Looking back History tells us team batting 2nd will be under severe pressure. selection of team also bad. umesh and dinesh karthik shd have been played for Ashwin and Nair. If Captain does not listen to Coach appears to have been casual for final and deliberately no efforts win. Had they won everybody would have asked Kumble to stay. it was a strategy to eliminate Kumble.
The news of Kumble seeking pay revision and Kohli also supporting the same has suddenly disappeared. How conveniently BCCI created conditions to dump Kumble and Kohli also made look like a villain. The most interesting is no news agency is asking the question also.
This whole dispute between Kumble and Kohli is being given undue importance to hide the misdeeds of former BCCI heads who still want to exercise their power but cant because there is Supreme Court appointed committee. These former heads want the members of Supreme Court appointed committee to resign one by one, taking the blame for lack of performance of the cricket team in the upcoming tours of the Indian team. These old bosses have made some players (current and former) party/ beneficiaries to their 'dealings'. Mr. Guha (part of SC appointed committee) already has resigned citing some reasons,some others also will resign. Both Kumble and CAC members played it safe by taking the actions that they have. India may see better coaches, but anymore a former player with 'honest' reputation will think twice before becoming India's coach.
star Power is not new and neither it is completely wrong.earlier we had super stars like Sunil Gavaskar, Sachin Tendulkar, sahwag etc. in this generation we have Virat Kohli.Then with whom should we side with?If Kohli is sacked then will Kumble play in his place?As the answer is in negative we must support the present star and not Coach.We had coach like Greg Chappel who completely destroyed the team of the day and finished the career of player like Irfan Pathan.In coach we require a sublime personality like Kersten and not dominating person like Kumble.This lack of communication too must have been cause of this humiliating defeat in the Champion cup.
That Players have overgrown their stature is nothing new. This had happened earlier too when Greg Chappell was the coach of Team India. Player-coach discord might have had a long history. Only reason it is coming to light these days is overenthusiastic media. Kumble is a good coach and a balanced personality no doubt and Kohli a good player and an excellent human being. it is unfortunate they couldn't walk together..!
Supreme court should entered on this and kohali should be send to tihaad for 1 month in view of deliberately loosing final with intention of not making kumble as most successful coach unable to grant automatically extension of further 3 years
Re: Re: Who stopped communication, no doubt arrogant kohali
by roger phillips on Jun 22, 2017 11:33 AM
Totally agree with you. Arrogance was the downfall in the finals.
Kohli is an exceptionally very good consistent player but not a leader to lead the indian team. Dhoni and yuvraj should not wait to sack them from bcci instead should take voluntary retirement
Re: sack virat as captain and voluntary retirement to dhoni &
by BHARAT MEHER on Jun 22, 2017 10:41 AM
I am totally with Kohli on this.In cricket captain is more imp than coach,It is not football where strategy is there.Also it is Kohli and his team which has given India laurels.You are all asumimg that it is Kumble who has given India laurels.Kumble has a role as a coach .definitely.But actual work done on foeld by Kohli and company.
Re: Re: sack virat as captain and voluntary retirement to dhoni &
by rajaganesan swaminathan on Jun 22, 2017 11:01 AM
can you take the captain post I will recommend for the post
Re: Re: Re: sack virat as captain and voluntary retirement to dho
by rajaganesan swaminathan on Jun 22, 2017 11:03 AM
are you prepared and I shall recommend to the board
Problem lies with superstar status of i dividuals. A coach generally has dispassionate views on final 11 and strategy for the match which a captain may feel encroaching in his area. In the final of Champions trophy or even the semi final India was found short of one pace attack. 3 genuine pace attack and 2 spinners who can bat well like jadeja and ashwin is the right balanced wining combination. Including one extra batsman like kedar jedhav is hardly useful. Any can fill the part timer role- like yuvraj,dhoni or even Kohli. So why sacrifice an useful pace spearhead like Umesh or Mohd. Sami. One cannot expect bhubhuneswar kumar or jaspreet to be immaculate and grab the wickets of openers in all the matches.
Re: Winning strategy
by BHARAT MEHER on Jun 22, 2017 10:43 AM
I am totally with Kohli on this.In cricket captain is more imp than coach,It is not football where strategy is there.Also it is Kohli and his team which has given India laurels.You are all asumimg that it is Kumble who has given India laurels.Kumble has a role as a coach .definitely.But actual work done on foeld by Kohli and company.what is this superstar thing.It is a simple thing.Kumble is interferring with Kohlis work.He is entering in his domain.
Carrying such heavy egos both!?? Virat is not doing any good to his job carrying such ego!! It certainly affects performance! His anger ego temper are shoe stoppers!