Mahasweta Devi is comparing Gandhiji with Mamta? Why does not she joins TMC instead of claimimg neutral which is really ridiculous. I don't know how dare she claims herself as an intellectual? She is really pseudo-intellectual.
Re: Mahasweta Devi the pseudo-intellectual.
by Bhaskar Nandi on May 15, 2009 02:41 PM
Please dont make such comments against figures like Mahasweta Devi. You may not agree to her comments . Let people express their own views.
Re: Re: Mahasweta Devi the pseudo-intellectual.
by Happy on May 15, 2009 02:46 PM
She is a great writer that does not mean that she knows everything and she has right to say anything.
Re: Re: Re: Mahasweta Devi the pseudo-intellectual.
by Bhaskar Nandi on May 15, 2009 02:55 PM
It does not even mean that she knows nothing. Me & u know everything. But is is better for all of us to use correct words against figures like Devi. "How Dare" is not the correct way. And advising her to join TMC is uncalled for. We dont expect Subodh Sarkar or Soumitra Chattopadhyay to join CPIM even if they support leftists.Dont u think so?
Re: Re: Re: Re: Mahasweta Devi the pseudo-intellectual.
by JS on May 15, 2009 03:52 PM
Mahasweta Devi is an aged lady she lost her metal balance.We don't want to see pre 1977.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Mahasweta Devi the pseudo-intellectual.
by Happy on May 15, 2009 03:19 PM
Mr.Nandi Subodh Sarkar or Soumitra Chattopadhyay and many other express everywhere that they support Left Front,their position is not hidden.Likely we expect that Mahasweta Devi/Suvaprasanna first declare that they stand for TMC.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Mahasweta Devi the pseudo-intellectual.
by Bhaskar Nandi on May 15, 2009 04:22 PM
No I dont consider Soumitra Chatterjee or Subodh Sarkar or PC Sorcar as an politician even if they support the left.Specifically Suvaprasana & Bratya Basu has openly supported TMC. No one can be neutral. Kaushik Sen has asked for change in scenario but has not supported TMC. Lets respect their views. But this question was never asked all this years when most of these intellectuals had supported the left. So why today?
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Mahasweta Devi the pseudo-intellectual.
by Bhaskar Nandi on May 15, 2009 03:40 PM
Both of them has already declared that. In what more mean words do you expect them to declare it.But they may not join TMC.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Mahasweta Devi the pseudo-intellectual.
by Happy on May 15, 2009 03:59 PM
You are not right Mr.Nandi and when an intellectual stand for any politics we will consider them as a politician and they should not act like a hypocrite,instead they are saying we r neutral-we want change and conducting meeting with the help of TMC party office.What is this?
Re: Mahasweta Devi the pseudo-intellectual.
by rudra mondal on May 15, 2009 02:36 PM
Who the hail are you to decide whether she is intellectual or not? Have you gone through any of her book. But I do not support her statement regarding Mamata and Gandhiji. But your comment creates a lot of doubt about your culture.
Re: Re: Mahasweta Devi the pseudo-intellectual.
by Happy on May 15, 2009 02:44 PM
If someone compare Mamta with Gandhiji then,sorry to say,I think he/she has lost is mind-stability.
Re: Re: Re: Mahasweta Devi the pseudo-intellectual.
by Bhaskar Nandi on May 15, 2009 02:59 PM
Let the old lady live with her views yaar. Does it matter to us? We know the difference between Gandhiji & Mamta ji quite well. So why loose respect on such figures?
All theories are fine. But, the Practical situation will be totally different. Mamta and Left will not be seen together, DMK and AIADMK will not be seen together, JD (U) and RJD/LJP will not be together, etc. Yet, the media says that the Congress has an edge.
Re: Literate fools
by Ganesh Raam on May 15, 2009 02:47 PM
Carrot's wife is the sister of Prannoy roy's wife. So he will say all lies and at the end will support congress. If congress has the guts, they should sit in the opposition, shaow their real courage in not accepting the Left's support.but they wont do so, b cos of the NRI( Non resident Italian). she's afraid that if BJP comes to power they will definitely get details of money stashed in Swiss bank, and most of the depositers will be "con"gress men and women with NRI's name in the first.somehow they want to cling to power.
