Why PV for sachin why these people are degrading this nations such ahigh civilian award sachin did nothing for the society and nation he is not at all deserved to be honoured with PV there are so many veteran athelitics and sportsman and women completely forgot and ignored by the political establishment this incident clearly indicate his proximity with selfish politicians
RE:Why PV for 10du
by eternity on May 06, 2008 12:47 PM
You seems to be very ignorant...Few suggestions for you, atleat devote an hours time for reading news paper...Try to get hold on some GK books..... if you cant afford then go to crossword and read free of cost.
After gaining substancial knowledge, you can come to this forum.....
anybody should be judged not by the no. of runs scored, but the no. of matches won...Sachin fails in this regard....But his conduct has been impeccable and nobody can doubt it...
RE:hi
by pranay shingi on May 06, 2008 02:05 PM
Who scored in finals in australia recently, who scored in 1996 World Cup, Who scored in 2003 World Cup? who scored in england? You hopeless gyus will never appreciate is efforts.. You are seek. First check the records and then speak.
RE:hi
by Priyadarshan on May 06, 2008 12:33 PM
if only conduct is the reason for this honour then there are so many others whos conduct is unquestionable why only sachin ????
RE:hi
by Vimal Kamdar on May 06, 2008 12:37 PM
Unfortunately, you/me are NOT the decider of the awards!!! Do you which other sportperson is been given the award? in this year and past few years from other sports? No...that does make 'news", does it?
RE:hi
by nihant on May 06, 2008 01:20 PM
its not just the conduct...if u havent herd he has 40 centuries in 2 formats of da game.. if u think dats ordinary..ur lame
RE:hi
by joydip bhattacharya on May 06, 2008 02:24 PM
Tell me one individual with so much success and money and close to GOd in the country is away form all controversies for so many years..........
RE:hi
by Vimal Kamdar on May 06, 2008 12:33 PM
Cricket is a team game, so therefore Sachins' runs are added to the 'team' total, right? Now How would you judge Brian Lara? In that regards, Steve Waugh must be having the distinction of making his team win on most occassions with his own batting. What about Viv Richards? how many his batting has won? or lost, like the WC 83 - was Viv NOT to blamed for that bad shot and the team losing the cup? Therefore, it is NOT possible to read into this fact - how many matches one has won. Definitely if you pick two players who have won matches contributing greatly to Indian test cricket - they would be Rahul Dravid and Anil Kumble. But then Rahul needed some other batsman to be with him - throughout or Kumble needed some other bowler to support him from other end and fielders to catch the catches! Let Sachin enjoy his moment, Let us be happy, rather than 'judging' him. Please, ?
Sachin is without doubt the greatest of all Indians alive..including our scientists,other sportsman,politicians etc. No doubt , abdul kalam n Gandhi family were gr8, but did they face the sort of daily pressure and expectations that sachin face. And other sportspeople like paes,sania fades when u compare sachins achievements. Basically, consistent achievements under pressure seperates the gods from men, and here sachin scores over all other Indians Sachin..the Greatest batsman to ever play the game! A hero and a living legend
RE:The greatest Indian alive!
by Priyadarshan on May 06, 2008 12:31 PM
you are a mentally ill person go and take treatment for it SOTP POSTING SUCH CRAPS others are not fools like you dude
RE:The greatest Indian alive!
by mani nookala on May 06, 2008 01:31 PM
I think ur mentally ill..so just shut up..u knw nothing about a person's greatness like sachin..he is without doubt the greatest indian alive..
RE:The greatest Indian alive!
by joydip bhattacharya on May 06, 2008 02:28 PM
One reason why I respect him becuase so many times he as given ne a pure happines....lot of laugh by his share batting.......Nothing/No one can be compare with this ....he brings smile in my face when he scores run.....that is wht he has doen to the nation for so many years .....Looking to see him receiving "Bharat Ratna"
RE:RE:Lage Raho Sachin
by badri narayanan on May 06, 2008 03:55 PM
You need some treatment, some people like you don't like others success and happiness.
Sachin is the greatest living legend India has ever produced, all world knows that. Please don't reply for this message I don't even want to discuss things with you kind of mentally ill guys.
Sachin set here an example for youngsters how to be a great performer and human being .The so called slegding or slapping fellow players or crying on field will not fetch you place .Performance for years ........will Do that .
