It is difficult to dismiss a claim without having knowledge about the same. Gomutra and gobbar are used as ingredient for some ayurvedic medicine. After all both these items have some chemical substances. It is too simplistic to reject when we do not know the factual details
There is no scientific proof that Go mutra caontain any curative compounds. it has same properties just like other ruminants buffaloes, Deer, elephants.
rediff deliberately, picks such useless stuff and publish to Malign majority citizens of India... I have never come across from rediff targeting other religions or making fun.
Re: Yet another useless act by rediff
by Defendtruth on Mar 19, 2020 09:53 AM
It is not USELESS stuff! It is dangerous and bordering on being CRIMINAL BECAUSE IT MISLEADS GULLIBLE PEOPLE. A lot of such potentially damaging shraddha and practices have caused harm and death in the past. After the world-known claim that there was PLASTIC SURGERY in India in transplanting an elephant head on human beings, this goumutra/gobar suggestion is bound to make world wonder about us. So far no scientific research has been done on finding whether gaumutra and gobar are different from other domestic animals and whether what they eat has any effect on their urine and excreta. Perhaps concerned govt. deptts. will look into this seriously and stop damage happening to citizens soonest.
we are brought up in a society with analytical and scientific proofs needed. when science and logic fails or not able to help, then resorting to unconventional methods could help. you cannot think and rule out any chances. it is like Newton sitting under the apple tree. When we have no remedy, nothing wrong in trying it out.
Re: logical or illogical
by daniel thorat on Mar 19, 2020 09:57 AM
Highly illogical because the figures of people recovered in China and all over the world prove that science and clean, undamaged logic wins over such blind, helpless surrenders.
Re: Oil in nostrils
by daniel thorat on Mar 19, 2020 10:01 AM
Any scientific analysis of both, the mustard oil and the cow ghee to suggest exactly what happens at sub-atomic/particle levels to these substances? What happened to such lines of thinking during the great plagues that attacked humanity in India and all over the world?