Nuclear deal is there to dump radioactive waste into India, Nuclear will give jobs to foreign countries greater then our own. Nuclear deal is about propaganda, and subjecting India's nuclear establishment to inspections. Nuclear deal means no foreign liabilities for failure of nuclear plant, nuclear deal means fraud when we have plenty of uranium, the nuclear deal mean cutting funds for development of our own nuclear program. Nuclear deal means inspections without any commitment of any material of nuclear.
Re: Re: Well they are just children, Don't remember Bhopal
by Govind Lal on Apr 22, 2009 07:40 PM
Amrit Please read my posts under 'No downturn for India's nuclear power plan' 22.1.09 rediff.
Please see the contentious issues in the Hyde act 1. No freedom to handle spent fuel. 2. No guarantee for alternate fuel supply 3. India is not a technology developer but a recepient. 4. India to side with US in NPT 5. India to participate with US National Security Administration for NPT. 6. Reporting of US President on the efforts of India in containing IRAN. 7. India denied space related dual use technology 8. India denied strategic planning of nuclear programms. 9. Stopped India in the production of fissile materials. 10.No joint move for universal nuclear disarmament. 11.All future agreeents are to be in consistent with this act. Hyde act is the enabling act for the 123 agreement. Please come back with doubt if any.
Re: Re: Well they are just children, Don't remember Bhopal
by Happy Indian on Apr 21, 2009 07:22 PM
Amrit Singh are you the daughter of Dr. Manmohan singh. Anyway the deal is good for our country in my opinion
Re: Re: Re: Well they are just children, Don't remember Bhopal
by Govind Lal on Apr 29, 2009 09:06 AM
Read my postings under 'No downturn for India's nuclear power plan' 22.1.09 rediff.
Please comment on my postings. Hope you are Indian even now. Do you still keep the same view?
1. Growth rate=original 3.5 % but in media it is approx. 7 % even WMF slams MMS for misquiding whole world.
2. infrastructure growth by march -2.5%, Agriculture growth -3.5 (negative grwoth in these sector ensure us debt trap). Theseare nevr discussed in indian media.
3. India by april 2009 loses 1.5 crore jobs (many more to go) and media projecting how india is better than rest of the economy.
4. Being importer economy sinking of rupee will cost us dearly. If recession is global why internal travelling getting costlier than international. Obviously our economy doesn't follow global trend.
5. If infaltion is around zero then why food prizes are 25 % high, by any calculation inflation can not be zero, then who is cooking data??.
Congress wins india loses. And, so are we indians.
Re: Re: propaganda.
by Amrit Singh on Apr 21, 2009 06:52 PM
Probably found the figures in Communist propaganda/manifesto. She is not an economist for sure.
Again they did it. After long discussion in parliament and nation. when BJP was trying to make fool Indian people by saying "This Indo-US deal is not good We will cancel it or we will renegotiate".
Now Advani said they will continue it, now He feels there is nothing wrong in it. Why they oppose this deal that time?? Now what he is trying to say?? Why they create drama that time??
Re: Another U turn by Advani and BJP...
by neelam on Apr 21, 2009 12:52 PM
Nuclear fuel has to be supplied by Developed countries like france denmark etc. To buy the nuclear fuel US will give debt to india at very high interest rate. The full process may take onother 5-10 years, even if it works properly it will provide only 4% of the electricity requirement. Question remains: 1.Why MMS was so much in a hurry that he has to buy votes to finalize it. He never floored it to parliament? 2. Why we should be in debt trap of US like pakistan. Not only that we can not run our nuclear programm as usual. That too for 5 % of electricity requrement???
3. developd countries can blackmail india for thier gain.
3. Who has got job so far???? I have a dought. because not even first instalment have been released.
4. Adwani nevr said what you quote, do not msiguiede people of India.
If India doesn't you are also a looser do not forget it. Jai hind!
Re: Re: Another U turn by Advani and BJP...
by Amrit Singh on Apr 21, 2009 06:49 PM
Why will India borrow money to buy nuclear fuel? India has fourth largest foreign exchange reserve in the world.
Re: Re: Another U turn by Advani and BJP...
by Neeraj Srivastava on Apr 21, 2009 03:55 PM
Gr8 to see a sanghi's reply. who never accept truth of their leaders. Manmohan was in hurry because Bush was also interested to complete it and India can not take risk to ignore this opportunity which makes India to join Nuclear club with out sign CTBT.
Its not matter of electricity only It was also related to our Nuclear programs..
If you are ready to blackmail then only any one can do that act..
==>3. Who has got job so far???? hahahhahahahahhahahahhahaa.. what a joke ... I have no answer of ur question
go and read speeches of Advani and others of that time...
Re: Another U turn by Advani and BJP...
by Amrit Singh on Apr 21, 2009 06:48 PM
India has not bought anything from USA related to nuclear deal. India has only reached agreement with France for delivery of nuclear power plants.
How India will end in debt trap because of nuclear deal?
