Mr.Vaughan is too critical of Cook's captaincy. In Indian pitches you should have patience in batting as well as in bowling specially in spin dept. As far as Cook is concerned, he is such an exceptional player of spin as well as fast. Probably in this series, he is not in form. We cannot rule him out just because he did not perform in one or two series; that too in sub-continental pitches. At least, if not captain, he can be retained as a batsman in the team.