To have a perfect India , we need reforms in all levels of decision making . Old systems has to go away . Also must practice restrictions for politicians . Long term plans have to come . Constitution amendmends , IPC amendmends etc are the need of the hour . Government jobs has to be available for public at all levels , no age bar
Ultimately she is the victorious.Her patience of four years efforts brought her the glory. She is an inspiration for the girls of generation to come. A common school girl can make wonders & beat the elites those spending crores as School & college donations & tuition fees.
Re: Nandini
by Gangenahalli gurudutta on Jun 04, 2017 08:52 PM
Firstly I will congratulate Nandini. But I must say, her ambition of seeing India perfect is immatured ones. Civil servants are not the ones who can make country perfect. She should first study why first world countries are perfect and not india. It is highly calibered, highly distinguished professionals who make a country perfect and organized. Wishing her all the best.
Nothing good has been done or is being done by the thick skinned IAS guys. It's high time these money draining posts are scrapped which in fact was a creation of British thugs to serve their selfish ends.
Re: Scrap IAS
by suresh kumar on Jun 02, 2017 08:07 PM
You are wrong. There are so many good officers. But corrupt, uneducated politicians shun them to corners. Recently a young IAS officer cried in public when a minister scolded her in public.
has been achieved by upsc system creating red tapeism and yes boss culture. of course corruption is there to large extent in govt sectors. They so far failed in delivering govt services to the people/poor and development of country. They all make tall claims in interview to serve nation but few keep up. They don't take performance appraisal in service as per hr practices.In true sense professionals in private sectors are best talents. Its my opinion.
Re: Is she from open category OR Reserved Category?
by Sarita Ranjan on Jun 03, 2017 09:13 AM
Good question! Because last year topper Tina took the benefit of belonging to scheduled caste despite of her elite family background.
Re: Re: Is she from open category OR Reserved Category?
by Yashodhan Joshi on Jun 04, 2017 09:11 PM
Instead of the rank what should be displayed marks secured out of the total. We would immediately come to know who belongs to which class, I mean category Open Category OR R-Category
Among Group A services IAS rules the roost.In the pecking order all other services come behind the IAS. IFS ,of course,is a group apart.To be among the top group satisfies one's ego.The idealism and the dream of doing something for the country evaporates when confronted with reality.There are exceptions like Vinod Rai.But the majority follow the path of least resistance and toe the line of political bosses.
Re: BEING A TOP BUREAUCRAT SATISFIES ONE'S EGO
by suresh kumar on Jun 02, 2017 08:18 PM
Please do not generalise. Mr. Sree Ram (MBBS, MS, IAS) a topper all along now sub collector in Devikulam (Kerala) is popular than film stars for his daring acts to enforce law of the land. Again the ex- Kozhikode District Collector Mr. Prasanth Nair, IAS who was fondly called as Collector Bro.. Ms. T V Anupama IAS who was food safety commissioner... there are many more..they are all swimming against the tide.
Another IRS Seat Lost. I personally think that persons already in Civil Services should not be allowed to take up UPSC again because its a huge loss for the country and it's exchequer. And I suppose an no one understands it better than an IRS Officer. If one wants to serve the country they can serve in any capacity. Being a UPSC topper is nothing short of individual ambition glorified and it has hardly anything to do with serving the country. If serving the country would have been a priority, one should have been conscientious and should not have appeared in the first place.
Re: Another IRS Seat Lost
by Anand A on Jun 02, 2017 03:09 PM
You are right, but theere is A difference, while all other central services indeed serve the country, revenue, forests, rail, etc etc and evn the scientific services like depts of space, atomic energy, agriculture etc etc, the real DIFFERENTIATION is the BROAD scope that "IAS" "with gen administration and more power for financial transaction etc and direct delivery of services etc it offers, is indeed a notch above the rest of the services. Rest as you mention, aspirations and scientific/technical/financial inclinations are different for different ppl. So a scientific guy or a finance wiz may not be interested in gen admin. BUT all said and done as of today, IAS rules, from top to bottom. BTW, the IRS post that she vacated will be filled up next time, so no worries there. The actual worry should be if an IITan/MBBS changes his track, then there is a definite loss of seat/money spent on education.