Re: why people attack her personally?
by somnath bhowmick on May 15, 2009 02:21 PM
Where is she getting so much money from? take a look at her expenditure during this election...
Re: Re: why people attack her personally?
by Bhaskar Nandi on May 15, 2009 02:28 PM
Thats for the election commission to check out. Leftists dont spend less too
Re: why people attack her personally?
by amitava misra on May 15, 2009 02:53 PM
I don't think so ..and i think most of the conscious people will agree that....she has got the most illusive personality...For the sake of power she is even ready to have an understanding with the Maoist.. moreover her party TMC is the most uncultured and unruly party besides full of criminals...if some day she got the power then her real face will be exposed...
Re: why people attack her personally?
by somen chatterjee on May 15, 2009 03:13 PM
Do you know she put herself as a Doctorate Degree Holder by Producing Fake East Geogia University Certificate ? As a minister of Central Government she is doing nothing for Bengal .Man made Flood wad a eternal remarks when people of Bengal faces devastated flood .
Re: why people attack her personally?
by Happy on May 15, 2009 02:19 PM
corruption free? who?Mamta? Try to get some inf. By the way make it clear I am not leftist. But please don't describe Mamta as corruption free otherwise defination of honesty will be changed.
Re: Re: why people attack her personally?
by Bhaskar Nandi on May 15, 2009 02:29 PM
Why dont u tell us. We are here to know from you. Believe me , I dont know of any corruption issues against her.
Re: Re: Re: why people attack her personally?
by Happy on May 15, 2009 02:38 PM
If you really want to know please take a look at her expenditure during this election.
Re: Re: Re: why people attack her personally?
by somnath bhowmick on May 15, 2009 02:39 PM
Buddhadeb, Biman, Karat, Yechuri..and all top brass of CPM don't have any corruption issues associated with them also...So, what;s the big deal?
Re: Re: Re: why people attack her personally?
by Happy on May 15, 2009 02:36 PM
Mr.Nandi hope right now you are in kolkata.Please go to Kalighat area and try to listen voice of common ppl. And I hope you know the matter of Ward No. 74
Re: Re: Re: Re: why people attack her personally?
by Bhaskar Nandi on May 15, 2009 02:46 PM
Dear Sir, such Tehelka cases are not new in India. In fact as far as i remember . Mamtaji had resigned from cabinet after Tehelka. By the way I thought u were talking on corruption by Mamata Banerjee herself is it not? And I am a common man yaar not a TMC activist but my voice dosent say she is corrupt.
Re: Re: Re: why people attack her personally?
by somnath bhowmick on May 15, 2009 02:41 PM
Buddhadeb, Biman, Karat, Yechuri..and all top brass of CPM don't have any corruption issues associated with them also...So, what;s the big deal?
Re: why people attack her personally?
by abhishek on May 15, 2009 02:26 PM
who told u she is corruption free?????? her party is matching left in all kind of campaigning. where is the money coming from? TATA motor's competitors. Can't u see simple facts.
Re: Re: why people attack her personally?
by Bhaskar Nandi on May 15, 2009 02:31 PM
So Tata Motors pays for the leftists spendings ? R u asking us to believe that too?
Re: Re: Re: why people attack her personally?
by supriyo haldar on May 15, 2009 02:48 PM
what evere you said...tell me why the corruption lover,party office maker LEFT is afraid of MAMATA....because she is fire....nad it is war between DEVI vs DEMON...
Re: Re: why people attack her personally?
by aroop kushary on May 15, 2009 02:42 PM
That's abs right. In fact she & her goons are so corrupt that in her every photo or cut-out, she has to put a label on her front & back -- 'symbol of honesty' -- to remind herself what she is-- ridiculous!!!
