Discussion Board

Binny celebrates India call up as Karnataka take lead over Delhi


Total 5 messages Pages | 1
Pakhal Vato
Ranji trophy is meaningless
by Pakhal Vato on Jan 01, 2014 02:43 PM  | Hide replies

Binny-Match-6,run-321,Avg-40.12,Wkt-11. Son of selector R.Binny.This year 1 fifty and 1 century.
Shukla-Match-7,Run-491,Avg-54.55,Wkt-6. Last year bet all rounder declared by BCCI. This year 2 fifty and 2 century.
Aron-Match-6.Wkt-20,Avg-29.95. Player from Jharkhand. Selector Saba Karim also from Jharkhand.
Dinda-Match-7,Wkt-29Avg-25.62. Career averages of both Shukla and Binny are almost same. Dinda’s career average is better than Aron. In 1999 Shukla was selected in team India but he was rejected after only 3 matches. There are so many big names who are initially included in the team matches after matches without performance. If IPL performance was considered then Binny should be in T20 team only.
Clearly performance is not quality. Only genetic relation and provincial relation is the quality.
I am sure there will be so many players from other states whose performance are better than Binny and Aron. Cricket lovers will agree with me. It is meaningless to perform in Ranji trophy to get a call in Team India.


    Forward  |  Report abuse
Pakhal Vato
Re: Ranji trophy is meaningless
by Pakhal Vato on Jan 01, 2014 03:27 PM
Also why there is Iswar Pandey(30 wkts this year) in the team and why did not R.Dhawan(49 wkts. this year) or JJ Bumrah (38 wkts this year), or Pankaj Singh(36 wkts this year), or Anureet Singh(35 wkts this year).

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Pakhal Vato
Re: Re: Ranji trophy is meaningless
by Pakhal Vato on Jan 01, 2014 03:39 PM
In case of including Binny as a all rounder performance of Pervez Rasool is much better than Binny this year, 515 runs and 14 wkts.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
hari ray
Quota Players Selected
by hari ray on Jan 01, 2014 07:24 AM  | Hide replies

Stuart Binny is selected because Roger Binny is a selector
Varun Aron is selected because he is from Jharkhand

Ishant Sharma and Rohit Sharma with rank bad performance in SA are selected for NZ team because they have Dhoni's blessings.

In the last tour to SA, India won a test where VVS scored a 96 in 2nd innings and Bhajji took 4 wkts. Ishant was in that team taking just 1 wicket in each innings. He is a great survivor. Poor selection and nepotism is a main reason why Dhoni lost 10 tests abroad and will continue losing.

Ambati Rayadu should have been given chance ahead of Rohit

    Forward  |  Report abuse
srikanth gota
Re: Quota Players Selected
by srikanth gota on Jan 01, 2014 11:19 AM
Don't say Stuart Binny got selected because of Roger Binny he is performed really well for Karnataka as well as for Rajsthan Royal over the year, even this year also performing well with bat and bowl that reason why he got selected.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Total 5 messages Pages: | 1
Write a message