Our educational development is not of our own since Independence. Why should we change over night when western Institutes hiring our own people with our money and becoming the Entrepreneurial s in our country.
NO ONE CAN BUY MANAGEMENT FROM EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTE , ITS CREATE ON JOB , THE SYLLABUS OF MANAGEMENT IS THE COMPILATION OF EXPERIENCED SOME ONES WHO WERE TREATED AS NON EDUCATED
as a matter of fact , no good thing has come of age in india. The only thing that has come of age and rightly so is "CORRUPTION"... india can surely be proud of it!!
the problem is a lot of courses and plethora of seats is de valuing almost all the courses including engineering..but now a days a lot of openings are there and needs to be said that if you aspire enough,you will make it
Yesterday on the news i learnt that one of the MBA grads started his own coconut water selling business under some brand....i could not stop laughing.......
In olden days we use to find BSc, Bcom, BA's doing the same like jobs....becuase there were no other jobs
All these MBA colleges are making the MBA degree a must for the indian students by tying up with corporates....poor indian parents have to pay their hard earned money now for 2 more years post graduation.
Re: News...
by Allinone on Apr 06, 2011 05:06 PM
Idiotic statement. He is Selling coconut water with a difference...with branding and all. And his MBA must have helped.
Re: News...
by Story editor on Apr 07, 2011 02:54 PM
You laughed because you are grossly ignorant. Branding indian food like paratha, dosa and drinks like lime juice, cocunit water is very important.
Re: Re: MBA is all GAS and little SUBSTANCE
by A P on Apr 07, 2011 01:37 AM
doesn't mean that the person above was not able to pass the entrance exam... on the other hand u seem to be an idiot...
Re: Re: MBA is all GAS and little SUBSTANCE
by Satyapriya Simha on Apr 07, 2011 06:29 AM
I couldn't get through the front door, someone else got through the back door and i was denied the ticket:)
There is very less rigour and very little effort and achievement in the area of research. Do our management institutes and Management Universities practice what they preach, the answer is 'NO'. Hence, there is a huge disconnect between 'Management Education' and the 'Practice of Management'. This is also one of the reasons, why management graduates struggle to establish themselves in the West into Management roles. They are forced to learn the hard way. Anyways. it is just waste of time discussing this issue. Management Institutions are not going to change. Management Education is nothing but glorifies 'M.Com' in India. One may wonder why should a course like M.Com exist. Happens only India.
Re: Management Education in India is a scam !!
by sq kazmi on Apr 06, 2011 07:27 PM
I agree. My take is that top ranking institutes act as channels for the corporate world to recruit people with high IQ, EQ and language skill. If they are directly hired after getting selected in top business schools, they will probably be as effective or may be even more effective than they are after completing 3 more years of GAS study. Rest of the institutions who do not merit such influx of candidates with high IQ, EQ and language skills, are essentially worthless.
Re: Management Education in India is a scam !!
by zxcvbnm on Apr 07, 2011 06:18 AM
M com is about accountancy and taxation. Accountancy is not just adding and subtracting. You will not get salary on time if good accountants are not there. Your organization would not survive if cash inflow is not matched with outflows. You have to be better than your competitions. Can you calculate the accounting cost of everything happens with an organization. say loss of customers. If an organization performs properly consumers will gain society will gain.
In sum I would say can you take 100% correct decisions...or even 70%. Suppose organizations starts taking good decisions westing little resources, what will happen to the society. We all are dependent on management for our better life and it is the most important thing we learn. Management is not just about MBA....mahabarat..ramayan...kuran...constitution of india ...all are about management....world is mucm much more complex than you perceive...there are mountains to concure.... we hvae to get the order of heaven.... people indeed indeed are very confusd about management education ...including teachers..who do not want to move beyond story telling as they are not good for anything...inefficient criminals...and idiot students who feel that MBA means bossing, boasting and cheating and they become a spacial creatures in the world.
There is very less rigour and very little effort and achievement in the area of research. Do our management institutes and Management Universities practice what they preach, the answer is 'NO'. Hence, there is a huge disconnect between 'Management Education' and the 'Practice of Management'. This is also one of the reasons, why management graduates struggle to establish themselves in the West into Management roles. They are forced to learn the hard way. Anyways. it is just waste of time discussing this issue. Management Institutions are not going to change. Management Education is nothing but glorifies 'M.Com' in India. One may wonder why should a course like M.Com exist. Happens only India.
Re: Management Education in India is a scam !!
by sanjay kulshrestha on Apr 07, 2011 12:11 PM
you are too much correct 1. coaching centre are catching money for preparation 2. institution are finding the way to catch money 3.student are catching money from family . 4.profeestionals are cathing money from organisation 5.only few non proffesionals are working 6.proffestianls are trying to enjoy their work 3.