Re: Re: Another IRS Seat Lost
by biswajit maji on Jun 04, 2017 01:00 PM
Even there is loss here - of years of training in premier institutes like NADT and NACEN. Who will make up for that - it's the tax payers like you and me.
Re: Another IRS Seat Lost
by Anand A on Jun 02, 2017 03:09 PM
You are right, but theere is A difference, while all other central services indeed serve the country, revenue, forests, rail, etc etc and evn the scientific services like depts of space, atomic energy, agriculture etc etc, the real DIFFERENTIATION is the BROAD scope that "IAS" "with gen administration and more power for financial transaction etc and direct delivery of services etc it offers, is indeed a notch above the rest of the services. Rest as you mention, aspirations and scientific/technical/financial inclinations are different for different ppl. So a scientific guy or a finance wiz may not be interested in gen admin. BUT all said and done as of today, IAS rules, from top to bottom. BTW, the IRS post that she vacated will be filled up next time, so no worries there. The actual worry should be if an IITan/MBBS changes his track, then there is a definite loss of seat/money spent on education.
Re: Another IRS Seat Lost
by Anand A on Jun 02, 2017 03:09 PM
You are right, but theere is A difference, while all other central services indeed serve the country, revenue, forests, rail, etc etc and evn the scientific services like depts of space, atomic energy, agriculture etc etc, the real DIFFERENTIATION is the BROAD scope that "IAS" "with gen administration and more power for financial transaction etc and direct delivery of services etc it offers, is indeed a notch above the rest of the services. Rest as you mention, aspirations and scientific/technical/financial inclinations are different for different ppl. So a scientific guy or a finance wiz may not be interested in gen admin. BUT all said and done as of today, IAS rules, from top to bottom. BTW, the IRS post that she vacated will be filled up next time, so no worries there. The actual worry should be if an IITan/MBBS changes his track, then there is a definite loss of seat/money spent on education.
Re: Another IRS Seat Lost
by Anand A on Jun 02, 2017 03:09 PM
You are right, but theere is A difference, while all other central services indeed serve the country, revenue, forests, rail, etc etc and evn the scientific services like depts of space, atomic energy, agriculture etc etc, the real DIFFERENTIATION is the BROAD scope that "IAS" "with gen administration and more power for financial transaction etc and direct delivery of services etc it offers, is indeed a notch above the rest of the services. Rest as you mention, aspirations and scientific/technical/financial inclinations are different for different ppl. So a scientific guy or a finance wiz may not be interested in gen admin. BUT all said and done as of today, IAS rules, from top to bottom. BTW, the IRS post that she vacated will be filled up next time, so no worries there. The actual worry should be if an IITan/MBBS changes his track, then there is a definite loss of seat/money spent on education.
Re: Another IRS Seat Lost
by Anand A on Jun 02, 2017 03:09 PM
You are right, but theere is A difference, while all other central services indeed serve the country, revenue, forests, rail, etc etc and evn the scientific services like depts of space, atomic energy, agriculture etc etc, the real DIFFERENTIATION is the BROAD scope that "IAS" "with gen administration and more power for financial transaction etc and direct delivery of services etc it offers, is indeed a notch above the rest of the services. Rest as you mention, aspirations and scientific/technical/financial inclinations are different for different ppl. So a scientific guy or a finance wiz may not be interested in gen admin. BUT all said and done as of today, IAS rules, from top to bottom. BTW, the IRS post that she vacated will be filled up next time, so no worries there. The actual worry should be if an IITan/MBBS changes his track, then there is a definite loss of seat/money spent on education.
Re: Another IRS Seat Lost
by Anand A on Jun 02, 2017 03:09 PM
You are right, but theere is A difference, while all other central services indeed serve the country, revenue, forests, rail, etc etc and evn the scientific services like depts of space, atomic energy, agriculture etc etc, the real DIFFERENTIATION is the BROAD scope that "IAS" "with gen administration and more power for financial transaction etc and direct delivery of services etc it offers, is indeed a notch above the rest of the services. Rest as you mention, aspirations and scientific/technical/financial inclinations are different for different ppl. So a scientific guy or a finance wiz may not be interested in gen admin. BUT all said and done as of today, IAS rules, from top to bottom. BTW, the IRS post that she vacated will be filled up next time, so no worries there. The actual worry should be if an IITan/MBBS changes his track, then there is a definite loss of seat/money spent on education.