Re: Re: Another U turn by Advani and BJP...
by Govind Lal on Apr 29, 2009 09:10 AM
Mr.Amrit Singh Please read my postings to know how India is being trapped in debt. 'No downturn for India's nuclear power plan' 22.1.09 rediff. Come back with your comments
Re: Let 200000 Tamils be killed by Congress Snoia and Mahishan
by Vivek Chandra on Apr 21, 2009 12:32 PM
But Tamils want a separate state in Sri Lanka. Srilankan govt is ready to offer some autonomy but some extremists have cast our a net of rosy dreams to general tamil population of northern Srilanka. Listen to Jaffna brahmins and dont be a victim of unrealistic dreams. Jaffna brahmins are pure and they should lead your way.
I think only these 4 fools are assured of jobs b'coz of nuclear deal...I pity their innocence...Now I know how cong have been fooling ppl for 60 years and continue to foo these innocents...
Re: India is democracy and NOT meritocracy.
by Sanjay on Apr 21, 2009 01:27 PM
Shameless person being OBC is not a qualification.Please when you get educated and look at your coolie caste system and ask why you are not a doctor, or laywer, or professor, or some mathematician, why not MBA or because most have not qualified for such a coolie caste. Now why do engineers do only engineering, or should we try to get some others qualified because they happen be from some other field.
The Same why did Manu who sons were not all Brahman, not qualify all his sons Brahman when he was born brahmin? See one must be qualified to call oneself Brahmin, as even the common labor has so many division in modern caste system weather, the plumber,electrician, skilled or unskilled labor. So without the education how to you make a post and deny the fact that people must qualify to be a caste.mprrk
How they will get job?When they will get job?when work will start on these power plants?It is wishful thinking only.Only benefit will go to Machinary supplier,Contractors,Babus &politicians only.JaiHo
Please do not post articles which are so shamelessly propagandized. Do you still claim to be the fourth pillar of democracy? Which democracy are you advocating for? How long would you lick Sonia's feet? When would your greedy stomach will get rid of its hunger?
Sometimes, you make me and I am sure, thousands similar souls in this nation to cry.
I am helpless. We are helpless. We are entrapped by a monster. And our media is Jaichand.
Re: Rediff please don't show your shameless greed
by neelam on Apr 21, 2009 12:55 PM
Nuclear fuel has to be supplied by Developed countries like france denmark etc. To buy the nuclear fuel US will give debt to india at very high interest rate. The full process may take onother 5-10 years, even if it works properly it will provide only 4% of the electricity requirement. Question remains: 1.Why MMS was so much in a hurry that he has to buy votes to finalize it. He never floored it to parliament? 2. Why we should be in debt trap of US like pakistan. Not only that we can not run our nuclear programm as usual. That too for 5 % of electricity requrement???
3. developd countries can blackmail india for thier gain.
3. Who has got job so far???? I have a dought. because not even first instalment have been released.
And Cong government could not leverage any benefit for the country upon signing it. N-deal was never a compulsion to a billion's nation. India could dictate a better deal against it.
But alas, India is still viewed as just a friend, while Pakistan is still perceived as ally.
When will India learn to dictate its own terms? Learn from China if your soul is too timid Mr. MMS. Learn to speak. Learn to join the league in stead of just bowing down.
You wold probably get some uranium imports benefits at considerable cost, but at the cost of what?
I know Mr. MMS, you are a 'door-mat' for Sonia. But where is your conscience? Would you be a 'door-mat' to US as well? And then tomorrow for China too? And who knows to whom next?
In spite of repeated request to amend some clauses of it, why is not US ready to make a single line of alteration? And why you are not in a position to stick to your position? In spite of such an inevitable market for US, when would you start giving your own terms?
Shame on you Mr. MMS. Shame on you Sonia. Who do not bother about country's future, how can we trust you?
If you still have a minutest shame, please step down and never show your a$$ again. Else, you know the results. You are already dead.
Re: N-Deal has its good sides but worse more
by Superman on Apr 21, 2009 10:38 AM
What communists were asking for was worse than we have got....They wanted to disrupt everything because China did not want India to sign it.... BJP had a logic....more power and everything...but when they were in power they would do this treaty in a much softer tone.... Sonia Gandhi's birthplace may be in Italy.....but 3/4th families of every BJP leader stays in the US.... Their future do not lie in India...
Re: Re: N-Deal has its good sides but worse more
by akchatte on Apr 21, 2009 10:42 AM
Now, this is a serious allegation, that I would ask for proofs. 3/4th family? means more than half of a family? I do not see any of the senior BJP leaders in this bucket. I am sorry.
Re: Re: Re: N-Deal has its good sides but worse more
by akchatte on Apr 21, 2009 10:44 AM
And if you mean someone's son went to US for studies, so are Congis too. So are many of Indian proletariat.
Re: We need nuclear feul
by ranjith on Apr 21, 2009 11:56 AM
ofcourse we will sign CTBT, but not before pakistan is fallen to our hands, we secure Kashmir, and we recapture our area from china. then CTBT no probs
