Discussion Board

MTNL, MKVDC, Mahajan & My Critic


Total 15 messages Pages | 1 | 2   Older >
Dhanishta
MTNL,MKVDC,Mahajan & my critic
by Dhanishta on May 23, 2003 07:25 PM

Excellent contribution. Even I did heard from different sources on this Investments. Remember this is not the first instance, there are several.

Good work.

Thanks

Dhani
Germany

    Forward  |  Report abuse
sharif d rangnekar
paranjoy's article
by sharif d rangnekar on May 12, 2003 10:55 AM

You have an amazingly simple style of writing that leaves one with a clear picture and understanding of what some our most powerful and influential politicians are up to. cheers

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Jayashankaran Unny
MTNL, MKVDC, Mahajan & My Critic
by Jayashankaran Unny on May 10, 2003 02:32 PM

Age of Independant India = 56 years

NO. of people below poverty line(actual figures not the Ministry mockery) = 50% of the population

No. of Journalists(Good+Bad) = 1000's if not lakhs

No. of Critics = Every second Indian has an opinion
about the other Indian and his activities. Unfortunately 90% of Indian's does not have any opininon about India and if anybody expresses it they will vehemently oppose it.

Rule of LAW = Politicians+Goondas+Power brokers
Sadly our judiciary and investigating agencies are OWNED by these people

Result = A parallel economy bigger(howmany times bigger only conjectures) than our Planned/Budgeted/Audited economy




    Forward  |  Report abuse
Kailash
mountain out of the mole
by Kailash on May 10, 2003 12:57 PM


The allegations are bullshit. What is the problem is someone takes an initiative to enable a project which is running short of funds to reach its completion.

The project on completion is going to provide water to million of people as also for agriculture purpose. The water is not for the consumption of Mr Mahajan or Mr Joshi.

And if this transaction is a fraud. Then the revenue earned through operations of railways in Mumbai was deployed for the metro railway project in Kolkatta. Then that transaction should also be called a fraud and investiagated.



    Forward  |  Report abuse
p chandra
And by the way, Yashodharaji,.........
by p chandra on May 10, 2003 12:16 PM

...it was an ordinary journalist, thoroughly and genuinely backed and protected by his bosses (where are such bosses nowadays ?) that brought the mighty out of the Oval Office with swollen eyes begging apology from the American people. The mighty eventually had to fall and evacuate the White House. Of course, we are talking about Richard Nixon and Washington Post. To the best of my knowledge, till the very today, the name of the White House informer remains a mystery. Both that deep voice and the journalist (name cannot be recollected) did a laudable service to their nation. And the most ironical part of the whole affair was that the issue for which Dick had to go was so insignificant from our Indian point of view !! Here Laloos chew away hundreds of crores of rupees and still go scot-free. Of course, Mera Bharat Mahaan !!

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Chris
Y such a negative reaction...??!!
by Chris on May 10, 2003 09:58 AM

Here's a journalist whuz made some real efforts to dig out dirty facts abt corrupt officials. Whether its the truth or not, is for the investigating agencies to decide. Action can be taken against the journo if it's not. It's the goddamn tax-payers money they r playin with & the readers just don't seem to care!
Just chk out the facts presented & then u'll realise y MTNL shouldn't invest. Rules r there for reason, especially the finance-related ones are important - by breaking them almost 250 crores has gone down the drain. And when kickbacks come into the picture..hey, wots new?!!

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Parminder
These politicians should be behind bars
by Parminder on May 09, 2003 08:47 PM

I guesss ppl fail to understand "MTNL is a public sector company" means it is partially owned by Taxpayers of this country. Any investment done by MTNL is our money who pay taxes and if MTNL invests in Business units that are sick its loss of MY MONEY. Ppl of this country are forgetting the ppl who pay taxes should hold bureaucrats and politicians accountable for our hard earned money. I hope now you will understand why it is important to invest wisely as the guidelines say Strictly in Business that have highest credit ratings. If you still do not understand please read "Investment basics for Oxymorons"

    Forward  |  Report abuse
syed abdullah quadri
MTNL/MKVDC/MAHAJAN
by syed abdullah quadri on May 09, 2003 07:36 PM

I do appreciate the good work done by Mr.Paranjoy G.T.But we are a shamless lot,look what happened to the Tehelka's nice work.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Parag
Comment
by Parag on May 09, 2003 07:03 PM

As an insider to a contracting company engaged in works with MKVDC works, I know that there was corruption in getting and issuing all these bonds from long back. The story is entirely true. Also the opinion of the users that MTNL is getting profits from MH is irrelevant as MKVDC serves MH as a whole. Base point is also that many dams constructed by MKVDC have false cost over runs fuelled by contractors and officials greed - in turn funded by taxpayer's money at a higher interest rate.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
praful
Poor stakeholders
by praful on May 09, 2003 06:03 PM

I sympathise with the stakeholders! Its outrageous how the Board of a 'Navratna' PSU took (or rather had to take) such an invt decision. Seems like the Govt needs to set its house in order first before targeting promoters who allegedly misuse funds from their companies.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Total 15 messages Pages: | 1 | 2   Older >
Write a message