I have been observing the various articles being published in rediff since long time. Now my doubt is confirmed, Rediff is not only anti Hindus, Anti BJP and anti majority of India but Rediff is inclined to being anti-India on the whole and seems to be playing in the hands of foreign agencies to tarnish the iamge of India on the whole and also halt the progress of India ... shame on you rediff ... may be that rediff takes this comment in a positive sense and do something to improve its image in the general public .. and mind well, I have formed this opinion after being a staunch supporter of rediff ...
The WB state government did offer similar incentives to the Tatas while trying to get them set-up the plant at Singur. This fact has come to light later. This is an essential step that every state government needs to take to attract industry to the state.
WHY IS THIS CONTROVERY IN CASE OF GUJARAT? THE CONGRESS POLITICIANS SHOULD BE CONCERNED ABOUT THE US$ 1.8 TRILLION THAT IS STASHED AWAY BY THEM IN THE SWISS BANKS.
YOU CANNOT LOOT THE COUNTRY IN THE NAME OF 'SECULARISM' ANY MORE.
It is really sad to see this discussion forum instead of debating on the issue of `Sops for Nano'has got into Communalism & Regionalism. Sticking to the main issue I would like to make the following points :- 1) The tax Sops given for NANO are Fully Deserving Because it will create so much of employment (Direct & Indirect)in the state. 2) Also the TAX Money already collected by the Government goes into the Bottomless Drain of CORRUPTION & MISMANAGEMENT. So it is better to forego some tax & Bring in Jobs & Development. 3) Just Look at the U.S.A. There too the Government is not only giving SOPS but also pumping in Public Money to Save Drowning Companies. So no harm if a few SOPS are given in order to bring about Employment & Development. 4) The NANO is a project which will revolutionise the Auto World & hence it is a project which will bring India into The world Auto Map & thus it deserves all the support it neeeds. 5) The article also says about the cost of building infrastructure for the project. Isnt it the Governments responsibility anyway to build good infrastructure ?
Re: The Price Gujarat Paid for NANO is worth
by santosh chaudhari on Mar 18, 2009 09:49 AM Permalink
one day there will be no land for farming and forest.then you will eat nano cars produced by tatas.Ratan tata is a business man and he thinks like one.If Ratan tata and Narendra modi are so considerate about people why they are not investing in farming.has any body considered farming as a employment.industrialization will only bring global warming and industrial waste.narendra modi forgets the population of the country when speaking about development.one day we'll be importing food grains from other countries for us.it will be same as gulf countries selling oil for food.it's same that most of people of india see concrete jungle and industries as development.if human race need to servive then industrialization should be very limited and the leaders should device ways for stoping population explosion in our country.
Re: The Price Gujarat Paid for NANO is worth
by sudipta sarkar on Nov 14, 2008 10:13 AM Permalink
Automobile factories across the world are largely automated. Therefore large-scale employment cannot be expected in an otherwise populated country like India from such industries(even the anciliaries). Well, tax for the government and employment for some automobile engineers may be expected from such an investment.
Re: The Price Gujarat Paid for NANO is worth
by sumit mukherjee on Nov 14, 2008 10:29 AM Permalink
Even automated plants need manpower my friend. Case in point, Maruti.
Sir, Gujarat and Maharashtra are the two states really promoting the industries with good spirits. Tata wold have taken withdraw the project from Singur a year back when the issues raised politically. For the political milage Ms Mamata Banerjee shattered the dreams of youger generation. The whole world keenly watch the negetive development took place in Bengal and the Bengalies has to wait for a long time to develope the state economically Thanks A.Surendran [suranair310@gmail.com]
Re: Nano Project
by sudipta sarkar on Nov 14, 2008 10:02 AM Permalink
The CPIM/Left Front shattered the dreams of many many more young when they chased all industries out of Bengal. The damage the Left Front did in West Bengal is irreversible.The mindset of the people in West Bengal have become anti-industry only becos of the left front policies.Only the left front supporters are the one who are shouting in favour of the Tata factory as they were promised by the CPIM goons of jobs. In many rural areas in West Bengal, the CPIM supporters or the ones linked to them, are given jobs and opportunities. Often those who are neutral and do not want indulge in nasty politics and money affairs are deprived and discriminated. West Bengal has been long written off as stinking backyard of India because of this Left Front.Just one Tata Nano factory will not change the fate of the state. Look at the infrastructure in West Bengal and Kolkata.Look at the abondoned factories which were closed down due to CPIM- CITU activities in Kolkata and West Bengal. Why is the so-called 'resurgent' CPIM/Left Front not trying to improve and revive those. I do not admire or support Mamta Banerjee as politicians always think about their own interest not the people's one. But the mess in West Bengal may only be removed when the Left Front is thrown out of the state and the state gives itself sometime to setlle down till it again starts to walk in the path of progress contructively.
Huge Tax sops and soft loan at (.1%, how much our farmers pay for agri. loan?) are for what? There would be maximum 1000 jobs as the plant needs to be highly automated to keep the cost down. So the question is why so much of Tax payers money to a Industrialist. any answer?
Re: Modi Give us Jobs
by Sandipan Gupta on Nov 14, 2008 09:35 AM Permalink
The biharis and UP wallahs have been adopted by the Railways ministry, don't you know that ?
Even there is a change of government at the centre, they need not worry, since most of the stations have been taken over by the biharis, right from the vendors within the station campus, up to the station master's job.
Re: Modi Give us Jobs
by Praveen Kumar on Nov 14, 2008 09:40 AM Permalink
Why u guys are against US. Not expected from U Gupta u are UPWala atleast u should not say that. We biharis are more hard working & smarts than all others.
Re: Modi Give us Jobs
by rashmin rao on Nov 14, 2008 09:52 AM Permalink
Sirji, We do not hate Biharis, Only pray that they get rid off their allergy to discipline and civic sense.
Re: Modi Give us Jobs
by ankur ganger on Nov 14, 2008 01:16 PM Permalink
Thats the reason bihar and UP is the most populates state in india with under development status and highest rate of Illiteracy and Crime.