RE:Proud of you Sachin....!
by prasad on May 06, 2008 05:36 AM
u r correct he has advised to youngsters that whether u r successful r not u should be be sincere this was the advice given by his father to him and sachin has passed on this to us.
RE:Proud of you Sachin....!
by Pahadi Chuha on May 06, 2008 09:13 AM
Now every other bengali says to me give Dada Padma Vibhushan...or every the Nobel Prize!!
well i am not an fan of sachin butafter looks like everybody is just jealous of him arre yaar he is the only person who is preforming well in aus and recently !!!!! i dont think he cant give anybody anything else other then profermance !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
RE:oh boy everyody is jealous of Sachin !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
by Kashlee on May 06, 2008 01:20 AM
The thing is stop treating him as something special....treat him like another sports star such as ganguly or dravid or sania or anand....he is not don bradman....he is made to be like that and he has to bear the burden....dont expect too many things from him because he is not extra ordinary....he is a great player....good technique but he is prone to same mistakes that the so called lesser mortals such as a dravid or ganguly can make....he plays when conditions are favorable or he really wants to play given his physical and mental state at that particular point.....he is not the medicine for all ills.....dont treat himi like god....then everything will look normal....why no one makes a fuss when dravid or leander gets a national award?????
RE:oh boy everyody is jealous of Sachin !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
by vimalan sadhasivam on May 06, 2008 05:47 AM
obviously you don't know anything about the game comparing Sachin with mortals like Dravid, Ganguly..haha..i don't treat him as god but there is no denying the fact that he is one of the greatest ever probably second only to the Don
RE:oh boy everyody is jealous of Sachin !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
by rajeev dash on May 06, 2008 12:10 PM
your knowledge about cricket is so little.Otherwise you wont have compared Sachin with a dravid or ganguly(Although they are also great platyers).
But sachin special.
He is like Pete Sampras in tennis and Tiger wood in golg.
What a surprise he is able to walk and get the award...I am sure he is preparing for one more tour to AUS and getting ready to play till 2015 WCUP now that he has got this award as well...
The guy is super smart that he knows how to prolong his career,he skipped the Test against SAF to make it appear like hes going to play in 20-20s(which isnt his favorite format cause he dont have 50 overs to score his century and also cant slow down when he reaches 50or 100 nor can he hit sixes like most players are doing) and then gets injured to avoid the olympic torch controversy and sits out 20-20 to play for coming test series or odi or whatever and then will sit part of that out and this way he can play for 10 more years or prolly for ever....
But i am not complaining cause since 2000 ive been following Cricket like WWF as the match fixers are still there and just by banning Azhar we let go other culprits so whatever result who cares..
RE:I thought he was injured
by Sandeep on May 06, 2008 09:53 AM
I don't think anybody can question his integrity, last 18 yrs he is playing for country always keep in minding team and not his personal mile stone, averybody who his play with him and against him, they will accept he his perfect team man, secondly player like him who is having variety of strokes will be sucessful in t20 also, if player like Sangakara is sucessful than why not Sachin Tendulkar,
RE:I thought he was injured
by Raman on May 06, 2008 09:49 PM
Like shane warnes ball of the century,Sachins so called Integrity and not thinking about his personal milestone is the joke of the century,probably joke of 20th century and 21st century... I am sure u guys want us to criticize him more and more and that is why u r talking this way so that we come up with more points against this so called legend who never scored a century when he came 4th down or never score fast the moment he approaches a milestone and fail like clockwork under crunch situations,who can forget his failures in WCUPs under pressure and not to mention that legendary choke against PAK when all it needed was 14 runs to win,the guy didnt even come to pick up the prize as he was crying in the dressing room...so called legend....CHOKER and selfish player,not to mention Desh Drohi to beg for exemption for taxes for his ferrari,i am sure his greed for money wouldve made him a accomplise in match fixing as well.
