Without changing the existing LBW rules, if the review system is put in place, the test matches will be over is 2 days. Today, the number of reviews are limited. But tomorrow someone may say why limit the no of reviews. let every decision be reviewed.
So the decision to introduce DRS will also involve change in LBW rules.
Re: there will be drastic changes
by S Shrikanth on Jun 27, 2011 05:29 PM
LBW is the decision which is completely dependent on the Umpire. If LBW decision is not challenged and Hawk Eye is not used to trace the trajectory of the ball, the umpire may take it for granted.
If BCCI is so scared of reviewing LBW decisions because Sachin Tendulkar does not like it, then it should propose to abolish LBW itself so that Mr Tendulkar is never out as LBW.
Re: Re: there will be drastic changes
by Varun on Jun 27, 2011 06:06 PM
Yeah right. Said with the assumption that haweye is perfect with the prediction. Honestly BCCI seems sensible wrt technology. India was not convinced with the prediction wrt spin.
note this, when ever you are voting for congress, you are directly voting on a isslum religious symbol the 'hand of fathima ( google it)', ther by directly supporting izslumisation of india and indirectly supporting terror attacks and bomb blasts!!
Re: Re: Re: O' voter fools of india!! note this, when ever you
by Chengiiz Khan on Jun 27, 2011 05:31 PM
and you too want to be a big (hutiya it seems mathew :)
Re: Re: Re: Re: O' voter fools of india!! note this, when ever
by zac mathew on Jun 27, 2011 05:36 PM
You are as original as you are foolish,Khan! You could have atleast come up with your won word if you are trying to be funny!
Re: O' voter fools of india!! note this, when ever you are vot
by zac mathew on Jun 27, 2011 05:18 PM
what's that got to do with cricket and UDRS? MORON!
Re: Re: O' voter fools of india!! note this, when ever you are
by Chengiiz Khan on Jun 27, 2011 05:21 PM
mathew .. i know u will be irritated with facts!!
Re: Re: Re: O' voter fools of india!! note this, when ever you
by zac mathew on Jun 27, 2011 05:23 PM
Do you have any facts on UDRS or cricket, Mr. Khan? I'll be glad to hear them.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: O' voter fools of india!! note this, when
by zac mathew on Jun 27, 2011 05:28 PM
are you anti cricket? as far as i can see this page is about cricket.
Good that UDRS is accepted by BCCI of course without the not- so 100% accurate Hawk eye.But hope balls pitched outside the leg stump in deciding LBWs could be checked by the UDRS? If not it would be again hopeless when on so many occasions batsmen are adjudged LBW with deliveries pitching outside the leg stump and on occasions when batsmen are hit outside the off stump.
Re: BCCI Vs UDRS
by Rabri Devi on Jun 27, 2011 05:02 PM
Good point. Hawk eye can be used for the leg stump line. For judging the height and line of impact, leave it to the umpire. Other features should take care of edges or bat-pad decisions.
Re: ICC is working under the thumb of BCCI....
by sakar panch on Jun 27, 2011 04:57 PM
might is right. The Americans have clearly shown the path. Why not?
Re: ICC is working under the thumb of BCCI....
by mk seshadri on Jun 27, 2011 04:57 PM
I fully endorse your views.It is stupid to use DRS for other forms of appeal in which the errors are minimal.BCCI has gone crazy and technically challenged