Re: Re: Re: why people attack her personally?
by Bhaskar Nandi on May 15, 2009 03:10 PM
Agreed 100% . Her party dosent have leaders like Binoy Kongar , Shayamal Chakraborty or Subhas Chakraborty who has a holy god like figure in front of general people like us. And such blemish free personalities like Mr. Buddhadev Dasgupta who orders to open fire against common rural mass HA HA HA
Re: Re: Re: Re: why people attack her personally?
by somen chatterjee on May 15, 2009 03:18 PM
Who is Buddhadeb dasgupta order for for fire ? Now your mask is open, idiot.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: why people attack her personally?
by Happy on May 15, 2009 04:17 PM
Mr.Nandi firing was not against common ppl it was against those person who cut the road and made nandigram as free zone even after repeated declaration that land will not be taken in Nandigran.Tell me one thing when top of the Administration declared that land will not be taken then what's the requirement of "BHUMIRAKHSA COMMITTEE".What's the reason of supporting MAOIST.For power everything is right?And all those so called neutral intell. when CPI(M) supporter killed they said well else very bad.Why? CPI(M) supporters are not human being? And that great self declared honest lady-Can you tell me what about her East Geogia University Certificate of Doctorate.Have you any answer? If you want you can support TMC but do not misrepresent knowing everything.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: why people attack her personally?
by Bhaskar Nandi on May 15, 2009 04:42 PM
Formal & official Land acquisition notice was issued by govt of west bengal before all this happened. Maoists had come out openly only due to lack of governance by WB Govt. Why dont the govt stop the operations of CPIML etc etc by declaring them illegal. It was done against SIMI a few years ago. So why not against the maoists? The Bhumi Uched... group was formed by many people including TMC activists , Sidiqullah Chowdhury , common leftist man also who had feared loosing their land. It is such instances which promote extraleftists like Maoism. Killing of all man is condemnable be it TMC be it Left. But such issues should not rise in the first place.It was wrong for the left govt to issue land acquisition notice at the indulgance of Laksman Seth who is facing the heat now. I know the full details so I dont misinterprete & I have never asked you to support TMC nor the Left. But when we write something it is better that we know the whole story behind it and not one sided view. What I have written above has been acknowledged by the CM himself when he expressed his anguish & mourning and agreed that it was a wrong step. Regarding the doctorate degree , I am not Mamata's secretary so u may ask Mamata itself. But that does not make her a bad person in my eyes nor a corrupt leader
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: why people attack her personally?
by Happy on May 15, 2009 04:13 PM
Mr.Nandi firing was not against common ppl it was against those persong who cut the road and made nandigram as free zone even after repeated declaration that land will not be taken in Nandigran.Tell me one thing when top of the Administration declared that land will not be taken then what's the requirement of "BHUMIRAKHSA COMMITTEE".What's the reason of supporting MAOIST.For power everything is right?And all those so called neutral intell. when CPI(M) supporter killed they said well else very bad.Why? CPI(M) supporters are not human being? And that great self declared honest lady-Can you tell me what about her East Geogia University Certificate of Doctorate.Have you any answer? If you want you can support TMC but do not misrepresent knowing everything.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: why people attack her personally?
by Bhaskar Nandi on May 15, 2009 03:46 PM
Please mind your language yaar. its a simple mistake from my side . not dasgupta but bhattacharya.and whos wearing mask??????? CM himself agreed to his mistake. SOOOOO?????
WEST BENGAL: Left always goes towards congress and mamata banerjee no way but has to go to NDA ANDHRA PRADESH; TDP cannot support Congress has to go to NDA. Since they have a chance to come back into power in AP they need centre support. Congress doesn't support if it is in power so TDP has to back NDA. TAMILNADU. Chances of both alliance having 50-50 (20 seats each to DMK and ADMK). Both cannot be in one alliance any one could support NDA.
Re: Re: DRAMA HAS BEGUN..........
by aravinth perumalsamy on May 15, 2009 02:04 PM
Haha good joke all u people either NDA or UPA supporters play with numbers which is not confirmed. Which ever government comes it is goign to be a relection in a year
Mamta Banerjee is only fighting for her self....her main goal is to become the CM of West Bengal and for that she can do anything....she can say to Mr. Ratan Tata that 'you are not required here', she can shift between BJP and INC several times..she can be so sympathetic to farmers...she can be so sympathetic to the petrol auto puller....she can be very much concerned about pollution...In one words to gain cheap popularity and of course the chair of CM she is trying to pull back the state....After 16th there will certainly be some sort of understanding between the left and the congress and she will be kicked out of the equation...SHE DESERVE IT....
