Re: 'Dhoni is negative. He doesn't have too many ideas'
by Syz on Aug 30, 2014 08:15 PM
One day trophy does not prove any skill. It is the test match victory that proves. None of the players of the current team is a real test player. They should not play test match, they are only good for one-day.
I am not a admirer of Dhoni .About captaincy - I have no comments - ultimately performance is measured by results - like a students performance by marks , individual games the winnings ,or trophies won . In cricket I think it is more how many games you win in foreign countries - home advantage is too much exploited so it is winning in enemies den which is more important .dhoni is pathetically poor in this aspect .One day games or 20-20 really is no cricket as luck has a role to play . Worst I see is when his fans and admirers say there is no one to take the responsibility - how many of the past captains come ? How early smith -SA was made captain and I think he has done very good job . Try even an under 19 captain or A team captain he can not give worse results than Dhoni .It is not like show me the person I will tell what he should be - it is better to try new things and fail rather than not try at all
I am not a admirer of Dhoni .About captaincy - I have no comments - ultimately performance is measured by results - like a students performance by marks , individual games the winnings ,or trophies won . In cricket I think it is more how many games you win in foreign countries - home advantage is too much exploited so it is winning in enemies den which is more important .dhoni is pathetically poor in this aspect .One day games or 20-20 really is no cricket as luck has a role to play . Worst I see is when his fans and admirers say there is no one to take the responsibility - how many of the past captains come ? How early smith -SA was made captain and I think he has done very good job . Try even an under 19 captain or A team captain he can not give worse results than Dhoni .It is not like show me the person I will tell what he should be - it is better to try new things and fail rather than not try at all
How can Mr bikash prove that Dhoni is negative?.If he is negative... who is positive?.Don't write off about Dhoni.Total team failed in all departments and you are blaming Dhoni who done well in the series.Now the matter is remove Dhoni as captain and tell us who will be next?Why are u discourage our team writing differently. His career tells how positive he is
it's immature to say so. Captain alone is never to be blamed for defeat. As victory is possible only out of team work so does defeat. Dhoni has given excellent performances in the past when he had better players.
Re: Dhoni
by vijay das on Aug 27, 2014 09:34 AM
Its is important that a good relation is maintained among the team. I feel MSD could not do that the same ever.
Re: Re: Dhoni
by Sheetal Kaur on Aug 29, 2014 05:43 AM
It was Dhoni who brought home the world Cup, or have you got a memory of a gold fish. Did that happen with out winning vijay das.