RE:I thought he was injured
by kabira speaking on May 06, 2008 12:15 PM
tendulkar.... integrity.... keeping team in mind....... never thinks abt his personal milestone..... hahahahahha..... wat a joke.... lol
RE:I thought he was injured
by Dire Straits on May 06, 2008 01:55 AM
Yeah, sure ... the guy is super smart. But funny that somehow this guy is rated by all ex as well as current players, dead or alive as the best batsman of his era. Sir Donald Bradman, Sir Vivian Richards, Sir Garfield Sobers, Brian Lara, Shane Warne, Allan Donald, Wasim Akram, WISDEN, etc all consider him to be the best. Really confusing !! It's also funny that nobody have ever rated MR. Rosgulla as the best of his era. Don't know why !! Also confusing that Sir Doanld Bradman was somehow mesmerized by Tendulkar, and in the process openly declared him as the best he have seen. I wonder why dosen't MR. Rosgulla ever gets such honor.
RE:I thought he was injured
by True Indian on May 06, 2008 12:21 PM
Mr. Raman, probably you are correct because you are the only expert who knows what kind of person is Sachin 10dulkar and other including Sir Donald Bradman, Sir Vivian Richards, Sir Garfield Sobers, Brian Lara, Shane Warne, Allan Donald, Wasim Akram, WISDEN, Ponting, Imran, etc all consider him to be the best are fool.
Sachin has the tendency to skip the matches telecast on channels other than on ESPN-STARSPORTS. Sachin skips the matches due to so-called injuries especially when the same are shown on SET MAX. That is the reason for him not playing IPL so far. Sachin plays for the sponsors lobby. Even during the World Cup 2007 in West Indies, it was the same story as telecast right holders were Set Max. So he played poor cricket to avoid India's progress in the next round. He skipped Sri Lanka series (SL rights are with SET MAX?). He is against SET MAX channels or against all the rival channels of ESPN-STAR with whom he has an understanding.
You can recall many instances of his non-availability and its connection between the channels holding telecast rights.
RE:Sachin plays for the sponsors.
by Anuj jadon on May 06, 2008 10:10 AM
How can u say that the injuries was "so called".Are u doctor.U can not question sachin's commitment.Remember 1996 world cup when his father was no more during world cup.Sachin's father was his inspiration.It was great loss to him.But after cremation he returned to England to play match against Kenya and scored a ton.This event shows his commitment and love for country.My advice is to Mr. SRT is to to write meaningful and logical things only.Do not hurt the feelings of carors of fans across the globe.
RE:Sachin plays for the sponsors.
by SRT on May 06, 2008 11:44 AM
Agreed Anuj. Even before the breaking of fixing scandal, there were many who were big fans of Azhar, Jadeja, etc. and they could not think anything adverse against their heroes, but they were shaken by the scandal. I know there many Sachin fans, even I do not Sachin like others, but it is a coincidence - shocking which can not be denied.
RE:Sachin plays for the sponsors.
by Hemlata Verma on May 06, 2008 11:08 AM
you r out of ur mind..get some treatment mr intelligent..hahahhahaha brain dead moron.
RE:Sachin plays for the sponsors.
by spindoc on May 06, 2008 12:17 AM
stupidity is the refugee of the idiots..I can understand u r not a fan of his but to come up with this..moron
RE:Sachin plays for the sponsors.
by rajeev dash on May 06, 2008 12:13 PM
Mr SRT, i am amused that we still have fools and dumbs like you who comment about a subject without knowing anything about it.
RE:Sachin plays for the sponsors.
by bharath bhat on May 06, 2008 12:03 AM
but set max also shown 2003 world cup which was held in south africa where he played and he performed where we reached to the final and he recd man of the series
RE:Sachin plays for the sponsors.
by CricFan01 on May 06, 2008 12:29 AM
Take your ridiculous argument somewhere. It is one thing to be 'not a fan' but another to take it to extreme limits. What about the home series against SA when Sachin played the 1st test and then missed out on the remaining 2? Did Set Max not show the 1st test and started showing 2nd and 3rd tests?
RE:Sachin plays for the sponsors.
by vimalan sadhasivam on May 06, 2008 05:50 AM
i have seen many ridiculous logics but this must be on top of all..you are so funny man
Even the strongest critic of Sachin dont mind but feel GOOD about him getting the PADMA award. If anything else ,as a Human Being he is well admired all over and it has got nothing to do with sports. Any sports loving person has got all the rights to critisize anyone including Sachin but that does not mean he/she doesnt love him.
RE:Let Sports be Sports
by Salil on May 05, 2008 11:08 PM
... all sports personalities have tried to waive off their taxes whenever they got cars which were gifted to them...
