants him to open his plant at their place, he choosed the wrong place where wrong policies exist.
In India one can never trust the government! How would Ratan Tata not know this! They are there only to make life miserable. Even the CBI can't be trusted. Its Complete Bakwas Investigations. Mera Bharat Mahaan!
Re: Ratan don't have any mamta....just go!
by Ankur on Sep 11, 2008 09:18 AM
Atleast u get quality of service in these private hospitals. They also have trusts wchich take of poor.
Have ever been to a government hospital. Check out Sion Hospital & Cooper. They make you beg / bribe for an appointment. U r not alloted beds. U are asked to take the same expensive tests which a private hospital will ask u to undergo. There is every risk that u make contact some other disease. I think ur knowledge on the condition of government managed hospitals is extremely limited.
ALso to take a loan from private or public sector bank is ur own decision & the one takes the decision has to suffer
Re: Ratan don't have any mamta....just go!
by WINSTON NORONHA on Sep 11, 2008 10:00 AM
I am sorry that your knowledge is so poor about Private and Government Hospitals. I have worked inPrivate Hospitals for last 11 years and prior to that for 9 years in KEM and Sion Hospitals. The surgeries performed there are of the highest quality. In fact most of the patients brought from the bomb blasts and riots were treated in these hospitals with very good results. Due to heavy load surgeries are prioritised while in private hospitals surgeries are scheduled depending on the paying capacity of the individual
Re: Ratan don't have any mamta....just go!
by SAIKAT BASU on Sep 11, 2008 09:36 AM
Have u ever thought why still people go to government hospitals? Because pvt hospitals cannot be afforded. Then what is the use of its QOS to 95% of indian population.They have to rely on govt. hospitals.
Re: Ratan don't have any mamta....just go!
by Adobe on Sep 11, 2008 09:14 AM
Allright, send your kind to the Govt school, where the teacher rarely comes to the school and if he does, will be sleeping in his room.
Re: Ratan don't have any mamta....just go!
by Arvind Singh on Sep 11, 2008 09:18 AM
Govt in India is nothing. It is group people selected/elected by us. and then we blame our Govt. I am 36 years old, when ever I go to any govt place. I see people like me working Till now, I am unable to see Govt. So we must raise our morals and of our kids if we want Govt to improve. No Govt is good, People make it best. In pvt sector, you choose high end professional to tweak the rules for max. profit, telling it cut throat competition. Although I think pvt sector are bring good and faster response but finally you are shelling out of your pocket. I respect pvt sectors but Govt things are working at the best level. Only problem is India's Huge population. Once we control it our govt will be best. So I would say, My Govt is mirror of myself. I see what I am. Wake up Indians and Govt will automatically rise. Jai Hind.
Re: Ratan don't have any mamta....just go!
by Ankur on Sep 11, 2008 09:35 AM
SO what have done to change your not so good mirror image. I have the couarge to admit I have done nothing. BUt since u r giving so much gyan tell what u ve done for the country People like u r just nuatankis. Tomorow a close relative fall sick u will rush him to private hospital. U wont wait for the formalities in public hospitals. If you r the one who walks ur talk u will fight teh system & get ur relative admitted in public hospital even if that means that he could die. WIll ur kids go to government schools? If u need change first have the guts to do it on ur own before preaching.
Re: Ratan don't have any mamta....just go!
by surendra joshi on Sep 11, 2008 09:26 AM
i agree 100% we give no moral values to our kids and ultimately they will make tomorrow
Re: Ratan don't have any mamta....just go!
by Biswajit Das on Sep 11, 2008 09:22 AM
"CHAASI BHAI JINDIBAD" we are all educating to become a farmer!!! and farmers are too educating their children to be absorbed by "CHASSABAD" TATA-ji go back, there are only farmers family to exist, there in no place to think of industrialization in West Bengal! All of the BENGALIES should start learning farming... Long live NOXALITES, MAMATA DIDI... All of the anti farmers are the real enemy of West Bengal, they should leave the state immediately... they should go to the other sataes or even outside the country...
Re: Ratan don't have any mamta....just go!
by mahesh kumar on Sep 11, 2008 09:23 AM
dear sirs, you are all looking only political angel of this issue, try to understand the business issue, tata's after al discussions and delibarations got the land which they wanted and bangal govt assured them that they will get taht, later a politician (mamta) came in and created all rubbish, please try to see thing without the politoical angel, unfortunatly today all indians are only interested in chatpati political news, nobody is interested in the things which requires brains to analyse.