Re: ITS BETTER IF SHE STAYS AWAY FROM BENGAL
by ayan mitra on May 15, 2009 02:04 PM
at least she is better than facist left front led by mr.buddhadev bhattacharya in west bengal.
Re: ITS BETTER IF SHE STAYS AWAY FROM BENGAL
by Auli Mazumdar on May 15, 2009 01:59 PM
She is not Mamata, but 'Kshamata' (power) banerjee...always after power.
Re: Re: ITS BETTER IF SHE STAYS AWAY FROM BENGAL
by Bhaskar Nandi on May 15, 2009 02:14 PM
Request you to please set your foot on ground before u discuss such issues. Ever been to any rural area and spoken to the people? Leftists had joined hands with both BJP (1988) & the Cong (last 5 yrs). Indian politics is not so easy my friend. You may not support Mamata's ideology but please dont call her power hungry because she is the one and only politician in India today who can resign from ministry when Tehelka corruption issues were raised. I myself respect left ideology and the way older leftists led their life. Even today Biman babu lives in a commune in Allimuddin. It is indeed admirable. But the leftists have moved away from their ideology today. Lets accept that truth
Re: Re: Re: ITS BETTER IF SHE STAYS AWAY FROM BENGAL
by amitava misra on May 15, 2009 03:06 PM
Mr. Nandi i am very much sure of my thoughts...she is a power hungry women...look inside her party...she never allow any leader to come up front..frequently she changes her right hand..tell me honestly how many times she visited Singur after the TATA's pull out...she was there not to help the unwilling farmer to get back their land but to gain a political platform from that issue...and about visiting of rural area ...i personally spoken to some peoples from Singur...now they have started considering her as a big CHEATER......
Re: Re: ITS BETTER IF SHE STAYS AWAY FROM BENGAL
by abhishek sengupta on May 15, 2009 02:08 PM
I guess Mr. ayan mitra should know the difference between fascism & communism.
Madam mamta (i dont know why the name chosen?) always seems to be indulged in politics of hate. For many years she even couln't stand the site of the 'hand' and she spoke badly against it. Now she has grabbed that same hand for mutual benefits and survival. She hates left from within for her fiery speeches and also acts failed to woo voters for all these years and her dream of becoming youngest women CM of WB turned sour. She now hates herself that even at the age of 90 she cannot become the CM. Where is the question of her standing and or going? no one in fact trust the woman. She lost whatever small political name she had after what she did with the Tata's nano. Such people need to be bycotted by all political partise and also voters!
GOEBBELS TRUTH IS WHAT LENIN FOLLOWED- SAY A LIE A HUNDRED TIMES AND IT BECOMES TRUTH
LENIN SAID - ONE MAN WITH A GUN CAN CONTROL 100 BUT THAT TIME THE AK47 WAS NOT INVENTED - NOW THE AK-47 USED BY CPIM CADRES IN NANDIGRAM TRIED TO CONTROL THE LAKHS WHO WERRE ERSTWHILE CPM SUPPORTERS.
THE INTELLIGENTSIA HAVE GONE AGAINST THE CPIM AND THAT HAS BEEN A GREAT BON FOR HER.
THE POOR FARMERS THINK THEY HAVE ONLY ONE SAVIOUR IN MAMATA
THE CPM CADRES WHO HAVE NPOT GOT THE LARGER PART OF THE PIE THAT THE TOP LEADERS HAVE TAKEN AWAY ARE NOW WITH THE TMC
MAY BE WE CAN SEE A MAJORITY OF SEATS WITH MAMATA AS RIGGING WAS STOPPED IN MANY CONSTITUENCIES. SHE HAS LEFT ALLIES IN HER PARTY AND THIS HAS HELPED HER TO BECOME MORE SUBDUED AND CUNNING
GOD HELP THE CPIM TOMORROW
MY PREDICTION
1.14 TO LEFT FROMT 2.28 TO OTHERS WITH MAMATA NEAR THE 19 MARK KOL [N] , KOL[S[, DIAMOND HARBOUR, MATHURAPUR, JADAVPUR, BARASAT, BASHIRHAT,, ULUBERIA, HOWRAH, CONTAI, TAMLUK, BIRBHUM, ARE SOME OF THE SEATS THAT SHE MAY WIN