Re: Another IRS Seat Lost
by Anand A on Jun 02, 2017 03:09 PM
You are right, but theere is A difference, while all other central services indeed serve the country, revenue, forests, rail, etc etc and evn the scientific services like depts of space, atomic energy, agriculture etc etc, the real DIFFERENTIATION is the BROAD scope that "IAS" "with gen administration and more power for financial transaction etc and direct delivery of services etc it offers, is indeed a notch above the rest of the services. Rest as you mention, aspirations and scientific/technical/financial inclinations are different for different ppl. So a scientific guy or a finance wiz may not be interested in gen admin. BUT all said and done as of today, IAS rules, from top to bottom. BTW, the IRS post that she vacated will be filled up next time, so no worries there. The actual worry should be if an IITan/MBBS changes his track, then there is a definite loss of seat/money spent on education.
Re: Another IRS Seat Lost
by Anand A on Jun 02, 2017 03:09 PM
You are right, but theere is A difference, while all other central services indeed serve the country, revenue, forests, rail, etc etc and evn the scientific services like depts of space, atomic energy, agriculture etc etc, the real DIFFERENTIATION is the BROAD scope that "IAS" "with gen administration and more power for financial transaction etc and direct delivery of services etc it offers, is indeed a notch above the rest of the services. Rest as you mention, aspirations and scientific/technical/financial inclinations are different for different ppl. So a scientific guy or a finance wiz may not be interested in gen admin. BUT all said and done as of today, IAS rules, from top to bottom. BTW, the IRS post that she vacated will be filled up next time, so no worries there. The actual worry should be if an IITan/MBBS changes his track, then there is a definite loss of seat/money spent on education.
Re: Another IRS Seat Lost
by Anand A on Jun 02, 2017 03:09 PM
You are right, but theere is A difference, while all other central services indeed serve the country, revenue, forests, rail, etc etc and evn the scientific services like depts of space, atomic energy, agriculture etc etc, the real DIFFERENTIATION is the BROAD scope that "IAS" "with gen administration and more power for financial transaction etc and direct delivery of services etc it offers, is indeed a notch above the rest of the services. Rest as you mention, aspirations and scientific/technical/financial inclinations are different for different ppl. So a scientific guy or a finance wiz may not be interested in gen admin. BUT all said and done as of today, IAS rules, from top to bottom. BTW, the IRS post that she vacated will be filled up next time, so no worries there. The actual worry should be if an IITan/MBBS changes his track, then there is a definite loss of seat/money spent on education.
Re: Another IRS Seat Lost
by Anand A on Jun 02, 2017 03:09 PM
You are right, but theere is A difference, while all other central services indeed serve the country, revenue, forests, rail, etc etc and evn the scientific services like depts of space, atomic energy, agriculture etc etc, the real DIFFERENTIATION is the BROAD scope that "IAS" "with gen administration and more power for financial transaction etc and direct delivery of services etc it offers, is indeed a notch above the rest of the services. Rest as you mention, aspirations and scientific/technical/financial inclinations are different for different ppl. So a scientific guy or a finance wiz may not be interested in gen admin. BUT all said and done as of today, IAS rules, from top to bottom. BTW, the IRS post that she vacated will be filled up next time, so no worries there. The actual worry should be if an IITan/MBBS changes his track, then there is a definite loss of seat/money spent on education.
Re: Re: Another IRS Seat Lost
by Anand A on Jun 02, 2017 04:40 PM
Rediff, Pls set right the software bug in the discussion board, how does my reply show up here 10 times!!!!! something crazy happening.
Another IRS Seat Lost. I personally think that persons already in Civil Services should not be allowed to take up UPSC again because its a huge loss for the country and it's exchequer. And I suppose an no one understands it better than an IRS Officer. If one wants to serve the country they can serve in any capacity. Being a UPSC topper is nothing short of individual ambition glorified and it has hardly anything to do with serving the country. If serving the country would have been a priority, one should have been conscientious and should not have appeared in the first place.
