Everybody can accept human errors as every body makes it but if somebody does not want to learn from that error then it is a fault and if somebody makes same fault every time then is well known that it is being done intentionally and therefore not acceptable. These are the things which both umpire went on doing from Day 1 and finished with India losing the test. Especially, Bucknor has been doing against India all the time; this cannot be a simple human error and should be judged by ICC. Asking Ponting%u2019s decision on dismissal of Ganguly shows the mentality and mindset of umpires%u2019. It would not be wrong to tell that umpires were with Aussies. No Indian umpires are in Elite Panel of ICC and ICC gives a reason that Indian Umpiring is not of top class so, how these umpires could remain in Elite Panel of ICC. ICC could not behave in two ways. ICC a supreme in Cricket should maintain its high standards for betterment of cricket and should not work partially.
ICC and BCCI should interfere in this matter. They should talk in several matters to resolve this unwanted situation. 1) ICC should not give its authority to this test match, as it has done in way back in 2001 India%u2019s tour to South Africa. I think Aussies should not have any problem because they tell themselves as world champions so they should not have any problem in going to another match and beat India (IF THEY CAN) 2) ICC should rethink about ban on Harbhajan Singh, as only few of the Aussies are telling that they have heard Harbhajan using racial terms to Andrew Symonds and we all know how much honest they are. So banning on their words is totally unjustified and unacceptable.
If these points are taken by ICC then BCCI should continue its tour of Australia either they should suspend the tour for the pride of India and Indians.
RE:ICC interference is necessary for game of cricket.
by dnyanesh tandel on Jan 07, 2008 03:46 PM
You are absolutely RIGHT. Let winner show they are not winner by FLUCK But by sincer gentalmen's game of CRICKET.
RE:Ausse - Cheeting champions
by dnyanesh tandel on Jan 07, 2008 03:51 PM
CHEETING IS VERY SMALL WORLD FOR AUSSI..
The are pretending to be good player ( Ther shoul be fine for the UMIRES which cost any country a possible VICTORY to defet. BCCI should BAND UMPIRE BUCKNER FOR life time aginst us, as neutral umpire.
Please Make a big issue regarding this. Otherwise no one will respect india in future. Emerge BCCI ti cancel the TOUR.. We should cancel the tour then only this matter will be addressed by ICC. All other Team should support for india.Obviously india have the right reasons..
ICC Agents for Australia? ICC acts like Australian Agent,
Actually All Benefits of doubts goes to Batsman, But here all benefits to goes Australia weather Batsman or Bowler Why others country never get benefits of doubts against Australia
All International Team should join together and fight for Justice,
RE:ICC is Agent of Australia
by dnyanesh tandel on Jan 07, 2008 03:56 PM
GOOD idea, this is big issue & to resolved this there is code of conduct in cricket. but if UMPIRES are not up to their standards why he had givern payment, they are equaly & more responsible , Why 3rd umpire can't inter fire the WRONG DESICION AT The time when it is HAPPENING ... after WIN or LOSS cricket records & game can't be corrected.
Instead of complaining about BCCI in these columns, let us have a letter/email campaign to tell BCCI what the fans think. Does anyone have their postal or email address?
Since the BCCI lack the guts to recall the team in the face of horrible umpiring, everyone should stop watching the game on television. Then the TV people will put pressure on the BCCI. TV pays for BCCI. Once BCCI is hit in the pocket book, they will pay attention. The actions against Harbhajan are atrocious. Australians invented sledging and are proud of it. Why does it become racist Harbhajan replies to them in kind? Andrew S. may be a talented cricketer but he is no sportsman. I for one am boycotting the next two matches.
RE:Boycott the rest of the Australia
by arvin vijay koul on Jan 07, 2008 01:43 PM
i am with you, my dear friend. Australians have crossed the line now. They are the biggest cheaters in the history of the game and BCCI should set an example in front of the entire world by calling off the tour
Its best on the part of BCCI to call back the team and then go ahead with whatever legal procedures they want to follow. Its high time the world considers India as a power to reckon with. ICC just got a taste of what things might be like without India in the worst WC ever 2007. So now the ball is in BBCI's court to support the team and uphold our Integrity and culture.
